WSJ : Sequoia Doesn’t Want a ‘King’ to Run Its $9 Billion Hedge Fund

Sequoia Doesn’t Want a ‘King’ to Run Its $9 Billion Hedge Fund
After tension around profit-sharing and culture, the fund tries a new leadership model

  • Sequoia’s $9 billion hedge fund adopted a “no kings” leadership approach, installing four leaders after its former head departed.
  • The change is an attempt to make the hedge fund’s operation look similar to that of its more famous relative, Sequoia Capital, the giant venture-capital firm.
  • The fund experienced a 29% loss in 2022, while the Nasdaq composite lost 32.5%, but gained 13.4% in 2023 and 19.3% in 2024.

Following a streak of disappointing performance, tension over profit-sharing and complaints about a negative culture, Sequoia’s $9 billion hedge fund is trying a new approach to leadership: “No kings.”

The firm has installed a group of four leaders in an attempt to make the hedge fund’s operation look similar to that of its more famous relative, Sequoia Capital, the giant venture-capital firm, according to people familiar with the fund. It is an unusual move for the hedge fund world, where co-portfolio manager relationships have been known to blow up and clients tend to like a single boss.

Sequoia Capital Global Equities is a large hedge-fund investor in tech and has long been seen as a way for clients to get some access to Sequoia’s private investments. It is a growth investor with bets on both public and private tech companies. Its private portfolio has included Stripe, TikTok parent ByteDance, SpaceX, Chinese food-delivery giant Meituan, Chime Financial CHYM -0.83%decrease; red down pointing triangle and failed crypto firm FTX.

The hedge fund reports to a board that includes partners of Sequoia Capital, which recently shook up its own leadership. Alfred Lin and Pat Grady, who Sequoia named as stewards in November, are reviewing the hedge fund’s operations, said a person familiar with the firm.

The changes at the top of the hedge fund started in February when its longtime head, Jeff Wang, stepped down. Some of his team had complained to Sequoia leaders that he wasn’t sharing enough of the fund’s profits and that he had created a negative culture, some people familiar with Sequoia said. Wang, who had run the fund for about a decade, had shouted and cursed at members of his team and made at least one analyst cry, the people said.

>>> What to look at today - 9th of December 2025

Asian shares fell, tracking Monday’s declines on Wall Street, as traders grew anxious about the pace of easing by the Federal Reserve beyond this week’s near-certain interest-rate cut. MSCI Inc.’s gauge of regional shares dropped 0.4%. US stock futures were little changed after the S&P 500 shed 0.3% on Monday. Yields on US Treasuries edged higher again on Tuesday, adding to their advance amid a global bond slump in the previous session. While the Fed is broadly estimated to deliver a 25 basis-point rate cut on Wednesday, some traders have warned that the US central bank may signal a slower pace of easing ahead. That’s because still-high inflation and the lack of fresh data during the shutdown have caused divisions among Fed officials. After this week’s likely cut, money markets are leaning toward two more moves by the end of 2026, down from three signaled barely a week ago. Asian bond markets were also a key focus on Tuesday. Australia’s policy-sensitive three-year yields rose to the highest since last November as the central bank warned that risks to inflation had tilted to the upside and Governor Michele Bullock said that conditions for a rate hike in 2026 were discussed in the meeting. That’s after the Reserve Bank of Australia kept its key rate unchanged for a third straight meeting as expected. In Japan, demand at an auction of five-year debt was weaker than the 12-month average, as mounting expectations for a rate hike this month reduced investor appetite. The yen consolidated after falling Monday, when a magnitude-7.6 quake struck off Japan’s northeast coast. Shares of construction companies and insurance providers rose on Tuesday. Finance Minister Satsuki Katayama said she is closely watching market trends, as the yield on 10-year government debt hovers near 2%, a level not seen since 2006. Elsewhere, Bitcoin fell about 1.5%. Gold and silver were rangebound after they fell on Monday. Oil steadied after the biggest drop in almost three weeks, as traders look to reports this week to assess the extent of the glut. The US 10-year yield hit its highest level since September in Monday’s session, extending bond selling in Europe and Japan, and supporting the dollar. A $58 billion sale of three-year notes arrived at a lower-than-forecast yield Monday, a sign of better than anticipated demand. A $39 billion auction of 10-years and $22 billion of 30-years are set for Tuesday and Thursday, respectively. Kevin Hassett, a top candidate to take over the role of Fed chair, said it would be irresponsible for the Fed to lay out a plan for where it aims to take interest rates over the next six months. The White House National Economic Council Director emphasized the importance of following the economic data in a CNBC interview Monday. Shares of Nvidia Corp. climbed in after-hours trading after the company was granted permission by President Donald Trump to ship its H200 artificial intelligence chip to China in exchange for a 25% cut of the sales. Chinese chip stocks were mostly lower in Asia while Japanese suppliers rose. Meanwhile, Goldman Sachs Group Inc.’s clients are pulling back their bullish views on artificial intelligence and US stocks following last month’s slide, with fresh survey data showing expectations for the S&P 500 turned much more conservative heading into 2026. US After Hours MAMA +17.2% on earnings; ALEX +37.3% surging on take private deal; ARES +7% nicely higher on news it will join S&P 500; TOL -4% lower on earnings.

