US regulatory scrutiny of ‘complex’ ETFs prompts fears of crackdown
Industry figures fear a ‘nanny state’ move to protect retail investors could exclude them from a swath of products
US regulators are scrutinising the sale of a range of exchange traded funds to retail investors, prompting growing concerns in the industry that they are planning a clampdown.
Finra, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, has asked for feedback on sales practices for “complex products” amid a surge in trading by small investors of some relatively complicated vehicles.
“The number of accounts trading in complex products and options has increased significantly in recent years,” Finra said, warning that “investors may not fully understand the attendant risks”.
These risks “may be heightened” still further at a time when retail investors are increasingly accessing these products through self-directed platforms, without the assistance of a financial professional, the regulator added.
However, there are concerns over the lack of a formal definition as to what Finra means by “complex product”.
Finra said it was “a product with features that may make it difficult for a retail investor to understand the essential characteristics of the product and its risks”.
If you chase all of the footnotes and referenced documentation, it’s not hyperbole to suggest that every fund providing anything but plain vanilla beta exposure to stocks and bonds would be included
Dave Nadig, financial futurist at ETF Trends
It gave examples such as defined-outcome ETFs (for example, buffered funds that aim to protect investors from a market sell-off); funds holding cryptocurrency futures; leveraged and inverse exchange traded products; and volatility and oil-linked ETPs.
Deborah Fuhr, founder of ETFGI, a consultancy, said Finra’s definition could include mutual funds and ETFs investing in everything from high-yield bonds and emerging markets to those based on quantitative strategies or environmental, social and governance principles.
“They’ve left it very vague, and I suspect that’s intentional,” Dave Nadig, financial futurist at ETF Trends, said in a video interview with ETFGI.
In his submission to Finra, Nadig said he was “a bit terrified” by the scope of what the regulator may regard as “complex”.
“If you chase all of the footnotes and referenced documentation, it’s not hyperbole to suggest that every fund providing anything but plain vanilla beta exposure to stocks and bonds would be included.
“Anything that’s using derivatives certainly would get caught into the mix,” Nadig added. “Even target-date funds have historically been called complicated by Finra.”
Stacy Fuller, partner at K&L Gates, a Pittsburgh-based law firm, said Finra’s definition of “complex” could even extend to closed-end funds — products so vanilla that the US Congress decided they were appropriate for retail investors as far back as 1940 — as well as “potentially any mutual fund that uses derivatives for hedging”.
Derek Horstmeyer, professor of finance at George Mason University School of Business in Virginia, said: “I think that’s a bad thing when they don’t define complexity,” pointing out that complexity and risk are not always analogous concepts.
Finra declined to comment for this story, but in its request for feedback said it was “concerned” about the risks entailed in complex products’ wider adoption.
The regulator said there were now nearly 150 defined-outcome ETFs with almost $10bn of assets, while leveraged and inverse funds “are often among the most actively traded ETPs”. Similarly, it said, trading volumes for listed options have almost doubled since 2019.
Nadig believed Finra’s move was a “reaction to a legitimate rise of retail interest in investing”, popularised by the Reddit-driven meme stock phenomenon.
“I think that’s a great thing, but because we’ve had some meme stock hysteria and folks looking at leveraging the ability to trade by phones, I think there’s a lot of concern that retail investors aren’t getting enough education,” he added.
Finra is also vague about any restrictions on retail access it might propose.
Among the ideas it is consulting on are the implementation of “enhanced” account approval processes before an investor may trade in complex products; a requirement for an investor to complete training or a learning course, and then pass a “knowledge check” before being allowed to buy certain products; or limiting access to “high net worth” investors.
Derek Horstmeyer, professor of finance at George Mason University School of Business
In its submission to Finra, VanEck Securities said “for over 85 years, the United States securities laws have been predicated on a disclosure-based regime [with potential risks being disclosed and investors left to make their own decisions]. [This] foreshadows a world that upends this bargain.”
“The US system is based on disclosure, as opposed to a nanny state where you are not allowed to own any of these things,” said Fuhr. “It’s a big thing when you think that retail investors have over 30 per cent of the [$7tn] assets in US ETFs.”
Nadig believed that, in moving away from the notion that disclosure can be the core of effective regulation, Finra was sending a “seminal signal . . . almost suggesting that investors can’t make good decisions on their own”.
However, Horstmeyer said the US already limited access to private equity and venture capital funds to “sophisticated” investors, due to their complexity.
As such he “did not see a problem in at least putting something of a speed bump in the way” for some other products.
“We are getting data on how much retail investors have been losing on out-of-the-money options and other complex products,” Horstmeyer added. “They have been taking a lot of excess risk and maybe some of them don’t understand. I would pump the brake on that.”
However, Nadig said that while he was a “staunch advocate for greater financial literacy”, he was “firmly against the idea that my retail broker, increasingly just an app on my smartphone, is going to be the judge and jury on which retail customer is allowed access to which products based on a test that could be as subject to bias, misinterpretation and misapplication as any other standardised test”.
“[ETFs] have driven costs down and increased access for all classes of investors, especially smaller investors and financial advisers,” Nadig added. “Any action taken by regulators should start from a principle of not breaking what isn’t broken.”
