Asia Mid-Session Market Update: G20 fails to impress the markets, China CPI/PPI in line and BOJ affirms policy stance
***Asia Summary***
- Markets take a risk on sentiment at the start of the week, seemingly unconcerned about the G20 who met over the weekendin Hamburg, Germany among heavy protesting. The Communique was fairly standard, reiterating to fight protectionism and secure free trade. New elements include to agree by November steps to reduce global overcapacity of steel and in afirst ever dissent: 19 members affirmed the Paris accord with the US (dissenter) saying it will help other countries "access and use fossil fuels more cleanly and efficiently."
- Japan govt cut its assessment of machinery orders for the first time since September 2016 after May orders fell 3.6% m/m and only rose 0.6% y/y v the expected 7.6%. USD/JPY rose 0.1% to 113.99 after the data and later tested 114.20. The PBOC again skipped open market operations for the 12th consecutive day, while local press highlighted financial stability as a major topic for the National Financial Work Conference, which will start in mid-July. CPI and PPI were a non-event in the session.
- Global shipping names rallied after Cosco Shipping (1919.HK) confirmed it will acquire Orient Overseas for HK$78.67/shr in a HK$49.2B deal. Maersk gave their support of the deal, saying consolidation would be good for the industry.
***Key economic data***
- (CN) CHINA JUN CPI M/M: -0.2% V -0.1% PRIOR; Y/Y: 1.5% V 1.6%E
- (CN) CHINA JUN PPI Y/Y: 5.5% V 5.5%E
- (JP) JAPAN JUN BANK LENDING (INC TRUSTS) Y/Y: 3.3% V 3.2%E; BANK LENDING (EX-TRUSTS) Y/Y: 3.3% V 3.3%E
- (JP) JAPAN MAY TOTAL CURRENT ACCOUNT: ¥1.65T V ¥1.79TE; ADJ TOTALCURRENT ACCOUNT: ¥1.40T V ¥1.63TE; TRADE BALANCE BOP BASIS: -¥115.1B V -¥45.0BE
- (JP) JAPAN MAY MACHINE ORDERS M/M: -3.6% V 1.7%E; Y/Y: 0.6% V 7.6%E
- (JP) Japan Jun Bankruptcies Y/Y: -7.5% v 19.5% prior
***Speakers and Press***
China
- (CN) China Head of State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) Pan Gongsheng said no intention of devaluing yuan currency to boost its competitiveness – financial press
- (CN) Overseas M&A expected to be major talking point at National Financial Work Conference in mid-July - SCMP
Japan
- (JP) Bank of Japan (BOJ) Gov Kuroda: Economy is turning towards moderate expansion; BOJ will continue to adjust policy as needed
- (JP) According to Yomiuri poll Japan PM Abe approval rating fell to 36% from 49% in June (lowest reading since being in office)
Australia/New Zealand
- (AU) Australia Department of Industry, Science and Innovation: Iron ore will sink back below $50/ metric ton next year as global supply expands and demand moderates in China
- (NZ) New Zealand Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment: Find no evidence of China steel coil dumping
US
- (US) Fed's Kashkari says large banks need to raise 'much more' equity - US financial press
***Asian Equity Indices/Futures (00:30ET)***
- Nikkei +0.8%, Hang Seng 1.0%, Shanghai Composite -0.2%, ASX200 +0.5%, Kospi +0.3%
- Equity Futures: S&P500 +0.2%; Nasdaq +0.4%, Dax +0.2%, FTSE100 +0.3%
***FX ranges/Commodities/Fixed Income (00:30ET)***
- EUR 1.1409-1.1390; JPY 114.20-113.89; AUD 0.7615-0.7596; NZD 0.7281-0.7265
- Aug Gold +0.1% at 1,210/oz; Aug Crude Oil +-0.8% at $44.58/brl; Sept Copper +0.2% at $2.66/lb
- (AU) Australia repurchases A$500M in Oct 2018 and March 2019 bonds
- (CN) PBoC skips open market operations (12th straight session)
- (CN) PBOC SETS YUAN REFERENCE RATE AT 6.7964 V 6.7914 PRIOR
- (KR) Bank of Korea (BOK) sells KRW1.20T v KRW1.2T offered in 1-yr monetary stabilization bonds; avg yield 1.46% v 1.47% prior
- (KR) South Korea sells 5-year bonds at 1.985%
- (JP) Japan 5-year JGB yield hits highest level since Jan 2016, near -0.03%
***Asia equities notable movers***
Australia
- Bellamy's Australia, BAL.AU China suspends export licence of newly acquired canning facility
- Ardent Leisure Group,AAD.AU Reports June theme park unit visitation -30.5% y/y, Rev A$4.4M, -35.3% y/y; +2.5%
- 88 Energy,88E.AU Gives update on Project Icewine, located onshore North Slope of Alaska; -25.5%
Japan
- KDDI Corp, 9433.JP President comments on mobile price cuts: Says price cuts needed to compete with Mvnos; -3.1%