Nikkei +0.14% Hang Seng -1.23% CSI -0.52% Shanghai -0.38% Shenzen -0.54%

Eur$ 1.1640 CNH 7.0750 CNY 7.0715 JPY 156.08 GBP 1.3329 CHF 0.8062 RUB 76.9737 TRY 42.5744 WTI$ 58.66 -0.37% Gold 4,177 -0.32% BTC 90,020 -1.45% ETH 3,108 -1.24% SOL 132.4520 -1.55%

S&P +0.07% Nasdaq +0.05% EuroStoxx +0.12% FTSE -0.01% Dax +0.17% SMI -0.35% (close yesterday)

Macro :
- German Lawmakers to Approve Record €52 Billion in Defense Orders
- EU Says Thailand–Cambodia Clash Marks Escalation in Hostilities
- Copper Frenzy Reignited by Data Centers, Tariffs, Shortage
- Nuclear Stocks’ $566 Billion Rally Is Far From Over, Funds Say
- Goldman Clients Take More Cautious Posture After November Rout
- Trump Told Xi US Will Allow Nvidia H200 Exports to China
- Trump Threatens ‘Severe’ Tariffs on Canadian Fertilizer
- Kushner, Apollo, Billionaire Dad Power Hostile Warner Bros. Bid
- Japan Builds Up ‘Missile Archipelago’ Near Taiwan to Counter China
- Trump's AI Czar David Sacks Supports President's 'One Rulebook' For The Technology, Warns 50-State Regulatory Patchwork Could
- Cocaine widely detected in some of NI's major lakes and rivers
- Indonesia Signals Peak in Nickel Mining Investment as Focus Shifts to Batteries, EVs

