FT : Benoît Cœuré says regulators likely to agree crypto framework in 2022

Benoît Cœuré says regulators likely to agree crypto framework in 2022
BIS innovation hub chief calls year ‘wake-up’ call for watchdogs, saying consistent regulation is needed

Financial regulators are likely to agree a global framework for crypto next year after the rapid growth of decentralised finance gave them a “wake-up call”, one of the most senior figures in the debate told the Financial Times.

Benoît Cœuré, chief of the Bank for International Settlements’ innovation hub, said conversations about high level global principles for cryptocurrency and decentralised finance had intensified in recent months.

The former European Central Bank governing council member has headed the BIS innovation hub for the past two years, giving him a front-row seat to international deliberations on crypto policy as the world’s central banks use BIS to share information and set global guidelines.

Cœuré, who announced on Thursday had been nominated to lead France’s competition authority, said it “wasn’t necessarily the wrong decision” for regulators to allow the market to develop and to garner an understanding of “how crypto assets work”.

“But now that it is really growing very fast and . . . becoming mainstream in different ways, then certainly the time for consistent regulation has come,” he said in an interview last week.

Cœuré said the new “wake-up call” was decentralised finance — a rapidly growing corner of the cryptocurrency market that uses distributed ledger technology and so-called “smart contracts” to carry out billions of dollars worth of transactions without a central hub like an exchange.

Decentralised finance, or DeFi as it is known, “opens new avenues . . . for interconnectedness with traditional finance which creates potentially new forms of systemic risk” that regulators can no longer ignore, Cœuré said, pointing out that DeFi connected with both stablecoins, widely used as a settlement instrument on DeFi platforms, and traditional finance.

“These [new] services will be competing with traditional finance, and money will flow in and out from one universe to another. This creates a compelling reason to start a discussion on global principles for crypto regulation.”

The pace at which rules are developing in individual jurisdictions is also strengthening the urgency for delivering a global framework. “The risk in 2022 is that large jurisdictions [like] Europe, the UK, the US, China, keep moving on but along different tracks and produce a system which is globally inconsistent,” said Cœuré.

“That’s a risk that should be avoided and there’s still time to avoid it,” he added, pointing out that different approaches would create the opportunity for “regulatory arbitrage” where companies and individuals could game authorities by picking the most advantageous places for their business.

Cœuré said the Financial Stability Board, a global grouping of finance ministries and regulators hosted by BIS, would be the most natural forum to agree a consistent framework and that it was possible for them to do it in 2022, though he cautioned that “we are probably at least two or three years away from having a stable landscape globally” since it will take time for countries to adopt the measures.

He added that the crypto framework could include agreements on categories for different activities and deciding whether a stablecoin — a form of cryptocurrency backed by traditional assets like the dollar — is electronic money, a money-market fund or a security. It should also include guidance so “service providers in these ecosystems and platforms are regulated according to the services they are providing”.

Cœuré favoured “strong consumer protection rules” and “personally wouldn’t mind if pension funds were to be prohibited from investing in crypto . . . it seems to be contrary to the kind of safety that you expect from a pension fund”. 

Still, he conceded that despite the strong case for global co-operation, different countries’ approaches to privacy would limit the scope for a global framework, as would some countries’ reluctance to share details about the technology used in their ecosystems, since the technology used in finance often overlaps with the technology used for other strategic purposes.

“The final decisions of sovereign states will be . . . a balance between sovereign strategic considerations on the one side and considerations about the good functioning of the financial system on the other,” he said. “That’s not new, it’s just that . . . these balances are shifting because technology is so important. The new risk is governments raising technological fences which create fragmentation in the global financial system.”

He also said policymakers were increasingly aware that central bank digital currency “should not be treated as a separate discussion” or allowed to stay in the separate track where it has developed. “We’re seeing the discussion pivoting . . . towards CBDC (central bank digital currency) being . . . a foundational contribution to the new ecosystem,” he said.

“You need central bank money as a safe asset that can be used as a settlement asset to make the new system stable . . . It’s not about CBDC being the sovereign alternative to private money, it’s more about CBDC being the glue that will hold the system together.”

>>> Weekend Papers Summary

Weekend Papers Summary

NEW YORK TIMES
-The New York Times is publishing hundreds of the Pentagon’s confidential assessments of reports (obtained through Freedom of Information requests beginning in March 2017 and subsequent lawsuits filed against the Defense Department and the US Central Command) of civilian casualties resulting from US-led airstrikes in Iraq and Syria. “The documents lay bare how the air war has been marked by deeply flawed intelligence, rushed and often imprecise targeting, and the deaths of thousands of innocent civilians, many of them children.”
-A New York Times investigation found that the American air war in Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan has been plagued by flawed intelligence, poor targeting and thousands of civilian deaths.
-As the pandemic has entered its third year, resurgent thanks to the Omicron variant, experts are urging U.S. adults to get vaccinated and boosted.
Yet among vaccinated Americans, only 30 percent have received a third dose, according to the C.D.C., and the lagging response is worrying health experts.
-Americans on edge as cases rise and the holidays loom. A week from Christmas, nearly 1,300 Americans are dying every day from the coronavirus and more than 120,000 are testing positive.
- Black elected officials, from Congress down to the counties, have been drawn out of their districts or face headwinds to hold onto their seats.
-Democrats’ achievements in 2021 were overshadowed by legislative setbacks, fallout from the Jan. 6 attack and a sense that Congress was not rising to meet a perilous moment in history.
-China’s crackdown has driven most of Hong Kong’s popular pro-democracy candidates either into police custody or exile. Officials are urging the public to vote, but turnout is expected to be low.
-Once a Symbol of US Strength, the Afghan district of Marja faces dire times. Residents are growing desperate for any kind of help, a frustration that has turned to anger that the international community has abandoned them.
-Despite a bid to protect it from a contentious rezoning plan, the Elizabeth Street Garden in SoHo will be replaced by housing units.
-IVF patients are faced with a growing list of costly “add-ons.” For one such test, some say more robust research is needed to support its effectiveness.
-Israel has threatened military action to destroy Iran’s nuclear program if need be. But defense officials say Israel does not have the ability, at least not anytime soon.
-Olympic leaders have criticized China’s handling of the Peng Shuai (the tennis player) case but tried not to say anything that would jeopardize the safety of the American athletes headed to Beijing.
-Authorities in Virginia say that Anthony Robinson, the so-called ‘shopping cart killer’, met his victims via online dating sites and later transported their bodies in shopping carts to dispose of them.

THE FINANCIAL TIMES
The Netherlands has become the first EU country to re-enter a strict nationwide lockdown, in a response to the spread of the Omicron Covid-19 variant that will shutter swaths of the economy until at least mid-January.
-Republican Party operatives in Pennsylvania are betting that another conservative financier, Bridgewater chief executive David McCormick, will be able to walk a similar political tightrope to win the state’s US Senate race next year.
-With the labor market the tightest in four decades and worker availability expected to determine the success or failure of deliveries this season, Amazon has taken the initiative with bonuses of £1,000 to attract staff and increase its Christmas workforce to about 75,000 people this year, leaping from less than a third of Royal Mail’s peak headcount before the pandemic to almost half the size.
-A stunning by-election loss follows a series of crises that have damaged UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s claim to be a political winner. As a result Johnson was put on probation by Conservative MPs with warnings he could face a coup by mid-2022 unless he raises his game.
-Russia has published a set of stringent demands it is making of the US and NATO, which would end all prospect of Ukraine or any more former Soviet states joining the transatlantic alliance and rewrite many of the principles upholding European security since the end of the cold war.
-Ghislaine Maxwell declined to testify on Friday as her lawyers wrapped up her defense on criminal sex trafficking charges after two days. “Your honor, the government has not proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt, and so there is no need for me to testify,” Maxwell, 59, said on Friday afternoon, after Judge Alison Nathan offered her the standard opportunity to take the stand to testify in her own defense.
-Russia has published a set of stringent demands it is making of the US and NATO, which would end all prospect of Ukraine or any more former Soviet states joining the transatlantic alliance and rewrite many of the principles upholding European security since the end of the cold war.
-The Federal Reserve could raise interest rates as early as March in the face of “alarmingly high inflation”, according to a senior US central bank official.
-Turkey’s main stock exchange halted trading on Friday after the country’s currency crisis, already stinging bonds, spread to equities. Borsa Istanbul announced a temporary so-called circuit breaker after its main Bist 100 index fell 5 per cent. After trading resumed, the benchmark was more than 8 per cent lower.
-Blackstone is close to acquiring a stake in one of New York’s newest office towers, in a deal that would value the 70-storey skyscraper at $2.85B and signal confidence that the crisis-hit city will remain the nexus of corporate America. Built on the eve of the pandemic, One Manhattan West abuts the giant Hudson Yards redevelopment and has sweeping views of the Hudson River.
-Thierry Breton, the EU internal markets commissioner has complained that US commerce secretary Gina Raimondo is campaigning on behalf of Big Tech, days after the EU approved a common position on draft rules aimed at curbing the power of large American tech companies, fueling a transatlantic tit-for-tat among senior officials.

THE NEW YORK POST
-Harvard University will go remote again in January due to the spread of the Omicron variant: “Please know that we do not take this step lightly,” university president Lawrence Bacow wrote in a memo to students and staff. “Public health experts anticipate the increase in COVID-19 cases to continue, driven by the Omicron variant, which we have now confirmed is already present in our campus community.”
-The national unemployment rate has dropped to a low 4.3%, but the percentage of working-age adults with jobs or looking for jobs hasn’t reached pre-pandemic levels, meaning millions have dropped out of the workforce. In 2019, the participation rate was close to 63.5% — it’s now 61.8%.
-Peloton chief executive John Foley has quietly snatched up a $55 million estate in East Hampton — even as employees of the exercise-bike company fret about their futures as its stock price tanks, The Post has learned.
-Boeing suspended its coronavirus vaccination requirement for US based employees, capping weeks of uncertainty as thousands of workers sought exemptions and challenges to a federal mandate played out in court.

>>> Barron’s Weekend Summary

Barron’s Weekend Summary: In 2022, investors should not expect the kind of returns they saw in 2021

* Cover Story:
-This past week, Fed Chairman Jerome Powell announced that the Treasury will accelerate the taper of its stimulus spending in a bid to combat the highest inflation rates since 1982. Therein lies the first clue that investors should not expect the kind of returns they saw in 2021. The Fed’s hawkish turn paves the way for an increase in interest rates—probably several—for the first time since 2018. Meanwhile, corporate earnings and economic growth are expected to decelerate next year. About the only constant: the persistence of Covid-19.

* Tech Trader:
Doug Clinton, managing partner at the tech investment firm Loup Ventures, thinks the landscape for tech stocks will remain challenging in 2022, at least for the first quarter. “You want to be on the side of the Fed,” he says. “We’re going to stay cautious ahead of rate hikes.” Clinton estimates that for every full percentage point increase in rates, the risk to tech stock valuations is 10% for the megacaps, and 20% for higher risk companies. “2022 might be the year of the discerning investor, after the year of the meme investor and the SPAC speculator,” he says. “Prices matter again.”

* The Trader:
-“Owning online payment stocks has been painful for the past two months. That’s created an opportunity in at least one smaller company in the space— Shift4 Payments. Everything was fine for payment stocks for much of the year. The ETFMG Prime Mobile Payments exchange-traded fund had gained 5.8% through Oct. 19—not great, but not too bad, considering its 34% rise in 2020. Then the bottom fell out. Since then, the ETF has dropped 20%, while big players like PayPal Holdings, Block—formerly Square—and Global Payments have tumbled even more.”
-“While the Fed has started to tighten monetary policy, it might be acting too slowly to do anything but contribute to a short-term selloff. If real yields remain deeply negative, the equity risk premium could fall even more. That could cause the S&P 500’s cyclically adjusted price/earnings ratio, based on operating earnings, to surge from a worrisome 35 times now to a problematic 45 times by the middle of 2023, Bannister says, putting the S&P 500 at around 6750, a gain of 46%.”