Hong Kong/China
-316.HK China COSCO Shipping Holdings confirms to bid HK$49.2B ($6.3B) or HK$78.67/share in cash for Orient Overseas International (~31% premium); +24.2%
-China Life, 2628.HK China Development said to seek to buy up to 25.3% of China Life - US financial press; +0.4%
US
- MYCC To be acquired by Apollo Global Management for $17.12/shr cash (~31% premium); declares one time dividend of $0.13
- PBR Federal Court of Appeals in New York partially grants appeal related to class action
- WFC Court Grants Preliminary Approval of $142M Settlement in Wells Fargo Unauthorized Accounts Class Action
***US market Friday Summary***
US stock markets moved up after the June jobs report offered more of the same for investors and the Fed to ponder. Fears that the Fed might have made (or is about to make) a policy mistake should ease, but the data are likely to suggest to the Fed that there is no urgency about raising rates again soon. Job growth accelerated ahead of forecasts, but wage growth came up short of expectations once again. The unemployment rate ticked up along with the participation rate, indicating some slack likely still exists for the US labor market. The NASDAQ reversed course once again, adhering to the fickle nature of trade that has engulfed technology stocks in recent weeks. Along with the strength in technology, homebuilding stocks move higher along with healthcare and deep cyclical sectors. The energy complex moved lower along with crude oil prices.
US rates drifted higher, while the Treasury curve continued to steepen, and TIPS breakeven spreads came off, helped by the decline in oil prices. The US Dollar firmed almost across the board, with the exception being the Loonie. The Canadian Dollar surged after a Canada jobs report crushed expectations. The Yen remained under pressure after the BOJ offered to buy unlimited amount in fixed-rate bonds as part of their yield control operations. Gold prices dropped back towards the 1200 mark, hitting that level for the first time since March.
Being an American or Chinese company helps, so does developing or embracing artificial intelligence. But perhaps the most striking thing that many on the list of the 50 Smartest Companies have in common is the fact that most of us have never heard of them.
The list is put together by the MIT Technology Review and is dominated by firms based in the US or China.
Three Chinese companies - voice recognition company iFlytek, developers of the WeChat instant messaging service Tencent and facial recognition company Face++ - feature in a top 11 otherwise filled with American companies.
Image: MIT Technology Review
Three of the top five are developing AI technologies as part of their business offering.
While big names such as Amazon, Google, Apple and Facebook all feature, the list is far from just a compilation of the largest and most powerful tech companies on the planet. There are smaller firms on the list too.
MIT Technology Review says the list represents its editors’ “best guess as to which firms will be the dominant companies of the future”, based on their current development of technology.
Here’s the top 11:
1. Nvidia
Headquarters: Santa Clara, California
Valuation: $90.9 billion
MIT Technology Review places Nvidia at the top of its list not for its main business of selling graphics chips for video games, but for quickly establishing itself as the leading provider of processing power for AI software. The company says all the major Internet and cloud-service providers use its chips to accelerate their processes, and a number of large carmakers, including Toyota, are using its autonomous-driving technology.
Image: MIT Technology Review
2. SpaceX
Headquarters: Hawthorne, California
Valuation: $12 billion
Tesla CEO Elon Musk’s space travel venture SpaceX takes the second spot for its development of reusable rockets. These make space travel far cheaper and faster, and are critical to SpaceX’s long-term goal of establishing an interplanetary transport system. The start-up has also begun preliminary tests of its Falcon Heavy booster, which is expected to be the world’s most powerful rocket when it is completed later this year.