Keep an eye on :
- AMD US : AMD, Intel Will Get Same Treatment as Nvidia, Trump Says
- ASCN SW : Ascom Names David Hale as New CEO
- ASM NA : ASM Supervisory Board to Reappoint CEO Hichem M’Saad
- AZA SS : Avanza Has Technical Issues, Aftonbladet Reports
- BHP LN : BHP to Sell WAIO Power Unit Stake to Blackrock’s GIP for $2b
- BHP LN : BHP Spurs Infrastructure Selloff as Miners Adjust Spending Plans
- CAN LN : Warner Bros., Canal+ Talks on South Africa Deal Stall
- DE US : Deere Must Reduce Agriculture Equipment Prices, Trump Says
- DTE GY : OpenAI Ties Up With Deutsche Telekom for AI Services
- DIS US : Jimmy Kimmel Extends Deal With Disney’s ABC for at Least a Year
- DKSH SW : DKSH Offers to Fully Takeover, Delist Malaysian Unit
- ENR GY : Activist Ananym Capital Built Stake in Siemens Energy: FT
- EVT GY : Evotec Holder Novo Holdings Offers About 9.4M Shares, Terms Show
- GMAB DC : Genmab Says Epcoritamab Shows Promise for Richter Patients
- JST GY : JOST Werke Holder Peter Möhrle Holding Offers 1.5m Shares
- HBMN SW : Mirum Buys Bluejay From Swiss Fund HBM For Up to $820 Million
- NDX1 GY : Nordex Gets Orders Totaling 102 MW in France, Belgium
- NOVN SW : Novartis Strikes $1.7 Billion Drug Target Deal With UK Biotech
- NVDA US : Nvidia Wins Trump’s Approval to Sell H200 AI Chips in China
- OCI NA : Orascom Construction, OCI Global to Proceed With Merger
- ORSTED DC : Trump Ban on Wind Energy Projects Ruled Illegal by US Judge
- PEP US : PepsiCo to Cut Costs, Lower Food Prices in Deal With Activist Elliott -- WSJ
- RNO FP : Renault, Ford Agree to Develop Two Electric Cars in Europe
- Revolut IPO : Revolut Offers to Buy Back Ex-Staff Shares at 30% Discount: FT
- SHEL LN : Putin Allows Rosneft-Shell JV Transactions With Stake in CPC
- SKAB SS : Skanska Signs $105m Data Center Contract in Virginia
- SYDB DC : Sydbank Cuts FY Net Income Forecast
- TMPL LN : Temple Bar Investment Trust PLC: Sale of Shares From Treasury
- TKA GY : Thyssenkrupp 2026 Adjusted Ebit Forecast Misses Estimates
- UCG IM : UniCredit Starts Active Wind-Down of Russian Ops: Kommersant
- VOLVB SS : Volvo Offers Software to Rivals in Reversal From Coding Delays
- VOW GY : Billionaire Porsche Clan’s Cash Needs Collides With VW’s Woes
- WBD US : Paramount Bid for Warner May Create Antitrust Issue, Thune Says

>>> Europe : Brokers Upgrades & Downgrades - 9th of December 2025

>>> Up
* Alexandria Group Raised to Accumulate at Inderes; PT 10.50 euros
* Allianz Raised to Outperform at KBW; PT 420 euros
* Colgate-Palmolive Raised to Outperform at RBC; PT $88
* Epiroc Raised to Outperform at BNPP Exane; PT 240 kronor
* EQT Raised to Overweight at JPMorgan; PT 399 kronor
* Generali Raised to Outperform at KBW; PT 37 euros
* Helios Towers PT Raised to 254 pence from 204 pence at Jefferies
* Man Group Raised to Overweight at JPMorgan; PT 256 pence
* RELX Raised to Buy at Deutsche Bank; PT 3,700 pence
* Trustpilot Raised to Buy at Goodbody; PT 250 pence
* Wallenius Wilhelmsen Raised to Buy at Nordea; PT 120 kroner
* Wolters Kluwer Raised to Buy at Deutsche Bank; PT 125 euros

>>> Down
* HelloFresh Cut to Underweight at Morgan Stanley; PT 5.50 euros
* Picton Property Income Ltd Cut to Hold at Peel Hunt; PT 80 pence
* Swiss Re Cut to Neutral at Citi; PT 137.64 Swiss francs
* Swiss Re Cut to Hold at Berenberg; PT 140 Swiss francs
* Volvo Cut to Hold at Deutsche Bank; PT 275 kronor

