Barron's : How to Deregulate Wall Street (Without Causing a Crash)

How to Deregulate Wall Street (Without Causing a Crash)
Wall Street should reform its outdated compensation system that rewards bankers for taking big risks.

Regulatory relief for the country’s big banks may soon be on the way—and not a moment too soon.
For seven years, the unintended consequences of the Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act have clogged the gears of capitalism. Colloquially known as Dodd-Frank, the bill was designed to ensure that big banks would never again trigger a financial crisis. But the law’s 848 pages and the 22,000 or so additional pages of related rules and regulations have created a crisis of their own.
The more onerous provisions effectively restrict bank lending and reduce financial-market liquidity, creating a drag on U.S. economic growth, which has slogged along at about 2% a year—what Harvard University economist Larry Summers has termed “secular stagnation.”
The promise of Donald Trump and his economic advisors and a Republican Congress is that loosening the restrictions on Wall Street and other banks will unleash long-hibernating animal spirits and jolt the nation’s gross-domestic-product growth into a higher trajectory.

In February, President Trump issued an executive order signaling his intention to dismantle Dodd-Frank. In the past month or so alone, the House of Representatives passed a bill gutting Dodd-Frank and sent it on to the Senate, and the Treasury Department issued a lengthy report calling for Dodd-Frank to be trashed. The most important piece in this puzzle, however, has gotten the least attention. On July 10, the president nominated Randal Quarles to the Federal Reserve Board of Governors and gave him the responsibility for regulating Wall Street and removing the shackles that Dodd-Frank and other postcrisis rules have placed on it.
Quarles, 59, a onetime partner at the Carlyle Group who left at the end of 2013 to start his own private-equity firm, served as a Treasury official in both Bush administrations. Not surprisingly, he is known to favor a lighter regulatory touch than his predecessor, Daniel Tarullo, and will push for the elimination of many of the rules that Wall Street dislikes. In a March 2016 Wall Street Journal opinion column, he criticized the then-popular idea of breaking up the big banks, which he thought would damage the economy.
TEAM TRUMP’S IDEA is that by encouraging banks to lend money to small and medium-size businesses—those that Dodd-Frank critics say have been more or less starved for capital in the past decade—hiring, wages, and investment will increase. GDP growth is highly correlated to bank lending and, so the theory goes, encouraging more lending should help the economy break out of its GDP rut. “This has been a great eight years for rich people in New York, in California, but for the average American, they haven’t seen wage increases,” said Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin in a recent interview. “The president understands that, and that’s the vision he has, and that’s the vision that I signed up for since Day One—to build an economic plan that would create jobs and create more growth in this country.” (At Treasury, Mnuchin keeps a framed copy of a newspaper article about his nomination, with Trump’s notation on it: “5% GDP.”)
Easier said than done. According to the nonpartisan Conference Board, the consensus GDP estimates for the rest of 2017 and 2018 still are much closer to 2% than to 4%. A recent study from Stanford University’s Hoover Institution argued that 3% growth would be possible if the administration’s plans were adopted. (Not coincidentally, three of the study’s authors are considered possible successors to Fed Chair Janet Yellen.) At the very least, if the administration acts judiciously—eliminating the worst of Dodd-Frank while bolstering the best—the changes will strengthen the financial markets and possibly lessen the impact of the next crisis, when it comes.
Deregulation has its dangers, including allowing Wall Street to take too much risk and to concoct products that export that risk to investors around the globe. Trump should be careful not to give the big banks carte blanche. They need and even want smart regulations, in the same way drivers know that seat-belt and drunk-driving laws make the roads safer for everyone.
To ease up on regulatory speed limits without causing another economic calamity, Trump should strike a grand bargain with Wall Street. In exchange for the smarter regulation that the banking industry seeks, and seems on the verge of getting, he should insist that Wall Street adhere to several postcrisis rules, including those that require higher bank capital and reduced balance-sheet leverage and that require derivatives to be traded on exchanges where their prices can be determined more easily. And, as part of the grand bargain, Trump should also insist that Wall Street reform its outdated compensation system, which rewards bankers, traders, and executives for taking big risks with other people’s money, but fails to hold them accountable when things go wrong, as happened in 2008.
Bankers, and the politicians who love their political donations, have been silent on the twisted incentives created by Wall Street’s longstanding pay practices. But a few responsible voices, including Warren Buffett, Bank of England Governor Mark Carney, and New York Fed President William Dudley, have pointed out the need to tweak incentives to change the culture on Wall Street and the behavior of the people who work there. In a March speech in London, Dudley reiterated his view that “bad incentives” played a key role in the financial crisis—and continue to be problematic.
“Compensation,” he said, “once again seems to be at the center of a scandal,” referring to the Wells Fargo fiasco. “Neighborhood bankers were paid based on the volume of new accounts opened, apparently with utter disregard for whether customers wanted them or even knew about them.”
While getting Wall Street to change its pay practices won’t be easy, there is little question that it would be popular politically. Who could be against a system that better ties compensation on Wall Street to the behavior of the people who work there? Furthermore, there is a historical precedent that bankers and traders on Wall Street will recognize.
Prior to 1970, the Wall Street partnership structure ensured that bankers had plenty of skin in the game—essentially their full net worth was on the line every day. Requiring that Wall Street’s top executives, bankers, and traders again have a significant portion of their wealth at risk would provide much-needed accountability and reinforce the soundness and safety of the financial system. It would also unleash the power of the U.S. economy.
DODD-FRANK HAS MADE IT far more difficult and costly for Wall Street to make loans to companies with below-investment-grade credit ratings, to engage in proprietary trading, and to help clients buy and sell big blocks of stocks and bonds. One result is that small and midsize businesses, in particular, have found it harder to get access to the capital they need to grow, invest in plant and equipment, hire workers, and pay higher wages. GDP growth is highly correlated to bank lending, and in theory, at least, encouraging it ought to help the economy break out of its postrecession rut. (See “Deregulation Could Lift Big Bank Profits 30%.”)
According to a Harvard Business School study, smaller businesses have been feeling the pain. “Small-business owners are generally quite adamant that even if they are just as creditworthy as they were in the period prior to the crisis, banks remain either wary or entirely unwilling to lend to them, no matter how many banks they approach,” according to the study’s authors, Karen Gordon Mills and Brayden McCarthy. “Lack of access to credit for small businesses is problematic because if credit is unavailable, small businesses may be unable to meet current business demands or to take advantage of opportunities for growth, potentially choking off any incipient economic recovery.”
The law has also made it increasingly difficult to buy and sell bonds by forcing banks to take a capital charge for holding large inventories of them on their balance sheets. As a result, bid-ask spreads in the bond market have been widening, forcing buyers to pay more while sellers receive less. Wall Street’s inventory of corporate bonds is down more than 90% since 2007. “A liquidity drought can exacerbate, or even trigger, the next financial crisis,” wrote Stephen A. Schwarzman, co-founder and CEO of the Blackstone Group, in a Wall Street Journal opinion column. “Sellers will offer securities, but there will be no buyers. Prices will drop sharply, causing large losses for investors, pension funds, and financial institutions.”

Regulation overseer: Randal Quarles was nominated by President Trump to the Federal Reserve Board of Governors. Chris Goodney/Bloomberg

Since President Barack Obama signed Dodd-Frank into law, nearly everything Wall Street does, or tries to do, is subject to oversight. