Wirecard makes serious allegations against the Financial Times
New dispute over the payment service provider: The Financial Times defends itself against serious allegations that Wirecard has raised in a letter. At the center is an ominous audio recording.The permanent feud between Wirecard and the renowned British financial paper "Financial Times" (FT) puts a lot of money at stake.
Source: dpaDusseldorf, Frankfurt It is far more than a dispute between a DAX company and a medium. It's not just about the reputation of a company in the elite class of the German capital market. The permanent feud between Wirecard and the prestigious British financial paper "Financial Times" (FT) puts a lot of money at stake, as every new critical article on Wirecard was usually followed by heavy stock market losses.
The core of the dispute: Wirecard accuses the FT of spreading false accusations , the newspaper writes about strange cash flows and a lack of compliance at the company.
Now the dispute has gotten a new dimension: In a letter Wirecard asks the newspaper to publish until further notice, no articles about the Group, and instead to start an internal investigation to detect misconduct in its own ranks.
Reason: Wirecard claims in a letter that it has "irrefutable evidence of collaboration between Financial Times employees and short sellers". This refers to investors who bet on falling prices of a particular stock.
The newspaper should "refrain from any publication that could lead directly or indirectly to market manipulation or insider trading in connection with Wirecard shares," says Wirecard. The letter from the law firm Herbert Smith Freehills, which Wirecard represents, and the statement of the German corporation contained therein are available to Handelsblatt.
According to the written Wirecard statement, the trigger for the latest escalation is the sound recording of a conversation that took place last Wednesday in London. In this, the British businessman Nick X. reported to the confidant of another investor of another upcoming critical article in the FT, it says in the statement. He himself has already built a five million pound short position, pending the negative article that will be released in the next 48 hours.
"Another distraction attack on the journalism of the FT"
The businessman had suggested to his interlocutor to speculate even with five million pounds on a price decline of the Wirecard share. In return for his tip he had demanded from the potential investor half of the expected profit. And he claimed to have successfully speculated against Wirecard several times in the past, each based on an upcoming Financial Times article.
Wirecard did not want to comment officially on the audio file and the lawyer's threat against the FT. The authenticity of the audio material could not be verified so far. The investor who initiated the recording did not want to comment officially. Nick X was not available for a statement. Documents available to the Handelsblatt show that the FT was indeed researching another report on Wirecard and had previously confronted the Group with a series of critical questions.
Wirecard responded to these questions "with another diversionary attack on FT journalism," the newspaper said. "There was no collusion between FT journalists and short sellers or other third parties about the content or release date of FT articles on Wirecard," a spokeswoman for the newspaper said.
In his statement to the business paper, Wirecard describes the genesis of the recording as follows: In recent days, the corporation has received information that Nick X. is trying to raise money for a short-term speculative attack on Wirecard ahead of another negative FT article. For this purpose, Nick X. and a business partner met with potential investors on the morning of July 17th.
Recording is at the Munich Public Prosecutor's Office
This conversation was "legally in accordance with all applicable British laws" been added. The record has now been passed along with further evidence and documents to the criminal investigation authorities in Germanyand the United Kingdom , it says in the Wirecard statement. According to the Handelsblatt, the material has since been received by the Munich Public Prosecutor's Office.
The agency has been investigating potential shorts and contacts since February . An investor had filed a criminal complaint in Munich against the FT. A London stockbroker had said he had been informed before the release of a larger article on January 30th. As a result, Wirecard filed civil action against the FT. In April, Bafin filed criminal charges against a single-digit number of people, including FT journalists.
The newspaper had repeatedly reported dubious events and a search at the Wirecard Singapore office. At the end of March, the Group acknowledged that employees could have been prosecuted under local law.
According to findings of the German financial regulator Bafin, about which the Handelsblatt reported a week ago , 2019 scarcely new shorts in the environment of the FT reports entered the speculation. Rather, they are well-known actors. The 2019 active shorts were "known insofar as they held mainly in the past net short positions in Wirecard AG," said the responsible Federal Ministry of Finance.
Against Wirecard is speculated for years, from 2016 to 2018, the Bafin registered five attacks. There are no indications that short-shifters have broken their positions to stay below the reporting threshold of half a percent of the share capital.
Significantly increased the positions from the 1st and from 7 February 2019. After indications of planned attacks, the Bafin had adopted on February 18, a temporary short sale ban on Wirecard shares - an unprecedented step. The ban expired in April.
Gapping up
In reaction to earnings/guidance:
- NVS +5.5%, EBAY +5.3%, SM +4.7%, PM +2.7%, ALLY +1.9%, BX +1.6%, TSM +1.4%, DHR +0.8%, DOV +0.8%, MS +0.7%, UNH +0.6%, ADTN +0.5%
Other news:
- EPRT +1.4% (prices secondary offering by selling shareholders of 22,859,406 shares of common stock at $19.75 per share)
- VOD +1.1% (confirms that the European Commission has cleared its acquisition of Liberty Global's (LBTYA) operations in Germany, the Czech Republic, Hungary and Romania
- SDRL +0.5% (has secured a nine well contract with three options, each for two wells, for the West Gemini in West Africa)
Analyst comments:
- NGVT +0.8% (initiated with an Outperform at BMO Capital Markets)
- AAPL +0.5% (upgraded to Outperform from Mkt Perform at Raymond James)