3. Amazon
Headquarters: Seattle, Washington
Valuation: $479.3 billion
Amazon makes the list for its use of a range of AI technologies, including computer vision, machine learning, and natural-language processing, to reinvent mobile computing and shopping. Amazon is moving its technology from online to real world shopping through its Seattle-based Amazon Go convenience store. Customers simply enter the store, scan an app on their smartphones, and walk out with their purchases. Amazon uses AI, cameras, and sensors to identify the products they have selected and bills them automatically — no lines or checkouts necessary.
4 23andMe
Headquarters: Mountain View, California
Valuation: $1.1 billion
Genetic testing company 23andMe sells reports on risks for late-onset Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, and eight other conditions. The company has more than 2 million customers worldwide, and its DNA-related products have been used in a number of research projects, including studies of female fertility, depression, Parkinson’s disease and even nail biting.
Image: MIT Technology Review
5. Alphabet
Headquarters: Mountain View, California
Valuation: $673.9 billion
Google parent company Alphabet is responsible for subsidiaries that are technology leaders in AI, autonomous vehicles, augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR). Its DeepMind division keeps devising new ways for AI systems to mimic human intelligence, while its self-driving-car project, Waymo, continues to improve performance.
6. iFlytek
Headquarters: Hefei, China
Valuation: $6.8 billion
iFlytek already dominates China’s voice-recognition market and is now expanding into voice-activated command systems for cars, homes, robots and schools. It has also established a multimillion-dollar fund to invest in AI-related start-ups around the world. It says that more than 160,000 developers use its software and more than 400 million people use its products.
7. Kite Pharma
Headquarters: Santa Monica, California
Valuation: $5.7 billion
This immunotherapy company is taking the body’s T cells, which naturally fight infections, and engineering them to fight cancer. It is furthest along with its therapy for aggressive non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, with more than a third of one study’s participants showing no sign of disease six months after treatment.
8. Tencent
Headquarters: Shenzhen, China
Valuation: $350 billion
Owners of China’s biggest social network, WeChat, TenCent are credited by some as revealing the future of social media. Though WeChat already boasts more than 900 million monthly active users, Tencent keeps expanding the mobile app so that it now offers messaging, online gaming, shopping, music, videos and peer-to-peer payments.
9. Regeneron
Headquarters: Tarrytown, New York
Valuation: $55.5 billion
Biotech company Regeneron uses genetic information to focus its drug development efforts. In March it announced that, along with the UK biobank and pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline, it would be sequencing genetic data from 500,000 volunteers to help support research into drug development and the connections between DNA and disease. It is also creating “off-the-shelf” engineered T cells to target tumors without requiring a patient’s own immune cells to be used - an approach that could make this field of treatment much easier to scale.
10. Spark Therapeutics
Headquarters: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Valuation: $1.9 billion
In addition to its treatment for a progressive form of blindness, the company has also been testing a way to combat hemophilia B, a blood clotting disorder. This involves intravenous treatment with viruses carrying a corrected version of the gene that codes for a blood-clotting protein called factor IX. MIT Technology Review says this is one to watch because the disease, which affects one in 5,000 men, is expensive to treat conventionally.
11. Face ++
Headquarters: Beijing, China
Valuation: $1 billion
Facial recognition company Face++’s software powers many of China’s most popular applications. Alipay, the popular online payment platform, uses the technology to let users log in and make payments using their face as ID; ride-sharing provider Didi Chuxing uses it to verify the identity of its freelance drivers; and smartphone app maker Meitu uses it to offer highly detailed photo-retouching features. The five-year-old start-up is believed to be the first facial recognition unicorn, having raised at least $145 million in recent years, including at least $100 million in December 2016.
Being an American or Chinese company helps, so does developing or embracing artificial intelligence. But perhaps the most striking thing that many on the list of the 50 Smartest Companies have in common is the fact that most of us have never heard of them.
The list is put together by the MIT Technology Review and is dominated by firms based in the US or China.
Three Chinese companies - voice recognition company iFlytek, developers of the WeChat instant messaging service Tencent and facial recognition company Face++ - feature in a top 11 otherwise filled with American companies.
Image: MIT Technology Review
Three of the top five are developing AI technologies as part of their business offering.
While big names such as Amazon, Google, Apple and Facebook all feature, the list is far from just a compilation of the largest and most powerful tech companies on the planet. There are smaller firms on the list too.
MIT Technology Review says the list represents its editors’ “best guess as to which firms will be the dominant companies of the future”, based on their current development of technology.