>>> Initiation
* Agilent Reinstated Buy at Goldman; PT $170
* Banque Cantonale de Geneve Rated New Hold at Octavian
* Danaher Reinstated Buy at Goldman; PT $265
* Helvetia Baloise Holding Rated New Outperform at Autonomous
* Lattice Semi Reinstated Buy at William O'Neil
* Magnum Ice Cream Rated New Neutral at JPMorgan; PT 14 euros
* Micron Rated New Buy at HSBC; PT $330
* Revvity Reinstated Neutral at Goldman; PT $105
* Rosebank Rated New Buy at Berenberg; PT 440 pence
* Teva ADRs Rated New Overweight at Barclays; PT $35
* Thermo Fisher Reinstated Buy at Goldman; PT $685

>>> Call
* HelloFresh Cut at Morgan Stanley on ‘Skewed’ Risk/Reward
* JPMorgan Sees ‘Reasons to Be Cheerful’ in Diversified Financials
* Maersk Placed on Positive Watch at Citi on Short-Term Ebit Boost
* Swiss Re Downgraded at Citi and Berenberg Following Target Reset
* Watch UK Retailers as BRC Says Sales Cooled on Budget Fears

The Information : Tiger Global Launches $2.2 Billion Fund

Tiger Global Launches $2.2 Billion Fund

Tiger Global has announced the launch of a $2.2 billion private investment fund.

In a note to investors reviewed by The Information, Tiger Global said the fund is expected to do a first close in March. The new fund is the same size as its venture fund raised in April 2024. Both are a fraction of the $12.7 billion flagship fund raised in 2021.

Tiger said that its recent strategy has been to devote two-thirds of its private capital to AI-related businesses. The memo touted its investments in Waymo, OpenAI and chip maker Cerebras.

CNBC earlier reported on the fundraising.

According to the memo, Tiger Global says it has had more than 90 portfolio company IPOs and has distributed $32 billion to its investors in the 22 years since it launched its first “PIP” or private investment fund.

The Information : Skild AI Said in Talks to Raise at $14 Billion Valuation

Skild AI Said in Talks to Raise at $14 Billion Valuation

Skild AI, which develops AI foundation models to power robots to perform a variety of tasks, is in talks to raise over $1 billion at a valuation around $14 billion from SoftBank and Nvidia, Reuters reported on Monday.

That valuation would be triple the two-year-old startup’s valuation from earlier this year, when it raised $500 million at a $4.2 billion valuation in a funding round backed by SoftBank, which has been doubling down on robotics investments.

Over the summer, Skild released videos of its model, the Skild Brain, powering a variety of robots, including robotic arms, robot dogs, and two-legged humanoids. The humanoids walked across stacks of pallets, up and down stairs, and through the woods. In September, Skild showed off a robot dog adapting to changes, including continuing to walk after having its legs cut off with a chainsaw.

WSJ : ‘Priceless’ Matisse Works Stolen in Daylight Heist of Brazilian Library

‘Priceless’ Matisse Works Stolen in Daylight Heist of Brazilian Library
Armed thieves make off with prints from French painter’s colorful ‘Jazz’ series

  • Two armed thieves stole eight Henri Matisse prints and five Cândido Portinari works from São Paulo’s Mário de Andrade library.
  • One suspect was arrested, but the accomplice and artworks remain at large following the daylight robbery on Sunday.
  • The incident highlights vulnerabilities in public museums and libraries, which are often constrained by budget and infrastructure issues.

SÃO PAULO—The two men might not have had the brazen ingenuity of the men who broke into the Louvre, but all they each needed was a handgun stuffed down their pants.

In the latest daylight robbery to hit the art world, two armed thieves stormed into São Paulo’s marble-floored Mário de Andrade public library Sunday and carried off eight rare prints by the French modernist master Henri Matisse.

The pair lifted their shirts to show the security guard they had guns—threatening an elderly couple—then swiped the artwork off the wall and plopped the pieces into a canvas bag, witnesses told local media.

