>>> What to look at today - 27th of December 2016

Generally markets remained mixed in thin holiday trade (Australia, New Zealand and Hong Kong remain closed). US dollar remained a bit firmer against most currencies, gold remained higher by nearly $3.50 throughout the session. China navy activities continue to keep the region on edge. Russian Ruble rose overnight attributed to expected corporate tax payments in Russia and higher oil. BoJ's new policy framework aimed at keeping long term interest rates around 0% will help maximize the benefits of global tailwinds for Japan's economy; Japan to take big step toward beating deflation in 2017 - speaking to Keidanren business lobby. Toshiba, 6502.JP: May take an extraordinary loss of ¥100B (prior $850M) on US nuclear ops - Nikkei; Not the source on US nuclear ops loss report; may book charge on US nuclear operations and a one time loss on CB&I Stone & Webster value.

Nikkei +0.03% Hang Seng -0.28% CSI -0.09% Shanghai -0.16%

Eur$ 1.0445 CNH 6.9576 CNY 6.9497 JPY 117.32 CHF 1.0278 RUB 60.9267 WTI $53.06 +0.08%

S&P -0.02% EuroStoxx +0.03% Dax -0.05% SMI +0.18%

Macro :
- Greek Debt-Relief Measures Unblocked by Eurozone, Move eases tensions between Greece and its creditors over bailout
- Russian Military Plane Carry 100 Missing After Takeoff: Tass
- Italy Plan Gives Banks a Year to Apply for Debt Guarantee: Rtrs - http://reut.rs/2hdUNRN
- Magnitude 7.7 Quake Hits 24 Miles SW Puerto Quellon,Chile: USGS

Keep an eye on :
- ABE SM : Abertis Buys Two India Road Projects From Macquarie, Mint Says
- BP IM : Banco Popolare, BPM Agree With Unions on 2,100 Early Retirements
- BMPS IM : *MONTE PASCHI IN TECHNICAL HALT
- BMPS IM : Monte dei Paschi Says ECB Sees Need for EU8.8b in Capital
- BMPS IM : Paschi Set for New Industrial Plan by January: Messaggero
- BMPS IM : Paschi CEO Confident Bank Will Be Relaunched With New Plan: Sole
- BIIB US : Biogen Estimates Seen Rising on Spinraza Approval, RBC Says
- BPOST BB : Bpost Says Avg Tariff Increase on Domestic Mail 1.5% for 2017
- DIS US : Disney Says ‘Rogue One’ Global Gross Est. $523.8m as of Sunday
- PPB LN : Paddy Power Wins Bid to Run Gambling Ops for NZRB: Sunday Times
- MS IM : Vivendi public offer on Mediaset would be blocked by communications regulator - Il Sole 24 Ore
- MS IM : Mediaset and Fininvest appoint advisors in Vivendi dispute, MS app. JPM & Intesa, Finvinvest Unicredit
- OHL SM : Villar Mir Readies OHL Stake Sale to HNA: Confidencial
- THULE SS : Thule CEO Sees North American Market Normalizing in 2017: DI
- 6502 JP : Toshiba May Book as Much as 500b Yen U.S. Nuclear Ops Loss: NHK --> -12% in Tokyo
- VIV FP : Vivendi public offer on Mediaset would be blocked by communications regulator - Il Sole 24 Ore
- VIV FP : Universal’s Animated ‘Sing’ Seen Earning $33M on Weekend
- VOW3 GY : VW Workers’ Council Chief Skeptical About Electric Cars: FAZ

>>> Asian Update

Asia Mid-Session Market Update: Japan data weaker overall; currencies range bound; Toshiba may take loss

***US Session Highlights***
- US markets closed for holiday Monday and will re-open Tuesday December 27th

***US markets on close Friday: Dow +0.07%, S&P500 +0.12%, Nasdaq +0.48%***
- Best Sector in S&P500: Healthcare
- Worst Sector in S&P500: Consumer Discretionary
- Biggest gainers: WMB +4.2%; RHT +3.4%; DNB +3.7%
- Biggest losers: CME -3.1%; CTAS -3.1%; BBBY -1.5%
- At the close: VIX 11.44 (+0.01pts); Treasuries: 2-yr 1.206% +-0.01bps), 10-yr 2.54% (-0.008bps), 30-yr 3.116% (-0.013bps)