Here’s the top 11:
1. Nvidia
Headquarters: Santa Clara, California
Valuation: $90.9 billion
MIT Technology Review places Nvidia at the top of its list not for its main business of selling graphics chips for video games, but for quickly establishing itself as the leading provider of processing power for AI software. The company says all the major Internet and cloud-service providers use its chips to accelerate their processes, and a number of large carmakers, including Toyota, are using its autonomous-driving technology.
Image: MIT Technology Review
2. SpaceX
Headquarters: Hawthorne, California
Valuation: $12 billion
Tesla CEO Elon Musk’s space travel venture SpaceX takes the second spot for its development of reusable rockets. These make space travel far cheaper and faster, and are critical to SpaceX’s long-term goal of establishing an interplanetary transport system. The start-up has also begun preliminary tests of its Falcon Heavy booster, which is expected to be the world’s most powerful rocket when it is completed later this year.
3. Amazon
Headquarters: Seattle, Washington
Valuation: $479.3 billion
Amazon makes the list for its use of a range of AI technologies, including computer vision, machine learning, and natural-language processing, to reinvent mobile computing and shopping. Amazon is moving its technology from online to real world shopping through its Seattle-based Amazon Go convenience store. Customers simply enter the store, scan an app on their smartphones, and walk out with their purchases. Amazon uses AI, cameras, and sensors to identify the products they have selected and bills them automatically — no lines or checkouts necessary.
4 23andMe
Headquarters: Mountain View, California
Valuation: $1.1 billion
Genetic testing company 23andMe sells reports on risks for late-onset Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, and eight other conditions. The company has more than 2 million customers worldwide, and its DNA-related products have been used in a number of research projects, including studies of female fertility, depression, Parkinson’s disease and even nail biting.
Image: MIT Technology Review
5. Alphabet
Headquarters: Mountain View, California
Valuation: $673.9 billion
Google parent company Alphabet is responsible for subsidiaries that are technology leaders in AI, autonomous vehicles, augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR). Its DeepMind division keeps devising new ways for AI systems to mimic human intelligence, while its self-driving-car project, Waymo, continues to improve performance.
6. iFlytek
Headquarters: Hefei, China
Valuation: $6.8 billion
iFlytek already dominates China’s voice-recognition market and is now expanding into voice-activated command systems for cars, homes, robots and schools. It has also established a multimillion-dollar fund to invest in AI-related start-ups around the world. It says that more than 160,000 developers use its software and more than 400 million people use its products.
7. Kite Pharma
Headquarters: Santa Monica, California
Valuation: $5.7 billion
This immunotherapy company is taking the body’s T cells, which naturally fight infections, and engineering them to fight cancer. It is furthest along with its therapy for aggressive non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, with more than a third of one study’s participants showing no sign of disease six months after treatment.
8. Tencent
Headquarters: Shenzhen, China
Valuation: $350 billion
Owners of China’s biggest social network, WeChat, TenCent are credited by some as revealing the future of social media. Though WeChat already boasts more than 900 million monthly active users, Tencent keeps expanding the mobile app so that it now offers messaging, online gaming, shopping, music, videos and peer-to-peer payments.
9. Regeneron
Headquarters: Tarrytown, New York
Valuation: $55.5 billion
Biotech company Regeneron uses genetic information to focus its drug development efforts. In March it announced that, along with the UK biobank and pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline, it would be sequencing genetic data from 500,000 volunteers to help support research into drug development and the connections between DNA and disease. It is also creating “off-the-shelf” engineered T cells to target tumors without requiring a patient’s own immune cells to be used - an approach that could make this field of treatment much easier to scale.
10. Spark Therapeutics
Headquarters: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Valuation: $1.9 billion
In addition to its treatment for a progressive form of blindness, the company has also been testing a way to combat hemophilia B, a blood clotting disorder. This involves intravenous treatment with viruses carrying a corrected version of the gene that codes for a blood-clotting protein called factor IX. MIT Technology Review says this is one to watch because the disease, which affects one in 5,000 men, is expensive to treat conventionally.