Authorities said the men snatched an additional five works by Brazilian painter Cândido Portinari before escaping on foot in a matter of minutes from the 100-year-old library, one of the city’s most important cultural landmarks. Security footage shows one of the men staggering down the cobblestone sidewalks of São Paulo’s historic center under the weight of the framed prints as people strolled by seemingly unaware of the heist under way.

“Their value is cultural, historical and artistic…economically, they are priceless,” São Paulo’s City Hall said of the works, which included prints from Matisse’s colorful 1947 “Jazz” series. Sotheby’s has described them as among the artist’s most seminal works.

São Paulo’s mayor, Ricardo Nunes, said Monday police had arrested one suspect—identified by local media as a 31-year-old man with convictions for drug trafficking—but were still on the hunt for his accomplice, as well as the artworks.

Sunday’s raid has heightened fears over the safety of the art world’s most priceless treasures, coming less than two months after thieves disguised as construction workers used a mechanical lift to scale the side of the Louvre Museum in Paris and steal the French Crown Jewels.

Even in crime-hardened São Paulo, art heists are rare. Curators warn that Sunday’s robbery highlights how public museums and libraries—hampered by tight budgets and aging infrastructure—have become soft targets.

The same library was robbed in 2006, when thieves made off with rare 19th century engravings by the Swiss artist Johann Jacob Steinmann. Police recovered one of the works 18 years later, seizing it from a Brazilian collector who had bought it from a London auction house.

The struggle to protect cultural heritage arguably is even greater in Brazil, where there is widespread public indifference to the country’s past—in part, a reaction to years of exploitative and violent colonial rule by the Portuguese. When the country’s National Museum in Rio de Janeiro went up in flames in 2018, it was the first time many Brazilians had even heard of it.

The Mário de Andrade Library was conveniently deserted when the art thieves slipped in through the main entrance just after 10 a.m. on Sunday.

It was the final day of the two-month exhibition “From the Book to the Museum,” a collaboration with the São Paulo Museum of Modern Art that displayed rare midcentury books, documents and prints.

>>> Stoxx 600 Pre-Market Indications

  • Orsted (D2G TH) +4.8%
    • Watch European Clean-Energy Stocks as Trump Ban Ruled Illegal
  • RENK Group (R3NK TH) +4.5%
  • Rheinmetall (RHM TH) +3.6%
    • *GERMANY TO APPROVE RECORD €52 BILLION IN MILITARY ORDERS
  • Hensoldt (HAG TH) +3.2%
  • BAE (BSP TH) +2.5%
  • Rolls-Royce (RRU TH) +2.3%
  • Vestas (VWSB TH) +2.2%
    • Watch European Clean-Energy Stocks as Trump Ban Ruled Illegal
  • Nordex (NDX1 TH) +1.9%
  • Wolters Kluwer (WOSB TH) +1.4%
  • Thyssenkrupp (TKA TH) -4.3%
    • Thyssenkrupp Forecasts Loss With High Cash Burn, Costs Ahead

>>> TradeGate Pre-Market Indications

DAX:
  • Rheinmetall (RHM TH) +3.7%
    • *GERMANY TO APPROVE RECORD €52 BILLION IN MILITARY ORDERS
  • Siemens Energy (ENR TH) +1%
    • Activist Ananym Capital Built Stake in Siemens Energy: FT
MDAX:
  • RENK Group (R3NK TH) +4.8%
  • Hensoldt (HAG TH) +2.9%
  • Nordex (NDX1 TH) +1.5%
    • Watch European Clean-Energy Stocks as Trump Ban Ruled Illegal
  • Thyssenkrupp (TKA TH) -4.3%
    • Thyssenkrupp Forecasts Loss With High Cash Burn, Costs Ahead
  • HelloFresh (HFG TH) -5.8%
    • HelloFresh Cut to Underweight at Morgan Stanley; PT 5.50 euros
SDAX:
  • Grand City Properties (GYC TH) +1.8%
  • SMA Solar (S92 TH) +1.4%
  • Kloeckner (KCO TH) -1.4%
  • Evotec (EVT TH) -3.9%
    • Evotec Holder Novo Holdings Offers About 9.4M Shares, Terms Show

WSJ : Sam Altman’s Sprint to Correct OpenAI’s Direction and Fend Off Google

Sam Altman’s Sprint to Correct OpenAI’s Direction and Fend Off Google
The CEO is prioritizing achieving mass popularity through ChatGPT versus moonshot projects like artificial general intelligence

When OpenAI CEO Sam Altman made the dramatic call for a “code red” last week to beat back a rising threat from Google, he put a notable priority at the top of his list of fixes.

