>>> Vigor to receive non-binding offers this week; Lactalis, Danone, Saputo, Lal

Vigor to receive non-binding offers this week; Lactalis, Danone, Saputo, Lala possibly interested - report (translated)
12 JUL 2017
Vigor [[BVMF:VIGR3], the Brazilian dairy company put on the block by J&F, will start receiving non-binding offers this week, Valor Economico reported, citing sources familiar with the matter.
According to the sources, possible parties interested in the asset include France's Lactalis and Danone [EPA:BN], Canada's Saputo [TSE:SAP] and Mexico's Lala [MX:LALAB].
Vigor had BRL 6bn (USD 1.8bn) sales in 2016, the Portuguese-language newspaper said.
J&F and Lactalis declined to comment, while Saputo and Danone said they don't comment on market rumors. Lala did not return requests for comment, the item added.

>>> Hedge funds show modest June gains

Hedge funds returns in June were somewhere between a modest loss and a modest gain, figures from three data providers suggest.
Eurekahedge, one of the data providers, said hedge funds “ended their five-month winning streak” in June by making a loss of 0.19%, while the key equity benchmark, the MSCI AC World Index (Local), moved upwards by 0.18%.
However, data from eVestment also out this week showed hedge funds performed positively in June. The firm said the hedge fund average return for the month was 0.13%.
It was even higher, at 0.4% according to HFR’s Fund Weighted Composite Index, and the firm said was the eighth consecutive monthly gain.
The year-to-date return by hedge funds was positive in all cases. Eurekahedge said hedge funds were up 3.03% and eVestment said the return was a positive 3.26%. HFR said hedge funds returned 3.7%.
However, the long-only MSCI index returned more: 7.65% according to Eurekahedge.
Emerging markets were the stronger performers in June. They returned 0.67%, according to Eurekahedge, while European hedge funds, for example, posted a decline of 0.18%.
North American fund managers posted modest returns of 0.32%.

FT : IAG calls for EU to relax ownership laws as Brexit concerns

IAG calls for EU to relax ownership laws as Brexit concerns mount
UK’s departure could force British Airways’ owner to buy out shareholders or risk break-up

International Airlines Group has pleaded for the EU to overhaul its “arcane” airline ownership laws, which rivals and analysts warn could force the owner of British Airways and Iberia to buy out a quarter of its shareholders or risk being broken up after Brexit.

Willie Walsh, chief executive of IAG, told the European Parliament on Tuesday he was “confident” the company’s structures would survive Brexit and meet the EU’s strict licensing rules.

But, in his first admission of potential challenges ahead, Mr Walsh called for the UK and EU to reach a comprehensive air transport agreement that “should also clarify” that UK nationals would count towards the EU ownership requirements, even after Brexit. 

Speaking to a group of MEPs, Mr Walsh said the EU “operates under an arcane system regulating the ownership and control of airlines”, and called for the rules to be relaxed. 

“Those structures are unnecessary,” he said. “I would prefer to see a situation whereby we don’t have to replicate [them].” 

For an airline to operate routes within the EU, it must demonstrate that it is effectively owned and controlled by EU nationals, with at least 50 per cent of its shares held by EU nationals. This poses a problem for UK airlines after Brexit, when their UK shareholders will no longer be classed as EU shareholders.


Several independent estimates all point to IAG falling below 50 per cent after Brexit, a problem shared with other airlines. 

Senior EU officials, analysts and rivals of IAG have told the Financial Times that, unless the UK and EU reach an agreement to waive the issue, IAG will be forced to spin off part of the group or buy out up to a quarter of its shareholder base in order to maintain lucrative EU flying rights. 

Andrew Lobbenberg, head of transport equities at HSBC, told the FT: “After Brexit, we think IAG will need to be demonstrably an EU-owned and controlled airline. But it is unclear how that gets to be the case.” 

Michael O’Leary of Ryanair, an outspoken critic of IAG and its Irish carrier Aer Lingus, said the airline was “in complete . . . denial” about the ownership challenge. 

“They’re hoping that it’ll go away,” he told the FT. “They’ll have to front up to how catastrophic it is at some point though. They don’t know themselves [how to solve it]. But their shareholders will have to sell, and the group has to get broken up.” 

Brian Havel, a professor in aviation law at the University of Oxford, also told the FT that IAG “could not exist in its current form” after Brexit.

Mr Walsh has in the past said he has “absolutely no concerns” about the IAG structure, which ensures all three of its carriers are able to maintain their national flying rights in Spain, the UK and Ireland, and has denied that the group will need to be broken up. A spokesperson for IAG said it would “continue to comply with all the relevant ownership and control regulations”.

