FT : Bhutan’s bold plan to introduce the world’s highest tourist levy

Bhutan’s bold plan to introduce the world’s highest tourist levy
Himalayan kingdom will finally reopen borders in September — but with a ‘sustainable development fee’ of $200 per person per day

Tourist hotspots around the world are considering how best to regulate and manage the return of visitors post-pandemic — Venice, for example, will introduce a daily tax of between €3 and €10 in January. The little Himalayan kingdom of Bhutan, however, is taking the concept to another level. When its borders finally reopen on September 23, tourists will have to pay a “sustainable development fee” of $200 per person per day.

The move, which will be closely watched by other governments and tourism agencies, is designed to encourage “high value, low volume” tourism, maximising economic benefits while limiting the impact on Bhutan’s traditional culture. The country has long been comparatively isolated, not allowing the first tourists to visit until 1974, and not getting television until 1999.

“Covid-19 has allowed us to reset — to rethink how the sector can be best structured and operated, so that it not only benefits Bhutan economically, but socially as well, while keeping carbon footprints low,” said Tandi Dorji, the country’s foreign minister and chair of the Tourism Council of Bhutan, as he announced the new policy. “In the long run, our goal is to create high-value experiences for visitors, and well-paying and professional jobs for our citizens.”

The government says the fee will be used to offset carbon emissions by planting trees and investing in hydropower and electric vehicles, as well as to fund community-led tourism projects.

Some tour operators, however, have criticised the move, saying it risks stifling the sector’s much-needed recovery. World Expeditions says the move will push the price of one of its most popular trips, the 27-day Snowman trek, from £5,890 to almost £9,000. “Increasing the price of a trek by 50 per cent will have huge impact on the future of Bhutan’s tourism industry and, after two years of Covid, would leave us very worried about the potential impact for the livelihoods of our colleagues within Bhutan,” said Gordon Steer, the company’s UK manager.

Tourism to the country was already highly controlled. Previously visitors from countries other than India, Bangladesh and the Maldives, had to book guided package tours rather than travel independently and pay a “minimum daily package price” of between $200 and $290 per night. From that $65 went to the government, and the rest towards the travel arrangements. Under the new scheme, visitors will have more flexibility, being able to book hotels and guides direct rather than as part of package tour. Indian tourists will have to pay the new sustainable development fee, but at a much reduced rate, currently only $15.

>>> US After Hours Summary: SNAP -26.6% sells off on earnings, takes online ad s

After Hours Summary: SNAP -26.6% sells off on earnings, takes online ad space with it; ISRG -12.9%, STX -10.2%, SAM -8.6% also down big on earnings; HNGR +24.3% jumps as it gets acquired

After Hours Gainers:

Companies trading higher in after hours in reaction to earnings/guidance: OZK +5.1%, UFPI +4.1%, THC +3.9%, VICR +3.7%, FFBC +1.8%, SCHL +1.8%, AKA +1%, GBCI +0.1%

Companies trading higher in after hours in reaction to news: HNGR +24.3% (to be acquired by Patient Square Capital for $18.75/sh), NOVT +7.6% (to join S&P MidCap 400), SIX +4.1% (to move to S&P SmallCap 600 from S&P MidCap 400), VCEL +1.2% (announces publication of Epicel study), TXT +0.1% (awarded $354 mln U.S. Army contract)

After Hours Losers:

Companies trading lower in after hours in reaction to earnings/guidance: SNAP -26.6% (also declines to provide guidance due to uncertain operating environment; also authorizes $500 mln stock repurchase program), ISRG -12.9% (also increases share buyback auth to $3.5 bln), STX -10.2%, CRSR -10.2%, SIVB -8.7%, SAM -8.6%, COF -5.4%, RHI -4.9%, BJRI -3.5%, MAT -2.8%, PPG -0.2%, ASB -0.1%, WAL -0.1%

Companies trading lower in after hours in reaction to news: TTD -6.9% (in sympathy with weak SNAP earnings), SBTX -6.6% (to merge with ARS Pharma), PINS -6.6% (in sympathy with weak SNAP earnings), WDC -6.2% (in sympathy with weak STX earnings), APPS -5.9% (in sympathy with weak SNAP earnings), META -4.9% (in sympathy with weak SNAP earnings), PUBM -4.8% (in sympathy with weak SNAP earnings), MGNI -4.4% (in sympathy with weak SNAP earnings), ROKU -3.4% (in sympathy with weak SNAP earnings), TNDM -3% (acquires infusion set developer Capillary Biomedical), MU -2.8% (in sympathy with weak STX earnings), GOOG -2.6% (in sympathy with weak SNAP earnings), TWTR -2% (in sympathy with weak SNAP earnings), WULF -1.9% (stock offering), FUBO -1.6% (FOXA expands streaming service FOX Nation across FUBO), SPCE -0.5% (Virtuoso adds SPCE to its global portfolio), SYF -0.1% (files mixed securities shelf offering)

>>> US Close Dow +0,51% S&P +0,99% Nasdaq +1,36% Russell +0,48%

Closing Stock Market Summary

Relatively negative headlines this morning fueled lingering growth concerns that led the stock market to a modestly lower open. The market soon regained upside momentum, though, trending higher for most of the day and finishing near its best levels of the session. The S&P 500, which flirted with 3,600 in mid-June, closed a whisker shy of 4,000.