11. Face ++
Headquarters: Beijing, China
Valuation: $1 billion
Facial recognition company Face++’s software powers many of China’s most popular applications. Alipay, the popular online payment platform, uses the technology to let users log in and make payments using their face as ID; ride-sharing provider Didi Chuxing uses it to verify the identity of its freelance drivers; and smartphone app maker Meitu uses it to offer highly detailed photo-retouching features. The five-year-old start-up is believed to be the first facial recognition unicorn, having raised at least $145 million in recent years, including at least $100 million in December 2016.
UBS Chief: We Deserve a Higher Stock Price
The Swiss bank’s booming wealth management group merits a valuation closer to peers like BlackRock.
If you are an institutional investor or a rich individual, Sergio Ermotti wants your money.
After overhauling UBS Group’s (ticker: UBS) battered franchise and turning it into a wealth management powerhouse, the CEO is hunting for a higher market valuation and more high-net-worth clients for his roughly 7,000 U.S. financial advisors.
Neither will be easy, as Ermotti acknowledged in a recent interview in Zurich.
“The priorities are twofold: One is to look and feel boring. You can continue to show the value of the transformation…so you can repeat the success. Nothing wrong with that: It’s like winning the [soccer] Champions League every year,” says the 57-year-old Ermotti, who is an ardent supporter of Italy’s AC Milan. “The second one is, how do you get fit and prepare for the changing environment?”
In the market’s eyes, UBS is caught between two stools. Since taking over in 2011, Ermotti shrank the investment bank and its balance sheet to refocus on UBS’ golden goose of wealth management—a legacy of its Swiss heritage and the (troubled) buy of U.S. brokerage PaineWebber in 2000.
The strategy, while mostly successful, has made the firm a strange beast in the financial-services jungle. UBS is the world’s largest wealth manager, with about $2 trillion in assets, but its investment bank still contributes more than a quarter of operating income (through the first quarter).
How to value such a hybrid? The market’s response has been: as an investment bank, beset by concerns over regulation, litigation, and profitability. That’s why, despite a 50% rise in the shares since 2012, the bank’s valuation is still in the middle of the industry pack, at around 1.2 times book value.
Investors’ refusal to embrace the new, improved UBS is vexing for its CEO. “At the end of the day, what we are isn’t the most expensive…investment bank. We are the cheapest asset-gatherer in the world,” he says, casting a beady eye on the richer valuations of U.S. money manager BlackRock (BLK), with a price-to-book value of 2.4 times, and Julius Baer Group (JBAXY), the Swiss private bank that trades at 2.1 times.
But those firms don’t have an investment bank that, although much lauded for its narrow focus and monklike attention to costs, still carries the remnants of a troubled past. Ermotti sees litigation costs and regulation as the two biggest hurdles to a rerating of UBS shares.
On the first issue, he reels off numbers like a man who has been spending a long time thinking about this problem. “Since I started…we put aside money for provisions of nine billion Swiss francs ($9.3 billion). We had CHF4 billion in legal costs, litigation costs, regulatory remediation.” That’s a cool CHF13 billion-worth, as Ermotti points out, three Swiss francs per share. Reducing these costs to a normalized level could add CHF2 billion back into earnings, giving the shares, now around CHF16, a slight boost.
On regulation, Ermotti bemoans the chilling effect that uncertainty—from the much-delayed Basel III capital buffers to the U.S.’ tough treatment of foreign banks—is having on his ability to deploy cash. “Nobody in the world believes we need more capital. Now the question is: ‘Guys, how much of this capital can be returned to shareholders?’ ” he says. “Until you unlock some of these issues, you don’t get a rerating.”
But Ermotti remains optimistic the market will eventually agree with his sum-of-the-parts valuation for UBS (a higher multiple for its wealth management business, blended with a lower valuation for its investment banking). “It isn’t a matter of years, it’s a matter of quarters,” he says.
CRUCIAL TO THIS STRATEGY is the firm’s U.S. wealth management unit, which accounts for more than half of its total assets. UBS has focused on the fastest-growing segments of high-net-worth individuals (with investible assets of between CHF2 million and CHF50 million) and ultra-high-net-worth individuals (above CHF50 million). “We went upmarket,” Ermotti says. “We don’t play for size. We play for quality.”
It’s a far cry from the dog days of the financial crisis of 2008, when UBS’ previous management repeatedly tried (and failed) to sell the loss-making unit to rivals. Ermotti stated his commitment to U.S. wealth management and saw the red ink replaced by an annual profit of CHF1.1 billion.