Unlike some other airlines, IAG has refused to reveal what proportion of its current shareholders would still be EU nationals after Brexit. A clause in the company’s bylaws allows the IAG board to determine which “bona fide” interested parties can be given information on the group’s shareholder breakdown on request. The FT asked for such information, but was told its request was not “bona fide”. 

Stephen Furlong, an aviation analyst at Davy, estimates that the group will be 20 percent owned by EU nationals in 2019, and Bloomberg data also suggest that only one-fifth of the group’s shareholders will be EU nationals after Brexit. One independent financial analysis circulating in the industry suggests that, even in the best-case scenario, where all those shares whose ownership is difficult to trace are classified as belonging to EU nationals, IAG remains 6 per cent short of the 50 per cent limit.

IAG has provisions in its bylaws to force non-EU shareholders to sell their shares if the company is at risk of losing its flying rights. The EU takes the issue of ownership requirements seriously, and has previously investigated airlines where it suspects non-EU ownership has dropped below 50 per cent. 

UK airlines were hoping that a set of guidelines on ownership and control issued by the European Commission last month would loosen the rules. Instead, they merely reinforced the status quo and confirmed that the EU will consider “effective control” — specifically, the entities or persons who ultimately own the shares — when deciding if an airline is majority controlled by EU nationals.

Other airlines have been more explicit about the challenges that ownership rules will pose after Brexit. EasyJet has said it will be 49 per cent owned by EU nationals after Brexit, while Ryanair said 38 per cent of its shareholder base would EU owned and controlled. 

Mr O’Leary told the FT on Tuesday that he hopes to make up some of the shortfall by encouraging pension funds to switch from holding shares in the UK to the EU, but warned that up to 10 per cent of his non-EU shareholders — potentially including UK nationals — “may be forced to sell their shares or be disenfranchised.”

WSJ : One Game Warren Buffett Doesn’t Play: Chicken

One Game Warren Buffett Doesn’t Play: Chicken
Elliott Management says it is planning to counter Berkshire’s $9 billion bid for Energy Future

Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway Inc. BRK.B -0.59% is under pressure to do something it usually doesn’t do: raise its bid.
Berkshire’s subsidiary Berkshire Hathaway Energy struck a deal last week to buy bankrupt Energy Future Holdings Corp., including Texas electricity-transmission business Oncor, for $9 billion in cash.
Paul Singer’s Elliott Management Corp., a major Energy Future creditor, said Berkshire’s bid doesn’t value Oncor highly enough and that it is working on a rival offer. “It is quite likely that the Berkshire transaction will not close, given the lack of support from the debtors’ creditors,” a lawyer for Elliott wrote in a Tuesday letter that was publicly released by the hedge fund.

For decades, Mr. Buffett has included in his company’s annual report a list of criteria for companies that might want to sell businesses to Berkshire. Berkshire is looking for large companies with little debt, the list says—and it isn’t interested in bidding wars or hostile takeovers.
“We don’t participate in auctions,” Mr. Buffett wrote in the latest annual report. “A line from a country song expresses our feeling about new ventures, turnarounds, or auction-like sales: ‘When the phone don’t ring, you’ll know it’s me.’”

If the Oncor deal doesn’t go through, Energy Future would pay Berkshire Hathaway Energy a $270 million fee, according to a filing. The fee would have to be approved by the bankruptcy court.
The potential Berkshire deal would need permission from a bankruptcy court and from Texas regulators. Regulators already have indicated they would support Berkshire as a buyer.
Berkshire Hathaway Energy declined to comment.
Berkshire watchers said the company is unlikely to raise its initial bid. “His trump card is his willingness to walk away,” said David Rolfe, chief investment officer at Wedgewood Partners, which manages about $6 billion and holds Berkshire shares, referring to Mr. Buffett. “He does not have a history of bidding-type competitions, and he typically has played a pretty strong hand.”
Mr. Buffett has long been known for quickly negotiating deals and sticking with his initial price offer.
“His playbook is not to negotiate,” said Robert Miles, who has written books on Berkshire. “Buffett would take the $270 million and move on to the next deal, which is what they did with Constellation.”