***Key economic data:***
- (CN) CHINA NOV INDUSTRIAL PROFITS Y/Y: 14.5% V 9.8% PRIOR; YTD: 9.4% V 8.6% PRIOR
- (JP) JAPAN NOV JOBLESS RATE: 3.1% V 3.0%E; Job to applicant: 1.41 v 1.41e (highest level since July 1991)
- (JP) JAPAN NOV OVERALL HOUSEHOLD SPENDING Y/Y: -1.5% V 0.1%E; 9th consecutive decline
- (JP) JAPAN NOV NATIONAL CPI Y/Y: 0.5% V 0.5%E; CPI EX FRESH FOOD (CORE) Y/Y: -0.4% V -0.3%E (9th straight decline, longest streak since 2011)
- (JP) JAPAN DEC TOKYO CPI Y/Y: 0.0% V 0.4%E; CPI EX-FRESH FOOD Y/Y: -0.6% V -0.4%E
- (KR) South Korea Dec Consumer Confidence: 94.2 (7.5 year low) v 95.8 prior
- (IL) ISRAEL CENTRAL BANK (BOI) LEAVES BASE RATE UNCHANGED AT 0.10%, 23rd straight month of hold
- (FR) France Nov Net Change in Jobseekers: -31.8K v -4.0Ke; Total Jobseekers: 3.45M v 3.477Me
- (JP) Japan Nov BOJ National CPI Ex Fresh Food, Energy (core-core) Y/Y: 0.2% v 0.2%e
- (JP) JAPAN DEC SMALL BUSINESS CONFIDENCE: 48.8 V 48.3 PRIOR

***Asia Session Notable Observations, Speakers and Press***
- Generally markets remained mixed in thin holiday trade (Australia, New Zealand and Hong Kong remain closed). US dollar remained a bit firmer against most currencies, gold remained higher by nearly $3.50 throughout the session. China navy activities continue to keep the region on edge.
- Russian Ruble rose overnight attributed to expected corporate tax payments in Russia and higher oil
- (JP) Bank of Japan (BOJ) Gov Kuroda: BoJ's new policy framework aimed at keeping long term interest rates around 0% will help maximize the benefits of global tailwinds for Japan's economy; Japan to take big step toward beating deflation in 2017 - speaking to Keidanren business lobby
- Toshiba, 6502.JP: May take an extraordinary loss of ¥100B (prior $850M) on US nuclear ops - Nikkei; Not the source on US nuclear ops loss report; may book charge on US nuclear operations and a one time loss on CB&I Stone & Webster value
- China Issues several papers and comments covering space activity, cyber security and intelligence reform
- (CN) Shanghai Avg New Home prices w/w +21.3% to CNY47.4/sqm v -4.6% prior; New home sales w/w -22.4% to 116K sqm v +14.2% prior - Uwin
- (CN) China Commerce Min Gao Hucheng: Sees 2016 FDI at CNY785B, +6% y/y

***Asian Equity Indices/Futures (00:00ET)***
- Nikkei -0.3%, Hang Seng closed, Shanghai Composite +0.1%, ASX200 closed, Kospi +0.15%
- Equity Futures: S&P500 -0.6%; Nasdaq +0.3%, Dax -0.5%

***FX ranges/Commodities/Fixed Income (00:00ET)***
- EUR 1.0433-1.0458; JPY 117.06-117.46; AUD 0.7273-0.7191; NZD 0.6879-0.6899
- Feb Gold +0.40% at 1,138/oz; Feb Crude Oil +0.17% at $53.11/brl; Mar Copper -0.01% at $2.46/lb
- USD/JPY: (JP) Japan Chief Cabinet Sec Suga: Attributes yen depreciation following election of Donald Trump to "proper crisis management" of exchange rates by Japan Govt
- (CN) PBOC to inject combined CNY80B in 7-day, 14-day and 28-day reverse repo operation vs. CNY70B prior
- (CN) PBOC SETS YUAN MID POINT AT 6.9462 V 6.9459 PRIOR
- (JP) Japan MoF sells ¥2.09T v ¥2.3T indicated in 2-yr 0.1% JGBs; Avg yield: -0.157% v -0.156% prior; bid to cover: 4.51x (highest since June) v 4.27x prior

