UK investors pull more than £31bn from equities and bonds
Alternative investments, such as private equity and property, are poised to benefit
UK insurers, pension funds and trusts controlling £4tn of assets have pulled more than £31bn from equities and bonds in the 12 months to the end of September, marking the heaviest withdrawals from asset markets since 1987.
The widespread retreat from stocks and bonds is a rare occurrence that industry insiders said demonstrates growing nervousness among institutional investors about where to place their money.
In its first assessment of UK investor trends since the British referendum on EU membership last June, the Office for National Statistics described the widespread retreat from markets as “unusual”.
The UK’s largest independent producer of official statistics added that the outflows may have been “influenced by changes in investor confidence in the economic environment”.
In 2015 as a whole, by contrast, institutional investors poured £28bn into equity and bond markets, according to ONS data.
Net withdrawals by UK institutional investors have only occurred in five quarters over the past 30 years. Two of those quarters were in 2016.
The other times that large UK investors moved en masse out of bond and equity markets were in the third quarter of 2001, when the September 11 terrorist attacks took place, and the fourth quarter of 2008, at the start of the global financial crisis.
The biggest falls in investment were in overseas stocks, which registered £33.5bn of withdrawals in the 12 months to the end of September, and UK stocks, which suffered £14bn of withdrawals. UK corporate bonds also experienced £4.6bn of outflows over the same period.
Paul Farrell, head of UK institutional investment at JPMorgan Asset Management, which has $1.8tn of assets under management, said there were two probable drivers behind the recent retrenchment: institutions parking assets in cash to lock in high returns from stocks, and others selling assets to make up for negative cash flows.
“The [asset] flows are indicative of institutional investors’ increasingly urgent focus on income-generating investments and on securing stable cash flows to meet future obligations,” he said.
He added that alternative investments, such as private equity and property, are poised to benefit in the current environment as investors seek to “harvest the illiquidity premium of alternatives”.
It is not just large UK clients that are pulling back from markets. According to Platforum, the research company, there are 2m fewer adults in Britain with savings or investments than there were at the end of 2015.
Amin Rajan, chief executive of Create Research, an asset management consultancy, said the move is likely to squeeze asset managers. “Investors suspect that the punch bowl is nearly empty and the party may be over before long,” he said.
“Asset managers have to recognise that business as usual is not an option. Now they face severe headwinds on many fronts. They need resilient business models that can provide the necessary shock absorbers.”