Berkshire’s energy unit reached a deal in 2008 to buy Constellation Energy Group Inc. but withdrew the offer after state-controlled Electricité de France SA agreed to buy a stake in Constellation. Berkshire received a $175 million breakup fee.
To be sure, many potential Berkshire deals that fall through never become public. In 2012, Mr. Buffett told shareholders that Berkshire almost spent $22 billion buying a company but couldn’t reach an agreement. He didn’t name the potential target.
A recent withdrawal occurred earlier this year when Kraft Heinz Co. , which is partly owned by Berkshire and Brazilian private-equity firm 3G Capital, backed away from a $143 billion approach to take overUnilever PLC in February after Unilever declined. Mr. Buffett revealed at his company’s May annual meeting that Berkshire would have invested $15 billion if the deal were reached.
“If it’s unwelcome, there is no offer,” Mr. Buffett told CNBC in February.
Mr. Buffett famously participated in one hostile deal decades ago—the takeover of Berkshire itself. Mr. Buffett bought shares in Berkshire, which was a New England textile company, starting in 1962. In 1965, he appeared at a board meeting to take control of the company formally and replace the management.
In retrospect, he has said, the deal was a mistake. “I found myself…invested in a terrible business about which I knew very little,” he wrote in 2014.
Mr. Buffett did raise the offer price in 1999 when he bought a majority stake in MidAmerican Energy Holdings Co., now called Berkshire Hathaway Energy. But he made the switch before the deal was announced, as he explained in his 2007 letter to shareholders.
Mr. Buffett originally offered $35 a share for MidAmerican, but after pressure from investment bankers, he raised it to $35.05, he said in the letter. “With that, I explained, they could tell their client they had wrung the last nickel out of me,” he wrote. “At the time, it hurt.”
But given MidAmerican’s growth since then, he said in the same letter, “I’m glad I wilted and offered the extra nickel.”

Reuters : Exclusive: Ant Financial refiles for U.S. approval of MoneyGram deal -

Exclusive: Ant Financial refiles for U.S. approval of MoneyGram deal - sources

Ant Financial, the affiliate of China's Alibaba Group Holding Ltd (BABA.N) that agreed to buy money transfer company MoneyGram International Inc (MGI.O) for $1.2 billion, has resubmitted the deal for U.S. review, people familiar with the matter said.

The deal is the latest and most high-profile transaction to be refiled this year with the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS), a secretive government panel which reviews acquisitions by foreign entities for potential national security risks.

Ant Financial and MoneyGram refiled after they were unable to secure clearance from CFIUS within the maximum time of 75 days that is awarded for assessing applications, the sources said on Tuesday.

Refiling resets the clock and gives up to another 75 days for the companies to complete the national security review and try to resolve potential issues.

"We are not commenting on the CFIUS process, but we are continuing to work with the various regulatory agencies and remain focused on closing the transaction by the end of the year," Ant Financial said in a statement.

MoneyGram declined to comment.

A CFIUS refile does not necessarily mean that a deal will be rejected, although it does indicate increased government scrutiny. More deals have had to be refiled with CFIUS following the inauguration of U.S. President Donald Trump in January, as several key positions at several government departments remain vacant or have taken too long to be filled.

CFIUS did not respond to a request for comment.

CFIUS had accepted notices of more than 120 transactions as of June 23, on pace to set a record, according to estimates by law firm Covington & Burling LLP. By comparison, CFIUS had received notices of just 97 transactions in all of 2013.

Ant Financial finalized its deal to buy Dallas-based MoneyGram in April, after it sweetened its bid by over a third to beat a rival offer from U.S.-based Euronet Worldwide Inc (EEFT.O).

MoneyGram's global remittance channels for sending money overseas would help Ant Financial, formerly known as Alipay, build a cross-border network after a string of recent investments in Asia.

Some U.S. lawmakers, including Republican Senators Pat Roberts and Jerry Moran, have written to Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, who also serves as chairman of CFIUS, to express concern that Ant Financial's acquisition of MoneyGram could pose national security threats, arguing that the information of U.S. citizens, including military personnel, could be compromised.

Ant Financial has said that MoneyGram's data infrastructure will remain in the United States, with personal information encrypted or held in secure facilities on U.S. soil. It has also pointed to existing U.S. regulations that call for such protections.

CFIUS approved a previous deal by Ant Financial, its acquisition last year of Kansas City-based EyeVerify, the company behind a mobile eye verification technology.

In addition to CFIUS, at least 46 U.S. states must have granted money transmitter licenses before the deal closes. Ant Financial is already approved for money transfers in 23 U.S. states, according to analysts at Elevation LLC.

WWD : Colette Concept Store to Shutter in December

Colette Concept Store to Shutter in December
The store is in talks with Saint Laurent to take over the location.

PARIS – Landmark French concept store Colette is closing its doors after 20 years.

Staff were informed of the decision on Wednesday morning, said Sarah Andelman, creative director and purchasing manager. Andelman is the public face of the boutique, founded by her mother, Colette Roussaux.

“As all good things must come to an end, after 20 wonderful years, Colette should be closing its doors on Dec. 20 of this year,” the store said in a statement, explaining that Roussaux was ready to retire.