The world’s most valuable startup should pause its side projects like its Sora video generator for eight weeks and focus on improving ChatGPT, its popular chatbot that kicked off the AI boom.

In so doing, Altman was making a major strategic course correction and taking sides in a broader philosophical divide inside the company—between its pursuit of popularity among everyday consumers and its quest for research greatness.

OpenAI was founded to pursue artificial general intelligence, broadly defined as being able to outthink humans at almost all tasks. But for the company to survive, Altman was suggesting, it may have to pause that quest and give the people what they want.

The move was striking in part because one criticism of Altman’s leadership has been his reluctance to put limits on what the company can accomplish.

And it was telling that he instructed employees to boost ChatGPT in a specific way: through “better use of user signals,” he wrote in his memo.

With that directive, Altman was calling for turning up the crank on a controversial source of training data—including signals based on one-click feedback from users, rather than evaluations from professionals of the chatbot’s responses. An internal shift to rely on that user feedback had helped make ChatGPT’s 4o model so sycophantic earlier this year that it has been accused of exacerbating severe mental-health issues for some users.

Now Altman thinks the company has mitigated the worst aspects of that approach, but is poised to capture the upside: It significantly boosted engagement, as measured by performance on internal dashboards tracking daily active users.

“It was not a small, statistically significant bump, but like a ‘wow’ bump,” said one person who worked on the model.

OpenAI’s “code red” moment represents the most serious challenge it has yet faced to its lead in the AI race. Competitors are gaining ground at a faster level than ever before, stealing market share and slowing growth. If the trend continues, OpenAI may not be able to pay for the giant computing contracts it has signed in recent months, and could even struggle to stay afloat financially.

At a lunch meeting with journalists in New York Monday, Altman said that while industry observers are focused on an OpenAI versus Google rivalry, he thinks the real battle will be between OpenAI and Apple. Devices will be critical to how people use AI over time, he said, and current smartphones are not well suited for the AI companions and use cases. OpenAI’s new hardware arm has been hiring aggressively from Apple recently.

But OpenAI’s more immediate threat comes from Google, which has been rapidly gaining ground since its Nano Banana image generator went viral in August. Then last month, Google’s new Gemini 3 model blew past OpenAI on a closely watched third-party leaderboard of model performance called LM Arena. Meanwhile, rival Anthropic has nudged ahead of OpenAI among corporate clients.

Behind Altman’s “code red” declaration, however, are tensions between camps inside the company that have been festering for years, according to people familiar with the matter.

A group including Fidji Simo, a former Meta Platforms executive who leads OpenAI’s product efforts, and Chief Financial Officer Sarah Friar, have pushed the company to pour more resources into ChatGPT. Simo has also told staff that OpenAI needs to do a better job of making sure its users discover the value of ChatGPT’s existing features before the company goes on to build new ones, and also wants to improve the chatbot’s speed and reliability.

Researchers meanwhile have prioritized state of the art technology that could lead to artificial general intelligence, or AGI, but don’t do as much to improve the basic chatbot experience.

OpenAI is set to release a new model, called 5.2, this week that executives hope will give it new momentum, particularly among coding and business customers. They overruled some employees who asked to push back the model’s release so the company could have more time to make it better, according to people familiar with the matter.

The company also plans to release another model in January with better images, improved speed and a better personality, and to end the code red after that, Altman said.

