WWD : Year-to-Date, M&A Activity Slows

Year-to-Date, M&A Activity Slows
According to the S&P, transaction values have declined 16 percent.

According to the latest year-to-date data from S&P Capital IQ, merger and acquisition activity in the U.S. has decelerated with the number of deals lower than the same period last year as well as total transaction value.

To date, there have been just over 6,400 total transactions in the 11 sectors covered by the S&P, which reflects a 4.3 percent decline in deal volume from the same period last year. Transaction values are off double digits, the firm said in its report.

Richard Peterson, principal analyst at the firm, said that “with announced U.S. M&A dollar proceeds in 2017 off 16 percent from year-ago activity, the slump in several sectors’ deal [counts] represents another cautionary sign for deal making this year.”

The analyst noted that real estate remains the top sector, followed by consumer discretionary — which includes retail and fashion apparel deals. Peterson said real estate M&A activity garnered 32 percent of the total number of deals so far this year. “While that percentage approximates real estate deals share of announced M&A shares at this time last year, the sector has experienced the second-biggest single drop in deal count year-over-year with a decline of 99 transactions,” Peterson added.

The firm also said that the second “most frequently targeted sector for U.S. M&A deals to date” is the consumer discretionary market. “However, this sector has suffered the biggest year-over-year drop in number of deals as deal count is 114 lower than a year ago,” Peterson said. “Contributing to this result has been a drop in the number of retail industry deals as to date this year there have been 159 announced M&A transactions. That represents the lowest deal count at this point in time for the retail industry since 2009 when 121 M&A transactions were announced.”

In the consumer staples market, the S&P said dealmaking was robust. The energy sector is also faring well with the number of deals outpacing last year. “As for areas seeing a notable slowdown in M&A deals, the information technology has reported 854 announced U.S. M&A deals to date this year, the slowest pace of deals since 2013,” Peterson said. “Similarly, this year’s financial sector M&A deal count of 422 is the most sluggish since the 2013 period when 406 transactions took place.”

The analyst also said the pace of dealmaking in the industrial sector is also down.

NYT : Goldman Buys $2.8 Billion Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Uproar Begins

Venezuelan bonds would seem to be an unlikely target for global investors.

The country is in near revolt and has barely enough ready cash to feed its people, much less pay the billions of dollars in debt that the government owes to its foreign lenders.

Yet bonds issued by Venezuela’s national oil company, Petróleos de Venezuela, or Pdvsa, have attracted some of world’s most sophisticated investors. They are betting that the government will use its dwindling supply of dollars to pay bondholders instead of importing food and medicine for its people.

Now, Goldman Sachs’ decision to snap up $2.8 billion worth of Pdvsa bonds maturing in 2022, at a 70 percent discount to the market price, has struck a nerve.

The investment has caused a political uproar in Venezuela, where opposition forces have taken to the streets to protest the autocratic rule of the nation’s unpopular president, Nicolás Maduro. Nearly 60 people have died in clashes, mainly between protesters and the police, in Caracas and other cities in recent months.

Julio Borges, the opposition lawmaker who heads the National Assembly, wrote a letter of protest to Lloyd C. Blankfein, the chief executive of Goldman Sachs, accusing the Wall Street firm of looking to make a “quick buck off the suffering of the Venezuelan people.”

Goldman Sachs has defended the deal, saying that many other investors, including mutual funds and exchange-traded funds, own the bonds and that its asset management division bought the securities on the secondary market, without interacting with the Venezuelan government.

Nevertheless, the transaction highlights the extent to which investors are willing to take on increasing levels of political and economic risk as they seek high-yielding investments when interest rates still hover near zero.

“There is a lot of interest in this trade,” said Carlos de Sousa, an economist at Oxford Economics, a research company based in London. “We are in a low-rate environment, and these are dollar bonds with really high yields.”

Among the large holders of Pdvsa bonds are BlackRock, T. Rowe Price, Fidelity, JPMorgan Chase and Ashmore, an emerging market specialist based in London.

But none of those firms carry Goldman’s reputation for being politically influential and financially opportunistic — a combination that has made it an easy global punching bag.

At the root of what makes the bonds so attractive to investors, beyond their more than 20 percent returns, is the crucial role played by the Venezuelan oil company in providing foreign exchange to the embattled Maduro government.

While Venezuela has been in economic crisis for more than two years, the surge of people to the streets began after its Supreme Court, which is loyal to Mr. Maduro, tried to dissolve the country’s National Assembly in late March. The group of lawmakers, controlled by opposition parties, is considered the only government institution independent of the president.

Mr. Maduro’s growing authoritarianism is only the beginning of mounting grievances against Venezuela’s ruling leftists, who have governed since President Hugo Chávez took control of the country in 1999.

Falling petroleum prices and years of economic mismanagement when oil revenues were high, have led to triple-digit inflation and left a majority of Venezuelans hardly able to buy sufficient food and other necessities. Even those who can afford meals most days have trouble finding basics like bread, eggs and sugar because of rampant shortages.

Pdvsa brings in about 95 percent of the economy’s dollars, so foreign investors believe that the government, even in a worst case, will do all it can to keep the company functioning.

Mr. de Sousa also points out that unlike pure sovereign bonds issued by the government, Pdvsa securities lack legal mechanisms, like collective action clauses, which can help a government negotiate favorable terms with foreign bond holders if it defaults on its debt.

Moreover, investors have noted that in the last year, as Venezuela’s economic situation has deteriorated sharply, the government has paid out billions of dollars to foreign investors holding the oil company bonds.

The Pdvsa trade is the latest sign that foreign investors are becoming bolder in investing in the bonds of governments in far-flung locales.

In recent months, higher risk countries such as Turkey, Russia and Brazil have been at the forefront of this trend.

Driving the bet, analysts say, is a view that emerging market economies, regardless of their political and economic challenges, are no longer willing to face the wrath of bond investors by defaulting on their debts.

That is because global investment giants like BlackRock and Goldman have become ready sources of financing, quick to lend billions in dollars or even local currencies, to governments in Africa, Latin America and Asia that in the past relied on banks.

Perhaps no country is as reliant on the kindness of risk-happy foreign bond investors as Venezuela. According to the research firm Exotix, Venezuela has a financing requirement of $17 billion in 2017, yet its central bank reserves are a paltry $10 billion.

As investors see it, if you can buy a Pdvsa bond at 30 cents on the dollar, which also provides a double-digit yield, even if this government — or another for than matter — has to default, the gains made on the investment would be enough to overcome any loss.

While Goldman Sachs defended its trade by saying that it bought the bonds on the open market from a broker, bankers and traders say the money ultimately ended up in Venezuela’s treasury because the seller was an institution with ties to the government.

Nonetheless, the threat by Mr. Borges, the opposition leader, that a new government would not make good on these bonds seems unlikely.

That is because these bonds carry covenants aimed at preventing an issuer from favoring one bond holder over another. So paying BlackRock or JP Morgan and not Goldman would open Venezuela to lawsuits.

All of which suggests that, despite the controversy over the Goldman trade, foreign investors will keep lining up to buy Pdvsa bonds.

“This is the only source of foreign currency the government has,” said Mr. de Sousa, the Venezuelan expert at Oxford. “So I think the government will continue to sell more of these types of bonds to foreign investors.”

FT : The argument for owning European equities

The argument for owning European equities
Investors should hold their noses and revisit Spanish and Italian bank shares

In this column last month, I covered non-US stocks’ historical leadership in US presidents’ inaugural years. History shows us that the party really gets going in the second half, making this your buying window. But what to own? For answers, look at sector and country winners from the first quarter of this year.

Since 1970 — when good sector data begin — non-US sectors that led in the first quarter of inaugural years led for the rest of the year. The first quarter’s top three non-US sectors led the MSCI EAFE Index (Europe, Australasia, Far East) 61 per cent of the time, by a median 3.4 per cent. Meanwhile, the three worst sectors trailed the rest of the year 76 per cent of the time by -4.8 per cent.

Country leadership also persists. Similarly, the first quarter’s top country or region led the rest of the year 80 per cent of the time, by a median 5.6 per cent. The second best kept leading 60 per cent of the time, with a 2.2 per cent spread. The worst kept lagging 60 per cent of the time, and by 6.2 per cent.

“No correlation without causation” is one of my pet rules. “No heat chasing” is another. But I see fundamental reasons why many first quarter trends continue. The drivers don’t suddenly shift when the calendar flips from March to April. With America’s new administration in place, falling political uncertainty had already given its bullish impact on US stocks, hence first-quarter growth has favoured non-US stocks. And when non-US stocks lead early in inaugural years, the outperformance usually grows with time.

Outside America, many nations are very sector heavy. So if you expect non-US stocks to lead, that impacts sectors too.

On a regional basis, the first quarter’s best were Australia and continental Europe, while Canada lagged behind badly. Of the 10 eurozone nations in the MSCI World Index, seven outperformed. So buy Europe — not just core stalwarts like Germany, the Netherlands and France, but also the periphery.

Spain was the single best-performing country in the first quarter, and midway through May, its lead has widened. Australia, however, has sagged, and I see it as part of the 20 per cent that reverses first quarter success historically. Aussie stocks are a heavy bet on materials, whose early-year bounce petered out as folks fathomed metals’ enduring supply glut.

As for sectors, in the first quarter, non-US’s best sectors were technology, healthcare, industrials, consumer staples and utilities. The worst were energy — hence commodity-heavy Canada’s lag — plus telecoms and discretionary consumer stocks.

I’ve long liked healthcare and tech and expect greatness from here. Global demand for drugs, gadgets and software likely stays sky-high through this cycle’s close. Buy industrials, but avoid those dependent on commodity prices — aerospace, diversified conglomerates and consumer-goods manufacturers have better potential. As for staples and utilities, own some but don’t go crazy. Both tend to lag during strong expansions. Maybe they’ll be part of the 39 per cent that flip-flops.

Financials are a special case. Globally, financials lagged behind in the first quarter and kept trailing. But eurozone financials led in the first quarter, and have sped up since. Buy them.

US loan growth is slowing, but eurozone lending is ramping up, and banks there are loosening. Based on senior loan officer opinion surveys from the Federal Reserve and ECB, eurozone credit availability has improved since early 2016, while US loan supply has tightened.

In America, more banks tightened than loosened in three of the last four quarters. In Europe, banks net loosened in three of four quarters. In the one quarter that more banks tightened (the fourth quarter of 2016) the difference was only 0.2 per cent — so basically even. Lending trends tend to follow changes in credit standards, so Europe’s looser stance argues for ever-faster loan growth.

Historically, relative credit availability has correlated with outperformance. For most of the 2002-07 bull market, eurozone banks lent more eagerly than US banks, and eurozone stocks outperformed US — by 182 per cent to 61 per cent over the whole bull run.

For this bull market’s first few years, we had the opposite — looser lending in America and US outperformance. Yet for the past year, there has been a fairly big disconnect between relative credit access and relative returns.

Even as eurozone credit improved, US markets outperformed — until just recently. Investors were too distracted by politics to fathom faster loan growth’s implications. The French election’s conclusion should help folks refocus.

Eurozone leadership is only just starting. Europe’s credit cycle is young. Banks have ample room to expand balance sheets and improve non-performing loan ratios.

America’s cycle is older. US banks have been expanding balance sheets for five years, and non-performing loan ratios are about as good as can be. US banks are healthy, stocks already reflect that. Yet investors still broadly hate eurozone banks. Their relatively brighter future isn’t priced yet. That goes double for Spanish and Italian banks — hated currently for no good reason, just bitter memories. Hold your nose and buy now.

Ken Fisher is the founder and Chairman of Fisher Investments

(Citi) Akzo Standalone Plan Won’t Create as Much Value as PPG M&A

Akzo Nobel concerns about an agreed deal with PPG are understandable, but wouldn’t materially impact the merged business in a negative way if managed carefully, Citi (buy) says in note.
  • Says the value creation from synergies from a PPG merger are not possible from Akzo’s standalone proposals
  • Notes that new strategy of spinning off specialty chemicals and increased dividends should still support the shares
  • Akzo shares have a "warrant" attached, this being the potential offer from PPG that is not discounted in the price, whether offer is made now or in the future
  • Akzo’s rejection of an offer of EU96/share needs to be looked at in the context of current share price of EU75
  • Adds that given the synergies from PPG offer available and "stranded costs" from Akzo’s strategy, evident as to why this gap exists to offer price
  • See upside to shares with Akzo remaining quoted, separation of chemicals should help deliver this value
  • Akzo PT EU90 derived from sum-of-the-parts valuation, specialty chemicals valued at 9.4x EV/Ebitda, paint business on 13x EV/Ebitda

REuters - E.ON hires Goldman to explore options for Uniper stake: sources

E.ON hires Goldman to explore options for Uniper stake: sources

German energy group E.ON (EONGn.DE) has hired Goldman Sachs (GS.N) to explore options for a sale of the group's remaining stake in Uniper (UN01.DE), the power plant and trading business it spun off last year, two sources close to the matter said.

Following the listing of Uniper in September, E.ON kept a 46.65 percent stake - currently valued at about 2.83 billion euros ($3.16 billion) - and has said it aims to sell the rest soon but not before 2018 due to potentially negative tax effects.

A sale could happen in several ways, including an outright sale to a third party or placements on the market, the sources said, adding it was less likely that peers would want to acquire the stake due to Uniper's eclectic business structure.

E.ON's exploration of options is at an early stage and no deal is imminent, the sources said.

Uniper has a range of operations from hydroelectric, coal- and gas-fired plants to storage assets and trading floors, and holds stakes in gas pipelines, LNG terminals and nuclear plants across Europe.

"Most power firms would want a part of Uniper, but there is hardly anyone with a profile that would accommodate all of the group's activities," one of the sources said.

Ever since their restructuring moves last year, German power firms are back on the M&A radar, with RWE (RWEG.DE) exploring an asset swap with Engie (ENGIE.PA) involving its majority stake in Innogy (IGY.DE).

One source said E.ON's Uniper stake could draw interest from private equity groups with a track record in the energy industry, including KKR (KKR.N), which in January agreed to buy assets from U.S. oil and gas producer SM Energy Co (SM.N) for $800 million.

This was one of a number of recent private equity-backed deals in the energy sector, which included Carlyle-backed (CG.O) Neptune Oil & Gas buying a stake Engie's exploration and production business for $3.9 billion.

E.ON, Goldman Sachs and KKR all declined to comment.

WSJ : Sprint Moves Media Account From Publicis Shop to Horizon

Sprint Corp. S 0.48% has moved its $700 million media agency business from Publicis Groupe ’s PUBGY 2.87% Mediavest Spark to independent media agency Horizon Media in one of the largest account changes of the year.

The win gives Horizon Chief Executive Bill Koenigsberg another feather in his cap as he expands his independent media operation. Last year, he joined forces with Hyundai-backed agency Innocean to launch another media agency called Canvas Worldwide. As part of the deal, Canvas also won the media account for Hyundai Motor Group ’s U.S. brands, including Kia Motors America and Hyundai Motor America.

“Horizon Media’s innovative ideas and dynamic approach using traditional and emerging channels is a perfect fit for Sprint as we continue on our transformation,” said Sprint’s marketing chief, Roger Solé, in a statement. “The agency’s unique and fresh perspective will support Sprint in an extremely competitive and continually evolving industry.”

Wireless companies have been locked in a fierce price war that only threatens to get more competitive as cable companies like Comcast and Charter Communications prepare to enter the cutthroat business.

Sprint spent just under $700 million on U.S. media in 2016, compared with spending by AT&T Inc. of $1.62 billion and Verizon at $1.3 billion, according to Kantar Media. The spending figure doesn’t include some forms of digital advertising. All three spent less on U.S. media in 2016 than in 2015.

Sprint, the No. 4 U.S. carrier by subscribers, has aggressively gone after its larger telecom rivals in recent years with offerings like unlimited data. But AT&T and Verizon recently launched unlimited data plans, forcing Sprint to end its longtime offer to charge customers half the price of other rival plans.

The intense competition has been clear even in the companies’ creative approach to their advertising. Last year Sprint tapped Paul Marcarelli, Verizon’s longtime “Can you hear me now?” pitchman, to star in ads in which he boasts about switching to Sprint.

Sprint’s move to independent media shop Horizon is also in line with the phone company’s recent creative agency shift from Interpublic Group of Co s.-owned Deutsch to Droga5, also an independent agency.

For Publicis Groupe, the departure of the Sprint account is another blow after a string of large account losses in recent years, including Wal-Mart, Procter & Gamble, Coca-Cola and Honda. Publicis also recently won some business, including H&R Block, KFC and P&G in the U.K.

“We are proud of the work we’ve delivered for Sprint during our partnership with them and our team’s dedication to the client,” according to a statement from Mediavest Spark. “We wish Sprint all the best in the future and will approach this transition with the utmost commitment and collaboration.”

TechCrunch : Launching an aerospace startup at Mach 2 with your hair on fire

Launching an aerospace startup at Mach 2 with your hair on fire

There are few industries whose evolution includes dramatic steps backwards, but that’s exactly what happened in commercial aviation and its experiments in supersonic flight.
For 27 years, supersonic travel was a reality, creating a bridge between Europe and the US that led to a bright future for commercial flight. And then, suddenly, that future disappeared. Blake Scholl is determined to bring that future back.
In an interview for Flux I chatted with Blake, the founder and CEO of Denver-based Boom, a supersonic jet company. We got into how the Concorde business model was flawed, why it takes an outsider to re-ignite innovation in the industry, and how simulation software has greatly reduced the time and cost of plane design.
An excerpt of our conversation is published below.
AMLG: Today’s guest is Blake Scholl, founder of . Welcome Blake. Let’s jump in — what is Boom exactly and where did the idea come from?marketing automation stack. He also built Amazon’s which was acquired by Groupon — a supersonic civilian aircraft company based in Denver, Colorado. RRE is an investor and we’re a huge fan of Blake. He is a certified pilot and a repeat entrepreneur who previously founded the payments company Kima Labs, Boom
BS: The first 50 years of aviation— from the Wright brothers forward — we had incredible progress and safety and comfort and economics and speed. Then this weird thing happened in the 1960s and 70s where we stopped making progress in speed. The American Airlines special from New York to San Francisco back then was actually scheduled for an hour less than it is today. What technology have we had the capability and then actually gone backwards? We had Concorde — a Mach 2 passenger airplane — flew it for 30 years and never took it mainstream. Now it’s in museums.

A visualization of the Boom plane


What we’re doing at Boom is trying to fix that problem, to bring back faster air travel but in a more mainstream, more affordable way than Concorde. We’re going to chip away at that problem until we have the fastest airplane that’s also the cheapest one to fly.
AMLG: We came up with road networks and steam engines, and humans got faster and faster and faster and then we had the Concorde and then we didn’t have it. It feels like we stopped with cars and jets. How does progress just halt like that, especially in an area like transport that’s so fundamental to the economy?
BS: You have to look at where innovation comes from. Everybody knows the first airplane came from bicycle entrepreneurs. What’s less well known is that the first practical airliner, the DC-3, and the first jetliner the de Havilland Comet — both came from founder-led companies. We haven’t had any founder-led companies in commercial aircraft since the last one was founded in 1921. The last founder retired from the industry in 1958. Since then we’ve had big companies basically optimizing the same concept.
What really happened that blocked supersonics? Well you have to look at where Concorde came from. Concorde was not an entrepreneurial project. It was a joint venture between two governments, the French and the British. Of course most joint ventures between the French and British have been wars.
Geoffroy de Courcel the French Ambassador (left) and Julian Amery the British Minister of Aviation (right) look at a model of a supersonic airliner, on November 29, 1962 in London, where they signed an agreement for the joint development of a supersonic passenger plane. Both countries agreed to spend £75 — £85 million for production lines.

AMLG: Yes we’ve had our fair share of wars. As a Brit I can say that warring with the french is one of our favorite things to do.
BS: Right. So it’s remarkable Concorde ever flew. It wasn’t about, let’s usher in the supersonic age. It was about, let’s beat the Russians. It was a Cold War era glory project disconnected from economics. It was a glorious technical achievement but wasn’t aimed at being practical.
So the Europeans had Concorde, the Russians had this thing people call Concordski. And on this side of the pond there was what was supposed to be a Concorde killer that the U.S. government was championing. The Americans had to have a Mach 3 three hundred seat airplane. By the way that thing was going to be an economic catastrophe. In 1970 Congress pulled the subsidies that were going to Boeing to build that airplane. We got this unholy alliance between aerospace protectionist interests and ostensibly environmental concerns and we banned supersonic travel in the US. Literally banned it. We put in place a speed limit.
AMLG: Wait why did they pull the subsidies? Due to cost?
BS: There’s a lot of ambiguity in the U.S. about whether the government should have been paying 75% of the development cost of a private airplane. That was the biggest reason that Congress pulled it. Besides it was over budget, behind schedule, all the normal things. But it was after that that we banned supersonic travel, when Concorde looked like a threat. That messed up what would have been the normal development path, the normal go-to-market path for supersonic airplanes.
Think about everything from cell phones to computers to electric cars. The way they come to market is they start at a relatively high price point that a small number of people can afford. Then as the technology gets figured out and you get economies of scale and the cost comes down, eventually every kid has a cell phone. But you have to start somewhere. The natural place for supersonic aircraft to have started would be the supersonic private jet. A small number of people whose time is super valuable who can afford something expensive. Those people fly mostly over land. If you can’t fly supersonic over land, well that destroyed the market. It destroyed what would have been the normal evolution of supersonic. Had that not happened I think we’d both be flying on supersonic jumbos today.
AMLG: But you’re not starting with the high-end private jet. You’re starting with commercial and want to make this accessible to everyone?
BS: That’s right. Basically because of the supersonic over land ban, you have to skip a step in your market development. Until that’s reversed I don’t think there’s a market for the supersonic private jet. But you can start with the thing that’s the next level of development, which is a small supersonic aircraft for commercial airliner use. The reason after 50 years why this is finally possible is enough development has happened in aerospace, around aerodynamics and materials and engines. You can pick up those pieces of technology and use them to create a small supersonic aircraft and skip the private jet part. In airlines you focus on routes that are mostly over water like New York to London, San Francisco to Tokyo, Seattle to Shanghai.
AMLG: So the plan is 45 people per plane, one on each side of the aisle — which sounds appealing, none of that battle for the arm rest — and you’re aiming for much lower fuel consumption per passenger right, something like 30% greater efficiency than the Concorde? How do the economics and profitability compare?

A British Aircraft Corporation sales chart, Jan. 18, 1967, showing 69 Concordes on order.


BS: Concorde was extremely expensive to operate for two reasons. One — it was a gas guzzler. Two — it had no economies of scale. The reason it had no economies of scale was that ticket prices were really high. You had to charge $20,000 per round-trip ticket to make any money and you had to put 100 seats on the airplane. You can’t fill 100 seats at $20,000 a pop. It doesn’t work.
If you want to make this work what you have to do is improve the fuel economy so you get the ticket prices down. Taking those one at a time. On the fuel economy piece if you run the numbers — and all the data for this is on Wikipedia — if you beat Concorde by 30% on gas mileage you’re at parity with subsonic business class. You’re not yet at parity with economy, and we need to get there eventually, but you can do it for business class.
So with this Mach 2.2, 45 seat airplane with business class pricing then the story for airlines is hey, if you can fly a Boeing or Airbus on a route and fill the seats and make money, you can fly the Boom jet on the same route and fill the seats and make money. Except you can be differentiated because the flights get there in half the time.
AMLG: It sounds like this is going to take a lot of money. I’ve seen you say that we can build the entire company and get to breakeven for less money than Uber raises in a round, which is funny for a lot of reasons — how much will this really cost?
BS: It’s definitely a capital intensive business. We’re working both on demonstrating the technology as well as demonstrating the market demand and that we have product/market fit with what airlines want.
We’re about a year away from flying our first airplane the XB-1 supersonic demonstrator which is a smaller version of the same thing that shows all the tech works. It will probably require the better part of a billion to get the first passenger flights happening. But at the same time, the market here is a thousand plus airplanes and they are $200 million dollars each. So it’s a pretty good prize and a pretty big ROI even though the capital requirements are large.
AMLG: So $200 million per plane is pretty good, and you’ve got flagship deals with Branson at Virgin Atlantic, who’ve said they’d like to buy at least 10 jets, as well as a bunch of other carriers with LOIs. Obviously they want your jets, so why haven’t they done it themselves? , why didn’t they build it?Boeing for instance had proposals for supersonic
BS: Put yourself in the shoes of the Boeing CEO for a moment. Boeing does one new clean sheet commercial aircraft about every 15 years. So they have to be choosy about what they take on. They have to go after the biggest market opportunity they see. Boeing is widely known to be working on a 797, which is a replacement for the 757, and they think the market size is 4,000 to 5,000 airplanes.
It’s a straightforward replacement of an existing product, for an existing market. Imagine the CEO of Boeing saying “you know let’s not do the 797 let’s do this supersonic thing, we’ll sell a thousand of them, it’ll be great.” The board’s probably going to replace you. This is one of these things that looks great from the perspective of a startup. Moreover, if the small supersonic aircraft pulls passengers off the Dreamliners then they’re going to sell less Dreamliners or have to reduce the price of the Dreamliner which doesn’t sound good. Why would you cannibalize your own business.
AMLG: So it’s a classic innovation dilemma for the legacy corporations. As you say maybe this is why it has to be a founder-driven thing. I want to go back to how you got into this. You’re a repeat internet entrepreneur. How did you get into airplanes, where did this interest come from?
BS: I’ve loved airplanes since I was a kid and I’ve been flying for fun since I was in college. I was living in a world where all other parts of technology are getting better and better, but air travel’s horrible and getting worse. It made no sense. I had this on my bucket list for the better part of a decade, that maybe some day I’d work on it. I created a Google Alert for “supersonic jet” in 2007. I wanted to be the first to know when someone cracked the nut. It was like crickets. Maybe a business jet I couldn’t afford to fly? Crickets. Sci-fi concepts that are never going to work? Crickets.
AMLG: With this one in particular it feels like there’d been some stigma, that it had been left on the drawing board. I do have to ask though, I mean clearly you’re passionate about aerospace, but usually the founder picks a market where they have a ton of expertise or experience — you didn’t have the engineering background to build planes from scratch. How did you feel qualified to start such an ambitious, technical company?
BS: You can learn a lot when you’re motivated. Most people underestimate their ability to go acquire new knowledge. In the first year of working on this it was basically education and recruiting. I read textbooks. I took an airplane design class. I spent a lot of time talking to the best people I could find in the industry and asking them questions and getting them to teach me things and to tell me when I was wrong about stuff. This doesn’t make me an aerospace engineer and I’m not going to design the airplane personally, but I know enough to be dangerous and I know enough to judge talent. I think that’s really important.
AMLG: So in that year you studied enough and talked to enough experts to get over a threshold and come to the conclusion that yes, this is a viable problem, this can be solved?
BS: That’s right. There was a pivotal moment where I’d built basically a spreadsheet model of the airplane. Airplane performance really comes down to four key variables: aerodynamic efficiency, structural efficiency, propulsive efficiency and speed of the airplane. If you have estimates of those things you can relatively straightforwardly predict what the fuel economy is going to be. I had some assumptions there and wasn’t sure how valid they were.
I built the model, took it to a professor at Stanford and said, hey can you look at this and check my math and tell me whether this is reasonable? This guy had done a bunch of research on supersonic airplanes and his feedback was, if you’re going to do this you should really try harder because these seem conservative. At that point I figured either I had no courage or had to find a way to start the company and make it happen.

AMLG: So that was the moment where you realized OK I’m doing this. You’ve said that all the information you needed was on Wikipedia. It reminds me of Elon, of what he did with rockets. He ordered a bunch of manuals off the Internet, read everything, then started to build SpaceX. It turns out you can do that.
BS: It turns out you can do that.
AMLG: Has SpaceX been an inspiration for you, has it paved the way for investors to be more open-minded to this?
BS: I do not think this company would exist if it weren’t for SpaceX, for multiple reasons. One is just personal inspiration. That Elon was able to go off and do something that a lot of people thought was technically impossible, and practically impossible to do as a startup. He’s gone off to accomplish things nobody else can do with less money and greater impact. That’s so cool. It’s an existence proof that’s personally inspiring. Also for investors, it’s like OK things of this scale aren’t impossible.
AMLG: I want to get back into the technology for a second. You mentioned there have been advances in materials science, engines, aerodynamics. What’s changed that makes this more feasible than before? I know that you can for instance, run design tests in simulations at a far cheaper cost?
BS: If you take Boeing’s latest airplane and put it next to their airplane from the 1960s, they look pretty darn similar and their capabilities are pretty darn similar. But they’ve actually completely swapped out the technology stack. We’ve got carbon fiber composites, better aerodynamics and dramatically improved engines. Those are the big three things that make this technically possible today — aerodynamics, materials and propulsion.
From the aerodynamics perspective you used to have to go to wind tunnels to design airplanes. That sucks because every wind tunnel iteration takes six months and costs millions. You’ve got to have an enormous budget and a huge team and a lot of time and you can’t test many ideas. Today you can do the equivalent of six months of wind tunnel testing in half an hour with a simulation running in the cloud. It’s almost like cheating, you can come up with better aerodynamic design, you can test a lot more ideas. If you look at our airplane carefully you’ll notice there’s not a straight line anywhere on it. It looks a bit like Concorde if you squint but the fuselage is differently shaped, the wings are differently shaped.
AMLG: Longer and thinner?
BS: Yes a bit longer and thinner. The key thing is the shaping. It’s not just a tube with wings coming out. That makes a huge difference. It’s not that Concorde’s designers were stupid, they just couldn’t do as many iterations as we can.
AMLG: With the aerodynamics — obviously the Concorde used afterburners to get up to speed, to get to Mach 2. You’re not going to be doing that. That’s the really inefficient part?
BS: That was the only way you could get to sufficient thrust with 1950s technology. Today we have something called turbofan engines which are quieter and more efficient and can generate enough thrust to get you going fast. When the Concorde flipped on the afterburners their fuel consumption went up 78% and they got just 17% more thrust. That’s a bad way to get extra thrust. It’s 2017 we don’t need afterburners to go fast anymore.
AMLG: So the turbofan helps solve some of that?
BS: Yes the turbofan gets you enough thrust for high speed while also being significantly quieter. Concorde was a pretty loud airplane, those afterburners were ripping.
AMLG: That’s kind of the elephant in the room. I’ve got to ask, why did you name the company Boom? Isn’t it a bit of a jinx, aren’t you fighting that whole conception of a noisy plane?
BS: Sonic booms are way overblown. And we’re owning it. That’s part of why we named it Boom. It’s like boom and you’re there. It’s fun to say. I love the name.
To talk more about the noise issue. There are two potential noise issues with supersonic airplanes. One is around the airport. The Concorde flying on an afterburner, that was just loud around airport communities. Turbofans basically solve that problem. This is going to be no louder than other airplanes that are flying today. The second piece is the sonic boom. A sonic boom is a noise that you hear any time a supersonic aircraft flies over. It’s not just one time, it happens on fly over.
AMLG: You’ve said yours is going to be 100 times quieter than the Concorde, that’s significant. What will that sound like?

A supersonic boom is the sound created by an object traveling through the air faster than the sound waves it creates.


BS: It will be more like a thump than a boom. There’s a story in the news a couple of weeks ago about how the military had scrambled some F-16s that had gone supersonic at a few thousand feet, and man that rattled windows and there was a loud crack. At that altitude at that speed with that airplane design it sure is loud. But when you’re up at 60,000 feet with an airplane that’s designed to attenuate the boom it can be a lot more benign. You’re in New York City. There’s all kinds of stuff that’s noise in your background — ambulances going by, fire trucks, trains and construction noise. The sonic thump is quieter than many of those things.
AMLG: But the same restrictions are in place. Do you think this is enough to get the rules changed? I know you’ve got lobbyists, you’ve got a head of policy, you’re spending a bunch of time in D.C. and trying to get productive conversations going. How do you get movement in Washington?
BS: There are two ways it could go. One is, we manage to persuade people quickly that these rules should be fixed. I would call that our Plan A. If that happens you’re going to suddenly see a lot more investment in this space, because if you can fly supersonic over land the market size quadruples.
But sometimes rule changes happen slowly. There have been efforts to change this for 20 years that haven’t gone anywhere. So plan B is, we bring our product to market we fly supersonic over water, we fly subsonic over land. Then you’re living in a world where San Francisco to Tokyo is faster than San Francisco to D.C. A lot of people will be scratching their heads and asking, what? Why do I have to spend four more hours on the back of this crappy airplane? Let me listen to that sonic boom thing. Wait a minute that? That’s the reason I have to suffer? Let’s fix that.
AMLG: Did you ever go on the Concorde?
BS: Only in museums. It shut down when I was in my early 20s and I didn’t have twenty grand to drop on a joyride.

The Concorde in production


AMLG: I never made it either. Although my dad did. In his twenties he was fired from his job, he used his last paycheck to go on the Concorde, where he actually met his future investor who invested in his firm. A fortuitous tale before the Concorde shut down.
BS: That’s awesome. One of our board members Sam Altman who’s president of Y Combinator was telling me that he got to go on Concorde when he was seven and it was a formative experience for him. I wish I’d had that. We’re going to make it possible for our kids.
AMLG: You’re going to change everything. Only of the world’s population has ever been on an airplane. Did you know that? Seems very low.5 percent
BS: It’s very low. We’ve got to fix that too. That’s where the future of supersonic gets interesting. Today with the first airplane we’re building we’re going to make this accessible for basically business class prices. So if you can afford to buy a business class international today, then you can afford to get there in half the time.
That’s just the starting point. There’s an interesting flywheel that happens. As we were saying about Hawaii, the faster the flights the more people go more often. When more people are going more often, the ideal size of the airplane increases. So instead of being 55 seats maybe it’s 100 or 150.
When you build a bigger airplane you can make it way more fuel efficient which means that ticket prices can come down and more people can afford to fly more often which means the airplane can get bigger which means it can be more efficient. That virtuous cycle starts spinning. And as you grow the market you can afford to invest more in your technology. There’s a whole roadmap for supersonic efficiency which basically no one is working on today. But when the market exists, we start to get investment.
There’s also a tipping point at which the fastest flight actually becomes the cheapest one. Because the faster you go, the more flights you can do with the same airplane, with the same crew. I call it the speed dividend — when things are faster, you get savings. That’s going to push us to a point where faster airplanes actually have an economic advantage over slow ones.
British Airways Concorde footage

AMLG: But you’re not planning to do the full stack and run a Boom airlines?
BS: No. One hard problem at the time. What we’re doing is pretty darn ambitious. Let’s do an airline and let’s build an airplane company and a supersonic airplane company on top of that? It’s too much for a startup.
The menu on British Airways’ first commercial flight included 1969 Dom Perignon, caviar and lobster canapés, grilled fillet steak, palm heart salad with Roquefort dressing and fresh strawberries with double cream. Customers were also offered Havana cigars. [Source]

AMLG: It’s also a very different concept, bringing speed to the masses. On the British Airways Concorde flight they served Dom Perignon, caviar and lobster — that’s my conception of the Concorde. This is different, this is really making it accessible.
BS: This is not about luxury or prestige. It’s about something everyone should have.
AMLG: OK segway to a totally unrelated question. I love movies so I have to ask — favorite airplane movie? Air Force One, Top Gun, Snakes on a Plane?
BS: You have to love Top Gun. I’m reminded of a line from it: “You won’t be happy unless you’re going Mach 2 with your hair on fire.” I find that inspiring.

>>> What to look at today - 31st of May 2017

Dow -0.24% S&P -0.12% Nasdaq -0.11% Russell -0.80%
US Market closed lower after a strong rebound last week. Seven of the eleven sectors finished in negative territory with the energy (-1.3%) and financials (-0.8%) groups leading the retreat. Crude oil weighed on the energy sector early, opening Tuesday's session with a loss of over 1.0%. However, the commodity rallied in the afternoon to settle lower by just 0.3% ($49.63/bbl). For financials, banks finished lower across the board with Goldman Sachs(GS 218.42, -4.36) showing relative weakness (-2.0%). IBB -1.4%, Healthcare -0.2%, -industrials (-0.1%), materials (-0.1%), consumer staples (unch), and real estate (-0.3%),  telecom services sector (+1.4%) led Tuesday's session.  fed funds futures market continues to sit on the expectation that the Fed will raise the fed funds rate again at the June 13-14 FOMC meeting, but then hold off on another rate hike until 2018. The CME's FedWatch Tool shows only a 45.3% probability of a subsequent rate hike at the December meeting, down from 53.5% a week ago. US after hours HTZ+3% of Notes offering. Asian Mkt little changed. Chinese markets have resumed trade following the Dragon Boat Festival. Volatility in China’s bulk metals has driven a 3-4% sell-off in coking coal and iron ore futures. This is despite the official manufacturing PMI surprising expectations for a decline. Nikkei is trading in a narrow range. Data revealed industrial production rebounded at a smaller-than-expected pace. Elsewhere, miners are capping the ASX amid the China commodity volatility

Nikkei -0.25% Hang Seng -0.06% CSI +0.08% Shanghai +0.26%

Eur$ 1.1167 CNH 6.7972 CNY 6.8346 JPY 110.90 CHF 0.9757 RUB 56.6645 WTI$ 49.31 -0.70%

S&P +0.02% EuroStoxx -0.03% Dax -0.08% FTSE +0.01% SMI -0.02%

Macro :
- China May Manufacturing PMI at 51.2; Est. 51.0
- Pound Falls as Poll Shows Conservatives May Miss Their Majority
- U.S. Willing for More Talks on Plane Laptop Curbs: EU Official
- European Commission paper proposes packaging different countries' debt into new sovereign bond-backed securities
- Ross Says He’s ‘Open to Resuming’ Talks on EU Trade Deal: CNBC
- Swiss to Hike Dividend Tax in Corporate Tax Reform Review: T-A
- Trouble Brews for OPEC as Expensive Deep-Sea Oil Turns Cheap (1)

Keep an eye on :
- ADS GY : Adidas Extends Sponsorship of New Zealand Rugby Through 2023
- AKZA NA : PPG Industries Board to Discuss Akzo Nobel Within Hours
- AKZA NA : PPG Loses Request for More Time to Make Firm Bid for Akzo Nobel
- ANTO LN : To sell its 40% stake in the 69.5 MW Javiera solar park in north-central Chile to Atlas Renewable Energy; no terms disclosed
- AZN LN : UCB Drops Case Against AstraZeneca Over Patent for Synagis
- BMW GY : BMW goes for pole position in fast-growing Chinese car market - FT
- CLNX SM : American Tower Said to Explore Acquisition of Spain’s Cellnex
- BN FP : Danone to Issue 13.84m New Shares for Payment of Dividend
- EDF FP : is considering a sell down of its 65% stake in Dunkerque LNG as part of its EUR 10bn divestment programme, two sources briefed on the matter said.
- EOAN GY : E.On Said to Hire Goldman to Explore Uniper Stake Sale: Reuters
- ERICB SS : Ericsson Welcomes Cevian as Shareholder, Spokesman Says, Cevian Capital’s Gardell Supports Ericsson CEO’s Plan
- ENX FP : Euronext Says Chief Operating Offier Jos Dijsselhof to Leave
- IG IM : Strategic Update: to cut costs by 2018 of more than 15% compared to 2016
- LHN VX : LafargeHolcim to Start CHF1 Billion Share Buyback in June
- MTX GY : MTU Seeks Engine Construction Alliances, Sees Earnings Jump: BZ
- NDA SS : Finland Won’t Make ‘Special Offer’ for Nordea, Sipila Says: HS
- NOVOB DC : Novo Nordisk Losing Market Share in Europe, Doustdar Tells JP
- RNO FP : Renault Mulls Launching Zoe Electric Car in S.Korea 2019: Yonhap
- RBI AV : Raiffeisen Says Its Talks With KNF About Poland IPO Continue
- SW FP : Sodexo CEO Landel to Retire in Jan. 2018; Machuel to Replace Him
- SYNN VX : Syngenta Says About 95% of Shares Tendered to ChemChina
- UCB BB : UCB Drops Case Against AstraZeneca Over Patent for Synagis
- UN01 GY : E.On Said to Hire Goldman to Explore Uniper Stake Sale: Reuters
- VACN SW : VAT Placing by Holders Prices at CHF120 Per Share
- VIE GY : Veolia Water France Aims To Double Operating Profit in 2020
- VIV FP : Vivendi CEO Said Poised to Take Over as Telecom Italia Chairman