* Features:
-The Internal Revenue Service is being a bit more generous with the formula businesses and eligible taxpayers can use when they tally the tax deductions for their work-related miles on the road. On Friday, the IRS released the standard mileage rate for business-related driving in 2022. The rate will be 58.5 cents per mile for business use. That’s a 2.5-cent climb from the 56-cent rate this year. It was a 57.5-cent rate the year before that, and a 58-cent rate before that.
-“The phrase life is a game does not mean that life is silly,” writes Edward Castronova, an economist and professor of media at Indiana University, in Life is a game: What game design says about the human condition, his fascinating and delightfully weird book on the subject. “It means that life presents all people with choices, and those choices—combined with the inevitable randomness produced by the choices of others as well as Nature herself—come back in terms of gains and losses.” Money is at least one way we keep score. In 2020, when the game “Animal Crossing” became a huge hit, many marveled at how suddenly kids and adults across the world were inadvertently learning about how prices and arbitrage work.

* Europe:
-Turkish markets have been shaken in recent weeks by the combination of the central bank’s ultraloose monetary policy in the context of soaring inflation, and generous government handouts to the population.The Turkish central bank on Thursday yet again cut interest rates, to 14%, shortly after President Erdogan had announced a 50% raise of the minimum wage for 2022.
Erdogan had fired the three predecessors of the current central bank governor, Sahap Kavcioglu, for refusing to loosen monetary policy despite his increasingly vocal exhortations.
-The global semiconductor shortage has made this year a tough one for the European auto industry but it also makes the sector a potential buying opportunity heading into 2022.

Chip supply issues have forced production cuts at the world’s largest car makers, with many seeing problems continuing into 2022. European car sales hit a record low in October, according to the European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association. JPMorgan analysts see global production recovering in the second half of 2022, at which point suppliers “should clearly outperform” car manufacturers. French car parts supplier Faurecia is a top pick due to its strong exposure to fast-growing regions such as China, and customers like major manufacturers Tesla (TSLA) and Stellantis (STLA).

* Emerging Markets:
-Emerging markets are ending 2021 miserably. The iShares MSCI Emerging Markets exchange-traded fund has lost 12% since July 1, while the S&P 500 gained 9%. Global inflation has forced emerging markets to hike interest rates, clipping pandemic recoveries, while the US and Europe keep their throttles open. China, which accounts for a third of global emerging markets, has focused on deleveraging and “reform,” including unpredictable attacks on high-flying tech companies. Meanwhile, successive Covid variants keep delaying the reopening process, hitting hardest on developing world tourism.

* Commodities:
Some analysts warn that 2022 will be a difficult year for commodities, with the pandemic’s impact on economic activity set to influence trading after a volatile year marked by a rally in energy that fueled inflation, and a retreat of precious metals prices. But others like Noel Dixon, a global macro strategist for State Street, think “It will be a more challenging year for commodities in 2022 because global central banks are tightening policy.”

>>> Weekend Papers Summary

Weekend Papers Summary


NEW YORK TIMES
-The New York Times is publishing hundreds of the Pentagon’s confidential assessments of reports (obtained through Freedom of Information requests beginning in March 2017 and subsequent lawsuits filed against the Defense Department and the US Central Command) of civilian casualties resulting from US-led airstrikes in Iraq and Syria. “The documents lay bare how the air war has been marked by deeply flawed intelligence, rushed and often imprecise targeting, and the deaths of thousands of innocent civilians, many of them children.”
-A New York Times investigation found that the American air war in Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan has been plagued by flawed intelligence, poor targeting and thousands of civilian deaths.
-As the pandemic has entered its third year, resurgent thanks to the Omicron variant, experts are urging U.S. adults to get vaccinated and boosted.
Yet among vaccinated Americans, only 30 percent have received a third dose, according to the C.D.C., and the lagging response is worrying health experts.
-Americans on edge as cases rise and the holidays loom. A week from Christmas, nearly 1,300 Americans are dying every day from the coronavirus and more than 120,000 are testing positive.
- Black elected officials, from Congress down to the counties, have been drawn out of their districts or face headwinds to hold onto their seats.
-Democrats’ achievements in 2021 were overshadowed by legislative setbacks, fallout from the Jan. 6 attack and a sense that Congress was not rising to meet a perilous moment in history.
-China’s crackdown has driven most of Hong Kong’s popular pro-democracy candidates either into police custody or exile. Officials are urging the public to vote, but turnout is expected to be low.
-Once a Symbol of US Strength, the Afghan district of Marja faces dire times. Residents are growing desperate for any kind of help, a frustration that has turned to anger that the international community has abandoned them.
-Despite a bid to protect it from a contentious rezoning plan, the Elizabeth Street Garden in SoHo will be replaced by housing units.
-IVF patients are faced with a growing list of costly “add-ons.” For one such test, some say more robust research is needed to support its effectiveness.
-Israel has threatened military action to destroy Iran’s nuclear program if need be. But defense officials say Israel does not have the ability, at least not anytime soon.
-Olympic leaders have criticized China’s handling of the Peng Shuai (the tennis player) case but tried not to say anything that would jeopardize the safety of the American athletes headed to Beijing.
-Authorities in Virginia say that Anthony Robinson, the so-called ‘shopping cart killer’, met his victims via online dating sites and later transported their bodies in shopping carts to dispose of them.

THE FINANCIAL TIMES
The Netherlands has become the first EU country to re-enter a strict nationwide lockdown, in a response to the spread of the Omicron Covid-19 variant that will shutter swaths of the economy until at least mid-January.
-Republican Party operatives in Pennsylvania are betting that another conservative financier, Bridgewater chief executive David McCormick, will be able to walk a similar political tightrope to win the state’s US Senate race next year.
-With the labor market the tightest in four decades and worker availability expected to determine the success or failure of deliveries this season, Amazon has taken the initiative with bonuses of £1,000 to attract staff and increase its Christmas workforce to about 75,000 people this year, leaping from less than a third of Royal Mail’s peak headcount before the pandemic to almost half the size.
-A stunning by-election loss follows a series of crises that have damaged UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s claim to be a political winner. As a result Johnson was put on probation by Conservative MPs with warnings he could face a coup by mid-2022 unless he raises his game.
-Russia has published a set of stringent demands it is making of the US and NATO, which would end all prospect of Ukraine or any more former Soviet states joining the transatlantic alliance and rewrite many of the principles upholding European security since the end of the cold war.
-Ghislaine Maxwell declined to testify on Friday as her lawyers wrapped up her defense on criminal sex trafficking charges after two days. “Your honor, the government has not proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt, and so there is no need for me to testify,” Maxwell, 59, said on Friday afternoon, after Judge Alison Nathan offered her the standard opportunity to take the stand to testify in her own defense.
-Russia has published a set of stringent demands it is making of the US and NATO, which would end all prospect of Ukraine or any more former Soviet states joining the transatlantic alliance and rewrite many of the principles upholding European security since the end of the cold war.
-The Federal Reserve could raise interest rates as early as March in the face of “alarmingly high inflation”, according to a senior US central bank official.
-Turkey’s main stock exchange halted trading on Friday after the country’s currency crisis, already stinging bonds, spread to equities. Borsa Istanbul announced a temporary so-called circuit breaker after its main Bist 100 index fell 5 per cent. After trading resumed, the benchmark was more than 8 per cent lower.
-Blackstone is close to acquiring a stake in one of New York’s newest office towers, in a deal that would value the 70-storey skyscraper at $2.85B and signal confidence that the crisis-hit city will remain the nexus of corporate America. Built on the eve of the pandemic, One Manhattan West abuts the giant Hudson Yards redevelopment and has sweeping views of the Hudson River.
-Thierry Breton, the EU internal markets commissioner has complained that US commerce secretary Gina Raimondo is campaigning on behalf of Big Tech, days after the EU approved a common position on draft rules aimed at curbing the power of large American tech companies, fueling a transatlantic tit-for-tat among senior officials.

THE NEW YORK POST
-Harvard University will go remote again in January due to the spread of the Omicron variant: “Please know that we do not take this step lightly,” university president Lawrence Bacow wrote in a memo to students and staff. “Public health experts anticipate the increase in COVID-19 cases to continue, driven by the Omicron variant, which we have now confirmed is already present in our campus community.”
-The national unemployment rate has dropped to a low 4.3%, but the percentage of working-age adults with jobs or looking for jobs hasn’t reached pre-pandemic levels, meaning millions have dropped out of the workforce. In 2019, the participation rate was close to 63.5% — it’s now 61.8%.
-Peloton chief executive John Foley has quietly snatched up a $55 million estate in East Hampton — even as employees of the exercise-bike company fret about their futures as its stock price tanks, The Post has learned.
-Boeing suspended its coronavirus vaccination requirement for US based employees, capping weeks of uncertainty as thousands of workers sought exemptions and challenges to a federal mandate played out in court.

FT : Breton accuses US commerce secretary of campaigning for Big Tech

Breton accuses US commerce secretary of campaigning for Big Tech
EU internal markets chief engages in transatlantic tit-for-tat over planned new regulations

Brussels has complained that a senior US official is campaigning on behalf of Big Tech, days after the EU approved a common position on draft rules aimed at curbing the power of large American tech companies, fuelling a transatlantic tit-for-tat among senior officials.

Thierry Breton, the EU internal markets commissioner, accused US commerce secretary Gina Raimondo of lobbying on behalf of the sector after she said this month that new European rules were “disproportionately” targeting US companies.

Breton said he had already discussed these concerns with Raimondo and that he was “a little bit astonished” to learn that she was airing the same issues publicly.

He said: “This is not something that we do against anybody. We do it for our European fellow citizens and our companies. This is our duty.”

The commissioner said the chief executives of the world’s largest tech platforms, including Google and Facebook, had his “cell number” and could call him to air their concerns. He also said these companies took part in extensive discussions ahead of the EU’s draft rules and that they had plenty of time to “express their concerns”.

He said: “We could discuss. So we don’t need any extra lobbying.” 

The US was also having a debate on regulating Big Tech, he said: “But I don’t want to interfere in what’s happening in the US and I think it’s fair not to interfere in what’s happening in Europe. It’s a balanced way of fair play for fair partners.”

The EU commissioner’s comments come at a particularly awkward time for large online platforms in Brussels. Just this week the European Parliament agreed on a common position on the Digital Markets Act, a draft piece of legislation aimed at curbing the power of Big Tech.

The new rules are expected to ban anti-competitive behaviour by the large platforms, including any highlighting of their own products or services at the expense of rivals, and to force big platforms like Google and Facebook to share data with smaller rivals.

While the DMA was created to force so-called gatekeepers, such as Amazon, to ensure more equal terms on their online platforms, the Digital Services Act will seek to clarify the way large online companies should keep illegal content off their platforms.

This is not the first time US officials have complained about EU draft legislation unfairly targeting American companies. Last June, the US accused Brussels of pushing “protectionist” technology policies that were specifically targeting American companies.

The National Security Council, an arm of the White House, wrote to complain about the tone of recent comments about the EU’s flagship tech regulation. “We are particularly concerned about recent comments by the European Parliament rapporteur for the Digital Markets Act, Andreas Schwab, who suggested the DMA should unquestionably target only the five biggest US firms,” their complaint, dated June 9, said.

The commerce department said on Friday that while Raimondo supported the goals of the Digital Markets Act, it was longstanding practice for the US government to consult to ensure other jurisdiction’s laws did not discriminatorily target US firms.

“While we appreciate the assurances of our European colleagues about their non-discriminatory intentions, it is still unclear whether the current and proposed scoping requirements under the DMA will cover well-known tech platforms, for example, from China and Europe,” a spokesperson said.