UBS is also starting to get a grip on compensation costs—the traditional bugbear of an industry where the big producers tend to jump ship when they get a better offer. UBS was “an unlikely trendsetter,” as the CEO puts it, in January when it overhauled its compensation structure in an effort to reward retention and reduce attrition.
“The previous system was no longer sustainable in the long term and not in the best interest of our clients and our stakeholders,” Ermotti explains. “We pay advisors a higher commission base, based on employment tenure, growth, and productivity.” He professed himself pleased with the early results, but it will take years to truly test the new system.
As a committed soccer fan, Ermotti knows that it is not easy, or likely, to win the Champions League every year.
ECB Taper Talk Puts Spotlight on Italy
Any sharp rise in borrowing costs risks reviving questions over the sustainability of Italian debt.
The recent volatility in bond markets has stirred up old fears in Europe. Investors have long been concerned about the possible impact of the end of the European Central Bank’s quantitative easing program on the eurozone’s periphery, not least Italy—the country long-regarded as too big to save. Now with markets abuzz with talk of central bank monetary policy “normalization,” those concerns are once again front of mind: Without the fire blanket of ECB government bond-buying, will Italian borrowing costs soar once again, plunging the eurozone back into crisis?
For the moment, there is no sign of any panic—or any immediate cause for alarm. Italian 10-year government bond yields have risen sharply in the past two weeks to just over 2.2% in tandem with other eurozone government bond markets. But the spread between German and Italian bond yields—a measure of the perceived riskiness of Italian bonds—has widened only modestly to 1.7 percentage points, well below the recent peak of 2.2 percentage points ahead of May’s French presidential election though still above the 1.3 percentage points a year ago before fears about Italian political risks started rising in the run-up to a November constitutional referendum.
Nonetheless, investors are wary because at some point rising Italian government bond yields run the risk of creating negative feedback loops into the real economy via higher domestic borrowing costs. With the trifecta of Italian government debt equivalent to 132% of gross domestic product, growth not expected to exceed 1.4% this year, and inflation still below 1%, any sharp rise in borrowing costs risks reviving questions over the sustainability of Italian debt. Italy can cope with bond yields rising above 2%, but what if they rise above 3% or 4%? asks Marchel Alexandrovich, European economist at Jefferies International.
These concerns are shared by policy makers, though ECB officials say they won’t allow this to influence its decision-making: the ECB’s task is to set monetary policy conditions for the whole eurozone, not an individual country. Besides, there is no reason why any ECB decision to taper its purchases of government bonds should trigger a crisis. After all, the Italian government benefits from a deep and liquid domestic market for its bonds: the Italian household sector holds €3 trillion worth of liquid assets and is currently adding to those savings at an annualized rate equivalent to more than 8% of GDP.
At the same time, the government is running a primary budget surplus which means that Rome only needs to issue new debt to roll over existing debt and cover its interest expense—a task made easier by the Treasury’s efforts to lock in current low-interest rates and extend the maturity profile of its debts. Policy makers also note that a rise in interest rates may not be as damaging as investors fear since higher household investment income could boost spending and growth.
The real short-term risk is that ECB tapering might crystallize existing fears about Italian political risks ahead of the general election that must be held by the end of February. If the outcome was a populist 5 Star Movement committed to taking Italy out of the euro, the eurozone would be plunged into crisis from which there is no obvious escape. Under such circumstances, Rome is unlikely to request the kind of bailout program needed to unlock further ECB assistance.
Yet even if the eurozone survives this test—continuing this year’s pattern of market-friendly political surprises—policy makers fear that long-term political risks will continue to hang over the government debt market. True, Italy is currently enjoying a cyclical upswing, helped by a buoyant global economy. It should also reap some benefits from the recent, belated efforts finally to clean up its banking system and tackle the legacy of bad debts. Other recent overhauls should also contribute to stronger growth including reforms of the labor market, judiciary and new incentives to encourage equity investment which should help unlock access to capital markets.
But these reforms are unlikely to lift Italy’s long-term growth prospects to levels that would remove concerns about its long-term debt sustainability. In a recent speech, ECB executive director Benoît Coeuré drew attention to the striking correlation between the quality of a country’s institutions as measured by the World Bank’s Worldwide Governance Index and its GDP/capita. Italy’s position at the bottom of the eurozone governance league, ahead of only Greece, may partly explain why Italy’s GDP/capita growth performance has also languished at the bottom of the European league, having remained stagnant for the best part of two decades.