***Asia equities / Notables / movers by sector***
- Consumer discretionary: Start Today Co 3092.JP +1.8% (raised to outperform)
- Financials: Sealand Securities Co 000750.CN halted (update on bond dispute); Guotai Junan International Holdings 601211.CN -0.2% (requested to increase internal checks)
- Industrials: Shimadzu Corp 7701.JP -0.2% (SMBC Nikko upgraded to outperform ); Fuji Heavy Industries 7270.JP +0.5% (Nov result
- Technology: Toshiba Corporation 6502.JP -13.5% (speculation on US nuclear ops loss); NavInfo Co 002405.CN -0.1%, Tencent 700.HK -1.0% (JV with Tencent and NavInfo); Nintendo 7974.JP -0.8% (plans to release 3 smartphone games a year); Sharp Corp 6753.JP +3.4% (guidance)
- Materials: Itochu Corp 8001.JP +0.6% (acquisition)
- Healthcare: Ono Pharmaceutical Co 4528.JP +6.0% (seeks wider opdivo use); Chugai Pharma 4519.JP +0.7% (emicizumab antibody meets target in phase 3 study for hemophilia)
- Telecom: KDDI Corp 9433.JP +0.9% (forms tie-up)

>>> What to look at this Xmas - 24th, 25th & 26th of December 2016

Weekly Update
Dow +0.46% S&P +0.25% Nasdaq +0.47% Russell +0.52% EuroStoxx +0.45% FTSE +0.81% CAC +0.13% Dax +0.40% Ibex -0.48% MIB +1.74% SMI +0.06% Nikkei +0.80% Hnag Seng -2.03% CSI -1.43% Shanghai -0.41%
US indices largely marked time heading into the final trading sessions of 2016. Volumes were commensurate with the seasonal slowdown associated with holiday trading schedules, running significantly below their 3-month averages. The hope that has manifested itself as the 'Trump bump' appears to be fading as the reality sets in that his administration is only week's away from taking the reins. Concerns about a potential trade war with China and Trump's tweet about expanding the nuclear arsenal raised questions about how aggressive the new government will be in global affairs, nevertheless the VIX volatility index moved below the July low in a continued sign of investor complacency. Stocks remain just below the recent all-time highs while the Dollar index seems to have stalled out around 1.03. In general, currencies, fixed income, and commodities remain confined within their recent ranges with the US 10-year yield consolidating in the mid 2.5% range. Central Banks including the BOJ and Riksbank kept policy on course at their scheduled meetings and it appears the ECB is likely to wait until after Germany's October election before making any significant policy moves. FedEx and Nike headlined the late December earnings reports and neither generated much in the way of excitement, but Micron shares surged and helped put a bid under other names in the semiconductor space after beating Q1 expectations forecasting Q2 results well above the analyst's consensus. For the week the DJIA rose 0.5%, the S&P500 gained 0.2%, and the Nasdaq added 0.5%.


Macro :
- Greek Debt-Relief Measures Unblocked by Eurozone, Move eases tensions between Greece and its creditors over bailout

Keep an eye on :
- MS IM : Vivendi public offer on Mediaset would be blocked by communications regulator - Il Sole 24 Ore
- MS IM : Mediaset and Fininvest appoint advisors in Vivendi dispute, MS app. JPM & Intesa, Finvinvest Unicredit
- VIV FP : Vivendi public offer on Mediaset would be blocked by communications regulator - Il Sole 24 Ore

>>> Asian Update

mAsia Mid-Session and Weekend Update: China President Xi spooks the markets on slowing growth; while China amps up naval activity in the Pacific

***US Market Highlights***
- US markets closed for holiday Monday and will re-open Tuesday December 27th
- BA: Iran Deputy Transportation Min: Iran will only pay ~50% of announced price of $16.8B for 80 new planes from Boeing (implies ~$8.4B) - Iran's official IRNA news agency

***US markets on close Friday: Dow +0.07%, S&P500 +0.12%, Nasdaq +0.48%***
- Best Sector in S&P500: Healthcare
- Worst Sector in S&P500: Consumer Discretionary
- Biggest gainers: WMB +4.2%; RHT +3.4%; DNB +3.7%
- Biggest losers: CME -3.1%; CTAS -3.1%; BBBY -1.5%
- At the close: VIX 11.44 (+0.01pts); Treasuries: 2-yr 1.206% +-0.01bps), 10-yr 2.54% (-0.008bps), 30-yr 3.116% (-0.013bps)