After Hours Summary: HLIT +10.5%, CDLX +8.8%, CAR +7.3%, SANM +3.8%, SEDG +2.6% higher on earnings; CHGG -31%, EVER -15.4%, VRNS -10.7%, FN -8.3% lower on earningsAfter Hours Gainers:
Companies trading higher in after hours in reaction to earnings/guidance: HLIT +10.5%, CDLX +8.8%, CAR +7.3%, MPWR +7.1%, VNOM +7%, CC +5.7%, MED +5.6%, OHI +5.3%, NTR +4.3%, VNO +4.1%, SANM +3.8% (also increases buyback authorization by $200 mln), NTB +3.7%, BIGC +3.2%, EXPE +3%, CTRA +2.7%, DVN +2.7% (also raises dividend by 27% and expands share buyback auth), SEDG +2.6%, LEG +2.1%, IPI +1.8%, AGNC +1.6%, NXPI +1.2%, MGM +1.1%, FMC +0.9%, FANG +0.4%, OGS +0.3%, ANET +0.2%, KMT +0.2%, INST +0.2%, OUT +0.1%, WMB +0.1%
Companies trading higher in after hours in reaction to news: ASTS +12.9% (receives experimental license from FCC for BlueWalker 3 satellite testing), GNW +5.4% ($350 mln share repurchase auth), LMDX +5% (stock offering), APTO +1.7% (highlights recent publications of pre-clinical data for luxeptinib), GFS +1.3% (announces $117 mln chip supply agreement with US DoD), MPLX +1% (Whistler Pipeline expansion reaches final investment decision), GLDD +0.4% (awarded large-scale US offshore wind rock installation project), WPC +0.3% (files mixed securities shelf offering), MSA +0.1% (increases dividend), WTS +0.1% (increases dividend), CCL +0.1% (celebrates restart of entirety of Carnival Cruise Line fleet), RYAM +0.1% (sells shares of GreenFirst for $43.3 mln)
After Hours Losers:
Companies trading lower in after hours in reaction to earnings/guidance: CHGG -31%, EVER -15.4%, VRNS -10.7%, FN -8.3%, FRPT -3.5% (also launches $350 mln proposed follow-on offering), MOS -3.5%, FLS -3.1%, CLX -1.7%, CNO -1%, RIG -0.8%, ZI -0.8% (also acquires Comparably), CBT -0.6%, RMBS -0.4%, BXP -0.2%, AMKR -0.1%, BRX -0.1%, QTWO -0.1%, RHP -0.1%, AMRC -0.1%
Companies trading lower in after hours in reaction to news: HAYW -12.2% (stock offering), BG -2.6% (launches renewable fuel feedstocks JV with CVX), CECE -1.3% (files for $150 mln mixed securities shelf offering), FTI -0.1% (awarded addl contract and received notice to proceed by XOM)
Apple Abused Dominance in Mobile-Wallets Markets, According to Preliminary EU View
Antitrust authorities take issue with limits on technology used for contactless payments
European Union antitrust authorities have told Apple Inc. AAPL -3.66% that they have formed a preliminary view that it has abused its dominant position in markets for mobile wallets.
The European Commission said that by limiting technology used for contactless payments with mobile devices in stores, Apple restricts competition in the mobile-wallets market.
The Commission also said it took issue with Apple’s decision to prevent mobile-wallets app developers from accessing the needed hardware and software on its devices to the benefit of its own solution, Apple Pay.
By issuing a statement of objections, the European Commission informs the company in writing of the objections raised against them. It does not prejudge the outcome of the probe.
>>> Up
* Aker BioMarine ASA Raised to Buy at Arctic Securities
* Banca Ifis Raised to Buy at Banca Akros (ESN); PT 22.50 euros (+)
* Lancashire Raised to Add at Numis; PT 505 pence
* Mintra Holding Raised to Buy at Pareto Securities; PT 7 kroner (+)
* SBB Raised to Neutral at Goldman; PT 34 kronor
* Tokmanni Raised to Buy at Nordea; PT 16.50 euros (+)
>>> Down
* Henkel Cut to Hold at Deutsche Bank; PT 75 euros (+)
* Huscompagniet Cut to Hold at Nordea
* Rheinmetall Cut to Neutral as Shares Reflect Benefits: Oddo BHF (+)
* Tal Education ADRs Cut to Market Perform at CICC; PT $4.10
* Tokmanni Cut to Hold at Handelsbanken (+)
* Weyerhaeuser Cut to Market Perform at BMO; PT $42 (+)
>>> Initiation
* Genmab Rated New Market Perform at Cowen; PT 2,554 kroner
* Swedish Logistic Property Rated New Buy at Nordea; PT 38 kronor
>>> Call
* Casino PT Cut at Citi Amid Rallye Safeguard Plan Uncertainty (+)
* Danske Bank Recruits Head of Equity Research Denmark From Nordea (+)
* Genmab Rated New MP at Cowen; Sees Royalty Gains, Few Catalysts (+)
- Hexpol (4QT1 TH) +2%
- Imperial Brands (ITB TH) +1.7%
- Verbund (OEWA TH) +1.4%
- Glencore (8GC TH) +1.4%
- Anglo American (NGLB TH) +1.2%
- Oxford Nanopore (4R0 TH) +1%
- Leonardo (FMNB TH) -2.5%
- HelloFresh (HFG TH) -2.6%
- Ferrovial (UFG TH) -2.6%
- Vestas (VWSB TH) -2.6%
- Vestas Cuts Outlook as Russia Exit Adds to Supply Chain Woes
- Bank of Ireland (BIRG TH) -2.7%
- Telefonica (TNE5 TH) -2.8%
- BBVA (BOY TH) -2.9%
- Sanofi (SNW TH) -3.1%
- Kongsberg (KOZ TH) -3.8%