Closing Market Summary:Oil Bolsters Indices at Mid-WeekThe major averages ended their midweek affair on a higher note as a leg higher in oil supported a modest gain in the stock market. Additionally, leadership from the heavyweight technology sector (+1.0%) countered some choppy trade from the likes of the financial (+0.1%), consumer discretionary (+0.1%), and health care (+0.2%) sectors. Today's action preceded tomorrow's policy statement from the European Central Bank, which is widely believed to call for additional stimulus measures. The Nasdaq Composite (+0.6%) settled ahead of the S&P 500 (+0.5%) and the Dow Jones Industrial Average (+0.2%).
Equities displayed modest gains in the early going, reaching their best levels shortly after the release of the Department of Energy's weekly inventory report. The report showed that crude oil inventories rose in-line with analyst estimates, but that gasoline inventories experienced a larger-than-expected draw (4.53 million; consensus 1.39 million). This echoed the results of the API report and led to a bid in crude oil, as investors believed that drawdowns in gasoline inventories would drive increased demand in oil for future refining. As a result, WTI crude ended its day higher by 4.8% at $38.23/bbl.
Commodity-sensitive energy (+1.5%) was able to take advantage of this swing in oil prices, climbing the leaderboard. Meanwhile, the top-weighted technology sector (+1.0%) finished in the second spot.
In the energy sector (+1.5%), oil and gas refining names were able to outperform as Marathon Petroleum (MPC 37.06, +1.89) gained 5.4%. Meanwhile, Dow component Chevron (CVX 92.82, +4.08) managed to top the price-weighted index as it climbed 4.6%. The energy space managed to re-enter positive territory for the year with today's trade, as the group shows a gain of 0.7% over that period.
Heavily-weighted technology (+1.0%) received a boost from large-cap component Microsoft (MSFT 52.84, +1.19), which managed to reclaim its 50-day moving average (52.24). Separately, Cisco Systems (CSCO 27.61, +0.56) benefited from some M&A news as the company announced that it would be acquiring Synata for an undisclosed amount.
On the bottom of the leaderboard, telecom services (-0.3%) led the downside while heavily-weighted financials (+0.1%), consumer discretionary (+0.1%), and health care (+0.2%) underperformed. Biotechnology weighted on the health care space as the iShares Nasdaq Biotechnology ETF (IBB 257.13, 3.00) surrendered 1.2%.
In the economically sensitive financial sector (-0.1%), Morgan Stanley (MS 24.61, -0.40) surrendered 1.6%. The company has plunged 4.8% since Monday whereas the broader sector has lost 1.6% over that period. Meanwhile, Franklin Resources (BEN 37.41, -0.59) tumbled 1.6% after the company reported that preliminary month-end assets under management totaled $714 billion compared to the $728.1 billion under management in January.
Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG 506.63, -18.06) displayed relative weakness in the consumer discretionary space (+0.1%) after it was confirmed that one of the sick employees at its Billerica, Massachusetts location was infected by norovirus. The location has been cleared to open on Thursday. Separately, large-cap Home Depot (HD 126.03, -0.69) fell 0.5%.
The Dollar Index (97.17, -0.03) ticked up off its session low as the euro/dollar pair backed away from its high of 1.1029 to trade lower by 0.1% at 1.1002. Separately, the dollar/yen pair rose 0.7% to 113.40.
The Treasury complex traded broadly lower throughout the day as the yield on the 10-yr note slipped five basis points to 1.88%.
Today's participation was below the recent average with fewer than 933 million shares changing hands at the NYSE floor.
Today's economic data included the weekly MBA Mortgage Index and the January Wholesale Inventories Report:
- The weekly MBA Mortgage Index was showed a seasonally adjusted increase of 0.2% in mortgage applications.
- Wholesale inventories increased 0.3% in January from an upwardly revised unchanged reading (from -0.1%) for December. The consensus estimate called for a 0.2% decline in January wholesale inventories, which are up 2.0% year-over-year.
- The gain in January was driven by a 1.1% increase in nondurable inventories. Inventories of durable goods actually declined 0.3%.
- The uptick in nondurable inventories was driven by drug (+3.3%) and farm products (+2.9%) inventories. The biggest increase was in paper inventories (+4.2%), although they make up just 3.6% of total nondurable inventories.
- With respect to durable inventories, the biggest weights were the declines in electrical (-3.6%) and metals (-1.8%) inventories. Machinery inventories, which account for 29% of total durable inventories, rose 0.2% after a 0.4% decline in December.
- Wholesale sales dropped 1.3% in January after a 0.6% decline in December. Durable sales were down 1.9% while nondurable sales fell 0.8%.
- The wholesale inventories to sales ratio jumped to 1.35 in January from 1.33 in December. This ratio stood at 1.28 in the same period a year ago.
Tomorrow's economic data includes weekly initial claims (consensus 275k) and the Treasury Budget for February, which will cross the wires at 8:30 ET and 14:00 ET, respectively.
- Nasdaq Composite -6.7% YTD
- Russell 2000 -5.6% YTD
- S&P 500 -2.7% YTD
- Dow Jones -2.4% YTD
Equity Strategy and Quantitative Research
US Equity Strategy: Momentum Sells Off, Value Makes a Comeback
In our previous reports (see Rising Momentum Tail Risk, The Case for Rotation in Equity Leadership, Momentum Stocks at Risk) we highlighted the tail risk associated with the equity Momentum trade, while arguing that Value is oversold and ripe for a comeback. Recent data suggests that there has been a significant Momentum/Value rotation, with long/short Momentum (FTUSMTUT) down 24% and Value (JPUSVALU) up16% YTD (vs. S&P 500 -3.2%). Momentum had five days of -3StdDev declines YTD, which is ~30 times more often than normally expected (fat left tail).
Reasons why this rotation may persist beyond the initial change in positioning:
· Momentum stocks trade at an extreme premium to Value stocks with valuation spread highest since 1980, except for during the tech bubble.
· Momentum is crowded while Value offers greater opportunity. Dispersion of high Momentum stocks has been decreasing and is at the lowest level since 2009 while dispersion across Value stocks relative to market is rising and at highest level since 2011 suggesting greater opportunity set.
· Rebalancing of active equity Quant portfolios could further fuel the rotation from Momentum into Value. Most Quant portfolios are rebalanced at lower frequency (e.g., monthly). The most common stock momentum signal skips the last month of price action (e.g., 12M – 1M momentum). Given this lag, this month’s severe Momentum sell-off could be reinforced in subsequent months as Quant portfolios get systematically rebalanced. On the contrary, short Value stock positions (that rallied this month) could get closed only next month and then included in the long portfolio subsequently.
· In addition, proliferation of passive equity Quant portfolios (e.g., Smart Beta, Low Vol) poses additional risk of Momentum crowding and could exacerbate Momentum sell-off. Momentum is typically one of the core factors within Smart Beta products. Also, currently, Low Vol and high Quality are positively correlated to Momentum and also trade at extreme valuation. These risk premia based products are estimated to have reached ~$900 billion in AUM (3Q15).
· Macro trends that may further drive the rotation from Momentum into Value: slower US growth and increased volatility resulting in a more dovish Fed; flat-to-weaker USD; stable-to-rising commodity prices including oil (with CTAs still very short and representing 20-40% of WTI open interest); more policy stimulus and improvement in China; commodity induced inflation surprise (even with Fed hiking) would be a positive for Value (including Financials); further stabilization in manufacturing sector (or convergence between goods producing and services industries); further improvement in the 2nd derivative of our business cycle indicator which just turned positive from low levels and moved into Recovery state (QMI, Figure 11); more synchronized business cycles across regions.
· Risk to Value Rotation: US economy reaccelerates but growth is lopsided driven by domestic services while manufacturing continues to deteriorate; dollar strengthens; oil weakens; China growth scare re-emerges and yuan depreciates.
For a list of Deep Value, JPM Value Composite, Momentum (at Any Price) and MARP (Momentum at Reasonable Price) stocks, see screens on page 4.