***Friday and Over the Weekend***
- (IT) Italy draft decree on bank rescue plan: Italy govt will be able to provide guarantee of banks' debt until June 30, 2017
- (CN) China President Xi: Said to express openness for China to have growth below 6.5% target; due to rising debt and concerns about the global outlook after Trump's election victory. Target does not have to be met if doing so creates too much risk. China will report PMI data on Dec 31st.
- (RU) Russia has told the US it would like to delay for several days ceasefire in Syria's Aleppo - press over weekend
- (CL) Magnitude 7.6 earthquake rocked southern Chile Sunday morning; No fatalities or major damage were reported

***Key economic data***
- (JP) Bank of Japan (BOJ) Monetary Policy Oct 31st-Nov 1st Meeting Minutes : Most members shares recognition that momentum towards price goal being maintained

***Asia Session Notable Observations, Speakers and Press***
- In Asia Australia, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Malaysia, New Zealand, Philippines, Singapore markets are closed.
- Chinese markets opened lower by 0.5% after President Xi warned about growth.
- (CN) China holding military exercises in Pacific Ocean including its Liaoning aircraft carrier; seen as a move to show off its power to US's new incoming President Trump - regional press
- (CN) China Op Ed: China needs to keep financial market liquidity stable and regulate its "money gates" to prevent asset bubbles, but it also needs to ensure a lack of liquidity doesn't cause financial stress - Chinese press
- (CN) Beijing to increase property controls to keep home prices stable next year - Xinhua

***Asian Equity Indices (21:00ET)***
- Nikkei -0.1%, Hang Seng closed, Shanghai Composite -1.1%, ASX200 closed, Kospi +0.1%

***FX ranges/Commodities/Fixed Income (21:00ET)***
- EUR 1.0444-1.0458; JPY 117.05-117.38; AUD 0.71643-0.7188; NZD 0.6875-0.6903
- (CN) PBOC SETS YUAN MID POINT AT 6.9459 V 6.9463 PRIOR
- (CN) PBOC to inject combined CNY70B in 7-day, 14-day and 28-day reverse repo operation vs. CNY145B prior
- (KR) Bank of Korea (BOK) sells KRW0.4T in 1-yr monetary stabilization bonds; avg yield 1.61% v 1.53% prior

(TechCrunch) Automile raises $7.5 million for fleet vehicle management software

--> Read across Verizon & Tom Tom

Automile raises $7.5 million for fleet vehicle management software
Automile, a fleet logistics and management startup, has closed a $7.5 million Series A round led by SaaStr with participation from Salesforce Ventures, Niklas Zennstrom, Dawn Capital and Point Nine Capital.
Automile provides customers with a box to install under the vehicle’s dashboard to track mileage, trips and provide route tracking. Automile ships its tracking device to customers for free. Customers pay anywhere from $5.90 per vehicle per month to $19 per vehicle per month for the service once they start to use it.
The most expensive plan gets you mileage logs, trip statistics, expense management tools, real-time location tracking, accident alerts, risk reduction tools and predictive maintenance. Automile currently has 6,000 customers, including Samsung and Nestlé. But a lot of its customers are in the businesses of plumbing, cleaning, oil, farming and concrete.
“Everything that moves around in the market around our cities is what we do,” Automile CEO Jens Nylander told me.



The logistics business for enterprise (think repair services, construction and agriculture) is one of the industries that technology has yet to really dive into. It turns out that most commercial vehicles (about 80 percent) in the U.S. don’t have fleet management tools at all, according to Berg Insight.
With the exception of Fleetmatics, which Verizon (owner of TC via acquisition of AOL) bought back in August to expand its fleet management offerings, Nylander said that few startups are focused on innovating in the corporate logistics arena. What makes Automile different from Fleetmatics, Nylander said, is that its customers can easily install the device themselves, instead of having to wait for a professional to come out and install it for them.
Automile anticipates a year-end revenue of $3 million, up from $800,000 last year. With the new funding, Automile plans to more aggressively expand into Europe and build out its engineering team in Palo Alto.

Barron's : Why 2017 Could Be the Year of the Stockpicker

Why 2017 Could Be the Year of the Stockpicker
With stocks and sectors no longer moving in unison, there will be a premium on savvy investment selection.

There’s a hoary Wall Street saying about investing: It’s not a stock market, but a market of stocks. That’s been untrue, however, for the past few years, during which stock sectors have tended to move up and down nearly in unison.

Since the end of the 2008 financial crisis, correlations between sectors have averaged 82%, compared with the 50% norm, notes Nicholas Colas, Convergex’s chief market strategist. This led to the mass “risk on, risk off” trade—which made it hard for active fund managers to beat their benchmarks, often the indexes that many exchange-traded funds mimic. “If all stocks are correlated, then it’s hard to pick, say, a 50-stock portfolio that will outperform,” says Robert Turner, managing principal at Turner Investments.

Yet there are a few inchoate signs that correlations are easing. If so, it’s something that should warm the hearts of suffering active-fund managers. The reality has been grim for them. According to Morningstar, active U.S. funds have seen $478 billion in net asset outflows over the past three years, with total assets now at $5.4 trillion. Over that period, passive funds—including exchange-traded ones—have outperformed their active competitors. During that stretch, they’ve gathered a net $914 billion in assets; they now have $4.2 trillion.

Until Donald J. Trump’s election as president, investors mainly cared about central-bank policy—to the exclusion of nearly everything else. High correlation meant that stock or sector selection mattered less than where rates were going.

The low-interest-rate environment and muted U.S. economic growth tended to decrease stock-return dispersion, says David Kostin, chief U.S. equity strategist at Goldman Sachs. When equities aren’t moving in unison, the opportunities for good stockpickers are better, he observes. Since the election, uncertainty has increased, and there is less slack in the economy, both of which suggest that dispersion will continue to rise in 2017, he adds.

Colas observes that in recent weeks, sector correlations have dropped dramatically, to 56.8%. Sectors have finally broken away from the broad market trend, he says.

Additionally, notes Bespoke Investment Group in a recent report, since the election there have been just two “all or nothing” days during a period in which the market rose 5%, an unusual combination. (Such days occur when the daily advance/decline reading for the Standard & Poor’s 500 index exceeds plus or minus 400, meaning stocks are moving up or down in unison.)

Kostin, Colas, and BIG agree that stock-picking is likely to take on added importance in 2017 and beyond. Interest rates won’t remain an on-off market toggle switch, they say. Instead, other factors will create both uncertainty and opportunity: tax reform, infrastructure spending, deregulation, and better economic growth. “Active managers will have a target-rich environment filled with stocks and sectors that will trade very differently from the market as a whole,” Colas predicts.

Can these managers breathe a sigh of relief? Hardly. The popularity of passive investment funds, which typically offer lower fees and are easier to understand, is here to stay.

“The barn door is open, and the cows are out,” says Turner. To compete, active managers will have to improve portfolio construction, he says. In addition to picking the right stocks, they must harness technology and add more quantitatively-based factors, which tend to be more predictive, to their investing arsenal.

Think of ETFs as the market’s version of a wolf pack picking off and weeding out the slower and weaker active fund managers in the herd, those with consistently poor returns and high fees. Santa might bring a year of opportunity in 2017 for portfolio managers—but only to the good ones.

EXPECT SHARE BUYBACKS to make a big comeback in 2017.

During the third quarter, S&P 500 companies spent $116 billion on stock repurchases, 28% below the total a year earlier, according to FactSet. Blame that partly on management uncertainty ahead of the elections.

However, if the past is any guide, should taxes on repatriated cash be reduced, as markets anticipate, many companies will bump up their buybacks. And if earnings growth perks up, as Wall Street expects, that would be another reason for more repurchases. A recent BIG research note says the average S&P 100 index member—among the very biggest market-cap stocks—has seen its total shares outstanding fall by 7% in the past five years, with 20 having 15% drops.

Companies that have shrunk their share base the most have outpaced the market, BIG says. Atop that list of 20: American International Group (ticker: AIG), Lowe’s (LOW), Allstate (ALL), and Home Depot (HD), whose stocks are all up roughly 200% in the past five years, more than double the market’s rise.

Hard to see why repatriated money would go anywhere else but buybacks.

WSJ : Sovereign-Wealth Funds Threatened by Government Spending

Sovereign-Wealth Funds Threatened by Government Spending
Kazakhstan’s experience shows how fast these funds can dwindle

Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbayev says the country’s sovereign-wealth fund has the money to help wean the central Asian nation off its dependence on oil revenues and build an economy of entrepreneurs.
The 76-year-old president, who led Kazakhstan to independence from the Soviet Union 25 years ago, earlier this year told visitors to the new capital city he built that “Kazakhs have never lived as well as they live today” and the nation’s savings help maintain living standards.
But since Mr. Nazarbayev created the so-called National Fund in 2000, his government has withdrawn $83 billion from it, according to a Wall Street Journal analysis of data from Kazakhstan’s central bank that was corroborated by the International Monetary Fund. The National Fund has a balance of $61 billion as of Nov. 30, down 21% from its peak in August 2014.

Leaders of petrostates from Kazakhstan to Azerbaijan, Russia and Venezuela have spent billions of dollars from sovereign-wealth funds as the relatively low price of oil has pressured government budgets. Spending the money deposited in these funds—rather than just the investment income they generate—is threatening the funds’ long-term viability.
“It’s really important for Kazakhstan and other oil-producing developing nations to convert these savings into a permanent windfall,” said Angela Cummine, an Oxford University academic and author of “Citizen’s Wealth,” a book examining sovereign-wealth funds. “It is very unwise to draw down the fund until it is depleted because then the major windfall from oil will be gone but economic problems will remain.”
Kazakh Prime Minister Bakytzhan Sagintayev acknowledged the problem in December. “If we continue spending in this way, we won’t have a National Fund soon,” he told business leaders.
The government in November published a draft decree “to prevent further reduction” of the National Fund. The government proposes spending less of it and investing more of the fund’s money in higher-yielding assets such as stocks and private equity rather than bonds, according to the draft. On Dec. 22, an official at the central bank said that the president has signed the new decree.
The scale of spending from the fund has prompted some people to express concern. That can be a risky move in a nation where, according to New York nonprofit Human Rights Watch, criticism of the government is regularly suppressed.
ENLARGE

“It was a wise idea to create the National Fund,” Rakhim Oshakbayev, a former deputy minister for investment and development, said in an interview. “When we started spending the money in the National Fund, it was like opening Pandora’s box.”
Information on how the fund is spent isn’t readily available, Zauresh Battalova, a former Kazakh senator and democracy campaigner, said in an interview. Marek Jochec, an academic at Nazarbayev University, earlier this year published an article in a Kazakh magazine saying that the fund risks losing significant income because of its investment strategy.
Money from the fund has helped finance the construction of Astana, the new capital city, according to the government. At the center of the city’s futuristic layout is Bayterek, a gold-orbed tower that stands as a monument to Mr. Nazarbayev, containing his metallic handprint on a plinth encrusted with silver and gold.
Through a spokesman, Mr. Nazarbayev declined to comment for this article.
Sovereign-wealth funds are state-owned investment funds usually created to save surplus revenues, often collected from natural-resource exports.
Kazakhstan’s National Fund transfers billions of dollars each year to the government budget and projects, according to the central bank.

The governments of Russia, Azerbaijan and Venezuela have also spent billions from their sovereign-wealth funds in this manner.
Venezuela’s Fund for Macroeconomic Stabilization is essentially empty after the government spent almost $7 billion from the fund since its inception in 1998, according to the Venezuelan government.
Russia, the world’s biggest oil producer, has spent about $195 billion from its Reserve Fund since it was created in 2008, leaving $31.3 billion in it as of Dec. 1, according to the government. Russia also has savings in its National Wealth Fund. It has spent about $1 billion of this fund since 2008, leaving it with $71.3 billion as of Dec. 1, according to the government. A Russian government spokesman declined to comment.
Azerbaijan has spent $89.7 billion from a sovereign-wealth fund created in 1999. The fund said it had $35.8 billion left as of Oct. 1. Money was used for “strategically important infrastructure and social projects,” a spokeswoman said. The government plans to draw less money from the fund as it develops new industries, she said.
Middle Eastern nations are also under pressure to tap savings. The Saudi Arabian Monetary Authority, the nation’s central bank, said its reserves fell more than 25% to $543 billion in the two years through the end of October. Spokesmen for the Saudi and Venezuelan governments didn’t respond to requests for comment.
The size of the withdrawals threatens the existence of the funds, potentially leaving oil-producing nations more vulnerable to an extended period of low oil prices. Norway, which owns the world’s largest sovereign-wealth fund, has a rule that the government shouldn’t spend more than the fund earns from investments, to “lessen the risk of overspending.” Norway has so far spent less than 1% of its fund. There is no such rule in Kazakhstan.
Mr. Nazarbayev, Kazakhstan’s president, wrote in his autobiography that the fund he created is a “particular source of pride.” It was inspired by Norway’s fund, he wrote, and “its aim was to safeguard the country’s stable social and economic development by accumulating financial funds for future generations.”