This suggests that the key to sustainably boosting Italy’s long-term performance lies in deeper institutional overhauls that will speed up the reallocation of resources to the most productive sectors of the economy and discourage the kind of rent-seeking that continues to drag on productivity and GDP/capita. For that, Italy needs a stable government committed to delivering reforms. Until it finds one, the specter of crisis will continue to stalk Italy—and the eurozone.
Amazon threatened to kill its Whole Foods deal if the grocer started a bidding war
... or if the M&A talks leaked to the press.
Amazon has long had a reputation as a hard-ball negotiator. It turns out its negotiations with Whole Foods leading up to its $13.7 billion acquisition agreement were no different, according to an SEC filing outlining a timeline of the talks between the two companies.
On May 23, Amazon made a written offer to acquire Whole Foods for $41 a share, less than a month after the first meeting between senior executives of the companies, the filing said.
Whole Foods came back with a counterproposal of $45 a share, which got Amazon to increase its offer to $42. But Amazon’s bankers from Goldman Sachs then “stressed several times” that the increase to $42 represented Amazon’s “best and final offer.”
Amazon’s bankers “also made it clear again ... that Amazon.com would disengage from its efforts to acquire the Company and pursue other alternatives and initiatives if the $42.00 per share price were not accepted,” the filing said, “and that Amazon.com expected that the Company would not approach other potential bidders while the Company was negotiating with Amazon.com.”
Amazon also threatened it would walk away if the talks leaked to the press, which they did not.
Translation: $42 or nada.
According to the filing, Whole Foods’ board of directors believed that the hard line Amazon outlined was “highly credible” and also believed that Amazon “would likely have sought to acquire another industry participant” if Whole Foods declined the offer or sought other bids. The board also said the best bet to “obtaining a superior transaction would be to enter into the attractive Amazon.com transaction to which any potential third party bidders could then react.”
As a result, Whole Foods never went back to another unnamed suitor — referred to as “Company X” — that had presented Whole Foods with a merger idea that would work out to $35 to $40 a share for Whole Foods shareholders. (If you have an idea of who this suitor is, I’d be interested in hearing it.)
Whole Foods also did not engage with four private equity firms that had expressed initial separate interest in a potential leveraged buyout of the grocer. The Whole Foods board, according to the filing, was concerned that the talks might leak and also did not think the PE firms would be able to beat Amazon’s offer.
In the end, the $42-a-share offer represented a 27 percent premium to Whole Foods’ closing stock price on the day before the deal was announced.
Other bidders can still bring offers to Whole Foods between now and when the company’s shareholders vote on the deal. If that happens and Whole Foods accepts another offer, the grocer would have to pay Amazon a $400 million breakup fee.
Amazon Prime is on pace to become more popular than cable TV
Estimates show that nearly as many U.S. households subscribe to Prime as to pay TV.
Someday soon, more U.S. households will be subscribers of Amazon Prime than cable or satellite TV, according to recent estimates of Amazon’s popular shipping and entertainment service.
According to estimates from Morningstar, nearly 79 million U.S. households now have an Amazon Prime membership*, up from around 66 million at the end of last year.
That compares to a projected 90 million U.S. households that will pay for cable or satellite TV this year, according to S&P Global.
According to these estimates, more U.S. households may have an Amazon Prime subscription than a pay TV subscription as soon as next year.
The implication here is not that Amazon’s Prime Video service is more popular than TV; the main reason most people subscribe to Amazon Prime is still the fast delivery of products.
But it is an indication that Prime is moving toward becoming a “no-brainer” for more than just wealthy Americans. To that end, Amazon has been courting lower-income American households with discounts for those on government assistance, as well as a monthly payment option for those who don’t want to cough up $99 for an annual subscription.
These growth tactics are important, since more than 80 percent of America’s wealthiest households already pay for Prime. And Amazon knows that Prime is the core of its retail business: Prime members spend more in a year than non-Prime members do, shop more frequently than others, and price-compare less, according to studies.
* Amazon doesn’t disclose Prime member numbers, so Morningstar’s estimates are based on an analysis of Amazon’s cash-flow statement. There are survey-based Prime membership estimates from other companies that range as high as 85 million U.S. members and as low as 60 million.