“Until our last day, nothing will change. Colette will continue to renew itself each week with exclusive collaborations and offerings, also available on our website colette.fr,” it added.

The store is in talks with Saint Laurent to take over the location, it said.

“We would be proud to have a brand with such a history, with whom we have frequently collaborated, taking over our address. We are happy of the serious interest expressed by Saint Laurent in this project, and it could also represent a very good opportunity for our employees,” it added.

Colette, famed for its regularly updated window displays and frequent store events, recently launched a series of monthlong takeovers of the store, beginning with Balenciaga from June 19 to Aug. 5.

Les Vacances de Lucien, offering a selection from brands represented by Paris PR firm Lucien Pagès, will take over the space from Aug. 7 to Sept. 2; followed by Sacai, from Sept. 4 to Sept. 30; Thom Browne from Oct. 2 to Oct. 28; Chanel from Oct. 30 to Nov. 25, and wrapping with Saint Laurent from Nov. 27 to Dec. 20.

The concept store famous for its blue dot logo posted revenues of 28 million euros, or $31 million, in 2016, with online accounting for roughly 20 percent, according to a spokesman.

It celebrated its 20th anniversary in March at Les Arts Décoratifs, where Brooklyn-based design firm Snarkitecture set up its installation “The Beach,” featuring an enclosure filled with 300,000 recyclable plastic balls.

In an interview with WWD at the time, Andelman – who has spent her entire career at Colette – responded to speculation about the future of the boutique.

“Every year, people ask us how long we plan to go on. We are always searching for newness, discovering new designers and launching new talents, so there is no reason to give up. If suddenly there were nothing interesting left anywhere, we would reconsider, but fortunately something cool comes along every day,” she said.

She said Roussaux, who still lives above the store, was the majority owner of the business and had never considered bringing in an outside investor. Andelman also said she did not know the revenues of the store.

“Our accountant does, but luckily, I function more by instinct. I never have a budget when I’m ordering. That doesn’t mean I spend money as if it didn’t belong to me. I’m careful. My orders are reasonable,” she said. “I know I own a percentage, but likewise, I don’t know what my percentage is.”

Andelman said the store’s revenues were hit by the terrorist attacks in Paris in November 2015, which sharply impacted tourism, but added the retailer was better equipped than some luxury brands to deal with with drop-off.

“We work at it, but we’re lucky in the sense that we get a steady amount of foot traffic, unlike some luxury stores on streets like Avenue Montaigne. So even if there is a drop in the number of foreign visitors, or people cut back their spending, the store keeps going at times like these,” she said. “We really felt the impact last summer. Fortunately, we also sell online and our e-commerce site is growing.”

(TechCrunch) Marketplace liquidity

Liquidity is a crucial metric for all marketplaces. But how can we truly evaluate this liquidity? The three keys to answering this question are density, appropriately balanced demand and supply and category concentration.
Density, geographic reach and distance between counterparts
The first step to analyzing the potential liquidity of a marketplace is understanding its geographic extent. For example, Upwork will see transactions filled between freelancers and employers all around the globe, while Tinder will (typically) only see two people dating within the same city. Tinder would therefore require a city per city launch and a city per city liquidity analysis.
In local marketplaces, there is a strong correlation between density and liquidity. The higher the number of participants within a relevant radius, the higher the liquidity of the marketplace. We define liquidity as the number of transactions filled out of the total potential transactions in a marketplace. We refer to density as the number of participants within a certain geographic area.
Let’s use Tinder as an example. If in a given week Tinder acquires 1,000 female participants in Chicago and 1,000 male participants in New York, Tinder’s number of total users increases, but its liquidity remains the same. Now, if Tinder acquires 1,000 female participants and 1,000 male participants all located in the borough of Brooklyn, this higher density of users (from both sides of the marketplace) will lead to higher liquidity.
To determine the density in a marketplace, you need to first define the limits of the geographic area within which its transactions can be filled. This distance threshold (“r” in the visual below) is different for every marketplace and you will identify it by understanding how far your customers are willing to travel to complete their transaction. For example, a seller at Letgo might not be willing to travel 30 minutes to sell a used skateboard for $30, but a babysitter at Care.com will likely travel 30 minutes to make $150 for a day of babysitting.
Once you define this distance threshold “r” you need to maximize density. But how?
You start by optimizing your marketing strategy to achieve the highest customer acquisition within the established distance threshold. As a result, you will maximize the active participants within that distance of each other, and therefore maximize density, moving from the low-density to the high-density marketplace diagram above.
The evolution of a balanced marketplace
Maintaining the optimal balance of demand and supply in a marketplace is crucial to achieve liquidity. If a marketplace doesn’t have the right number of buyers per listing, or the right number of items listed per buyer, transactions will go unfilled.
How can we analyze what is the right balance of demand and supply? By looking at several ratios:
  • The average number of buyers relative to the number of sellers needed to fill a transaction
  • The number of bids per buyer required to fill a transaction
  • The average of items listed per seller required to fill a transaction
Let’s base our example on a used furniture marketplace in which the average ratio of bids per item listed required to fill a transaction is 100 to 1. So, every item listed needs 100 bids for it to sell. Now the conversion from this ratio to the ratio of buyers to sellers is determined by the average number of bids per buyer and the average number of items each seller is selling. This is the key to the analysis.
For simplicity, let’s assume the average items posted per seller is 1 and the average bids per buyer is 10. This means that the ratio of buyers to sellers is 10:1; it requires 10 buyers for every seller, to fill a transaction. However, it usually takes time for the average number of bids per buyer to be this high, and it will only happen once the company has reached a stable stage of liquidity.
At an early stage, the likely scenario is that the average number of bids per buyer is 1 or less, which means the ratio of buyers to sellers initially is more like 100:1. So, it requires 100 buyers for every seller to fill a transaction. The ratio of buyers to sell would evolve like this:

The first reason why average bids per buyer increase over time is that when a new buyer experiences a marketplace for the first time, they are hesitant to bid. The buyer needs to trust the marketplace before being ready to make a committing bid. Trust takes time. Furthermore, at a stable stage the diversity of inventory in the marketplace will increase the likelihood that a buyer will find something that interests them.
However, the conclusion here is not just that the bids per buyer increase over time and that this determines the evolution of a balanced marketplace. It is that you need to closely monitor the second-degree KPIs (like bids per buyer and listings per seller) to understand how to adjust your strategies to maintain a balanced marketplace over time. In the same way that it is common for average bids per buyer to increase over time, it also is usual that the average items listed per seller change over time.
Category concentration and diminishing marginal returns
Once you have defined the distance threshold under which your marketplace will fill transactions, you need to breakdown the liquidity per category within the marketplace. For example, if our used furniture marketplace has 1 million active buyers at a certain point in time, how many of them are in the market for a table? How many are looking for chairs? How many want a couch? Only a small segment of the 1 million active buyers will be interested in each category. This means you cannot just evaluate the overall liquidity of the marketplace, you need to do it on a per-category basis.
It is often the case that most participants are interested in just a few of the categories served by the marketplace. This means that as you spend marketing dollars to acquire users, the higher-concentration categories will yield liquidity faster than the rest. And in most cases, the low-concentration categories will require a much larger marketing investment to achieve liquidity.
Let’s go back to our furniture marketplace example to illustrate this point with the following assumptions:
  • 50 percent of the buyers are interested in buying a couch while the other 50 percent are equally scattered across 50 other furniture categories
  • We are spending $100 on marketing
  • Our CAC is $1
  • The liquidity threshold per category is 50 buyers (the liquidity threshold is the number of buyers needed for a transaction to fill)
We would have 50 new buyers in the couch category, and one new buyer in each of the other 50 categories. The 50 new buyers in the couch category will substantially increase the likelihood of a filled transaction within its category, while the additional one participant in any of the remaining categories barely increases its chances to fill a transaction in their respective areas.
If we take this example to scale and we assume:
  • Marketing budget of $500,000
  • A liquidity threshold per category of 250,000 participants
Only the couch category would reach liquidity. And even if we were to invest $1 million in marketing, only the couch category would reach liquidity because all the other areas would only reach 10,000 participants each. And the same would happen until the invested amount goes above $25 million. This means that such a marketing strategy would lead to diminishing marginal returns from a liquidity standpoint:
Again, the best way to solve this issue is to align the marketing strategy to the category concentration. In other words, allocate the majority of the marketing investment to the most predominant category (which in our example would be the couch category). The liquidity chart in that case would look like this:
This is, of course, an extreme example.
A more realistic case would have several concentrated categories and a long tail of dozens of others. To illustrate this, let’s assume 30 percent of the buyers want to buy a couch, 20 percent a chair, 10 percent a table and the remaining 40 percent are scattered across the 40 other outstanding categories. This time, the liquidity chart would look like this (which is more realistic):
Density, a balanced demand and supply and category concentration are crucial drivers of marketplace liquidity. To maximize your return on marketing investment, you need to align your marketing and liquidity strategies. To monitor the evolution of your liquidity, you need to track your second-degree KPIs.
VCs should also dig into these three principles when evaluating a marketplace investment opportunity.