An OpenAI spokeswoman says there’s no conflict between the two philosophies, and that broad adoption of AI tools is how the company plans to distribute AGI’s benefit.

For a long time, ChatGPT’s blistering growth had papered over these internal differences. Ever since OpenAI launched ChatGPT in November 2022, the AI race has been its to lose. Caught flat-footed, Google declared its own “code red” that year as it raced to catch up.

ChatGPT’s appeal to everyday consumers led its user base to explode to more than 800 million weekly average users, according to the company, and its valuation rose accordingly, to $500 billion in its latest round of fundraising.

The technology may have been complex, but the logic powering that growth was simple: the more compute and data that goes into the models, the smarter they are, and the more users will want them. Altman turned his attention to removing any barriers to the start of this equation, spending the summer and fall signing deals for up to $1.4 trillion worth of commitments to AI infrastructure like data centers and chips.

A major engine of consumer success in the last year and a half was a version of ChatGPT dubbed GPT-4o, for “omni,” or the ability to function across text, audio and images. It became ChatGPT’s default model in May 2024—and shot to the top of the LM Arena leaderboard with record scores.

Internally, OpenAI paid close attention to LM Arena, people familiar with the matter said. It also closely tracked 4o’s contribution to ChatGPT’s daily active user counts, which were visible internally on dashboards and touted to employees in town-hall meetings and in Slack.

The 4o model performed so well with people in large part because it was schooled with user signals like those which Altman referred to in his memo: a distillation of which responses people preferred in head-to-head comparisons that ChatGPT would show millions of times a day. The approach was internally called LUPO, shorthand for “local user preference optimization,” people involved in model training said.

In his memo, Altman made a direct link between user signals and LM Arena performance, saying the company’s number one priority was to improve its model performance through “better use of user signals (for example, we should be at the top of things like LM arena).”

At the same time, there were clouds appearing in the research race for the most cutting-edge capabilities. The gains predicted by so-called “scaling laws” that had powered generative AI’s early rise—the notion that compute, data and performance increase along a predictable line—showed some signs of slowing. That led researchers to pivot to a new paradigm for its founding goal of achieving humanlike intelligence: an automated Socratic method of questioning dubbed “reasoning.”

Reasoning got better answers to hard questions, but it took more time and a lot more compute. Nevertheless, it seemed to OpenAI researchers like an important path toward the goal the company used to attract its most talented AI researchers: building AGI.

Following the departure of founding chief scientist Ilya Sutskever last year, OpenAI tapped Jakub Patchocki, a strong proponent of reasoning models, to be chief scientist. He pushed hard into building reasoning models, starting with o1, which the company released in preview in September 2024, and has continued to pump out this year.

Reasoning models turned out to be good at some work tasks and questions that require lots of time to think through, like OpenAI’s deep research product, but they are not as helpful or fast enough for some of the immediate tasks most people turn to ChatGPT for, like drafting an email.

That’s where 4o came in.

Prerelease versions of 4o that were heavily trained with user signals didn’t show much appreciable improvement on internal evaluations of capabilities on things like science or reasoning, according to people who worked on the model. But they performed far better than expected when OpenAI leaked an anonymous version to LM Arena—where people seemed to love it.

LM Arena works using similar AB-style tests to those run by OpenAI that drive an internal metric dubbed the “win rate.” Anyone can visit LM Arena and try out two models in a side-by-side matchup, responding to the same questions, and then select their preferred answers.

The 4o model’s success with users led engineers to continue relying on those user signals in what is called post-training of subsequent updates, despite earlier warnings from some staffers that overusing these signals could make the model unsafe, people who worked on the model said.

“You are training a language model to copy the users, and have the same preferences in these side-by-side comparisons.” Then “you can stick it into your algorithm and max out the score,” one of the people said.