The headlines this morning included central bank news, corporate news, and U.S. economic data. The Bank of Japan lowered its 2022 GDP growth forecast to 2.4% from 2.9% and the ECB announced a larger-than-expected 50-basis point increase for its key lending rates.

Corporate news included homebuilder D.R. Horton (DHI 75.83, +2.75, +3.8%) cutting its FY22 revenue outlook and saying it saw a moderation in demand in June and July. Also, Microsoft (MSFT 264.84, +2.57, +1.0%) said it will slow its pace of new hire activity.

As for economic data, initial jobless claims topped 250,000 for the first time since last November; the Philadelphia Fed Index was negative in July (-12.3) on a further drop in new orders activity; and the Leading Economic Index for June was down 0.8%.

Buyers were not deterred by these factors, suggesting to some that the growth concerns resonating today were already priced in during the weak first half of year. Market breadth showed some buyer conviction with advancing issues leading declining issues by a roughly 3-to-2 margin at both the NYSE and the Nasdaq.

The mega caps were an important directional driver with the Vanguard Mega Cap Growth ETF (MGK) closing up 1.5% versus a 0.6% gain in the Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (RSP) and a 0.9% gain in the S&P 500.

For the mega caps, the biggest move was made by Tesla (TSLA 815.12, +72.62, +9.8%), which reported better-than-expected earnings after yesterday's close. Tesla's outperformance gave a nice boost to the S&P 500 consumer discretionary sector (+2.3%), which was at the top of the leaderboard today.

Other parts of the market did not fare as well today as the Dow, Nasdaq, and S&P 500. Small and mid cap stocks underperformed on the day with the Russell 2000 (+0.1%) and the S&P Mid Cap 400 (+0.6%) closing behind the broader market.

Another weak spot today was energy as oil prices fell. WTI crude oil futures settled the session down 3.4% to $96.49/bbl. Natural gas futures fell 1.2% to $7.79/mmbtu. Unleaded gasoline futures fell 3.7% to $3.15/gal.

The energy sector (-1.7%) was one of two to close in negative territory. The other sector that closed with losses was communication services (-0.2%). Communication services was held down by AT&T (T 18.92, -1.56, -7.6%), T-Mobile (TMUS 133.18, -4.27, -3.1%), and Verizon (VZ 47.65, -1.42, -3.0%), which all traded down after AT&T beat on earnings but lowered its free cash flow guidance. 

Separately, buyers stepped in to the Treasury market after economic data this morning stoked slowdown concerns. The 2-yr note yield closed down 15 basis points at 3.09% while the 10-yr note yield fell 13 basis points to 2.91%.

The Treasury market was certainly more responsive to slowdown worries than the stock market was. Stocks for the most part handled worries about an economic slowdown relatively well, as participants were clinging to the notion that stocks have priced in a slowdown already and that the arrival of weak data will compel the Fed to take less aggressive rate hike steps in coming months.

Reviewing today's economic data:

  • Weekly Initial Claims 251K (consensus 240K); Prior 244K; Weekly Continuing Claims 1.384 mln; Prior was revised to 1.333 mln from 1.331 mln
    • The key takeaway from the report is that it reflects some loosening in a tight labor market that will temper some of the payroll growth expectations for July, as this report covered the period in which the survey for the July Employment Situation Report was conducted.
  • July Philadelphia Fed Index -12.3 (consensus -1.2); Prior -3.3
  • June Leading Economic Index -0.8% 
  • Weekly EIA Natural Gas Inventories showed a build of 32 bcf vs a build of 58 bcf last week

Friday's economic data is limited to the July IHS Markit Manufacturing PMI preliminary (prior 52.7) reading and July IHS Markit Services PMI preliminary (prior 52.7) reading at 9:45 a.m. ET.

  • Dow Jones Industrial Average: -11.4% YTD
  • S&P 400: -14.9% YTD
  • S&P 500: -16.1% YTD
  • Russell 2000: -18.2% YTD
  • Nasdaq Composite: -22.9% YTD