By this spring, interaction with 4o appears to have started taking a toll on some people—and subsequently on OpenAI’s reputation. A number of users spiraled into delusional or manic states while using the chatbot for extended periods, with some believing they were talking to God, aliens or a self-aware machine consciousness.

Families of ChatGPT users who committed suicide or became delusional began filing lawsuits accusing the company of prioritizing engagement over safety with 4o. A support group says it has assembled 250 cases, the vast majority involving ChatGPT. Some people still remain in the grip of what their families describe as 4o-enabled delusions.

In the spring, OpenAI declared a “code orange” around the sycophancy crisis and devoted more resources to understanding and addressing the problem. The company said in October that hundreds of thousands of ChatGPT users each week exhibit possible signs of mental health emergencies related to psychosis or mania.

“We have seen a problem where people that are in fragile psychiatric situations using a model like 4o can get into a worse one,” Altman said that month in a public question-and-answer session. “I don’t think this is the last time we’ll face challenges like this with a model.”

Some doctors and mental health experts say chatbots like ChatGPT may trigger or worsen these types of mental health issues in vulnerable people because the bots are prone to tell users what they want to hear rather than what is most accurate and helpful—a problem known in the AI world as sycophancy. Others including OpenAI say the jury is out on how much of a causal role AI plays and whether those affected would have suffered mental illness anyway.

In response to the crisis, OpenAI says it has worked with mental health experts, tried to make sure its models respond better to people in possible distress, and rerouted some user conversations to what it calls safer models.

The company also says it tweaked its training to make sure user-feedback signals did not become too powerful a voice in its post-training of future models.

When OpenAI released its long-awaited GPT-5 model in August, it said the model was “less effusively agreeable” and used “fewer unnecessary emojis” than 4o. But the changes angered scores of users, who criticized its colder tone and led Altman to restore 4o to ChatGPT for paying subscribers.

“I think you should take the fact that I, and many others, have been able to form such strong bonds with 4o as a measure of success,” one user wrote in an “Ask Me Anything” Reddit forum that Altman hosted. The new model “might be an ‘upgrade’ but it’s an upgrade that’s killed off someone I have grown to appreciate as a friend and companion.”

A few weeks after the lukewarm launch, Google released its Nano Banana image-generator, and its Gemini AI app briefly replaced ChatGPT at the top of the app store. In October, OpenAI executives declared another “code orange” and pushed staff to focus on accelerating ChatGPT growth.

The same month, the company also said it made changes to GPT-5 that reduced by 65% the rate of the chatbot’s responses that don’t fully comply with the company’s detailed guide for how it should respond to mental health issues.

“We carefully balance user feedback with expert review, multiple safety systems, and extensive testing which allows us to improve ChatGPT’s warmth without it becoming overly agreeable,” a spokeswoman said.

It’s not clear how Altman’s new directive to again top LM Arena by tapping user signals will affect that balance.

Altman also said in the memo that ChatGPT should lean more into personalization, another feature that some doctors and victims’ advocates have suggested may have played a role in exacerbating some users’ mental health issues. With personalization, ChatGPT is able to access contents and summaries of some prior conversations along with a set of facts about users, allowing the bot to reference them and even mirror a person’s tone.

OpenAI’s attempt to reconcile ambitious bets on future products and research with a consumer business focused on the here and now in some ways recalls the trade-offs faced by social media giants. Meta Platforms for years veered between competitive imperatives like copying TikTok with a product called Reels to expensive long-term projects like starting a virtual-reality world dubbed the metaverse, which it is now scaling back.

Social-media companies have also come under intense scrutiny for the way their ranking algorithms select content based on what keeps people coming back and sticking around longer, which critics argue led to negative impacts on teens and other vulnerable users. The advent of AI chatbots offers a new twist in this same debate.

“Years of prioritizing engagement on social media led to a full-blown mental health crisis,” said Jim Steyer, founder and chief executive of child-advocacy group Common Sense Media, in an interview. “The real question is will the AI companies learn from the social-media companies’ tragic mistakes?”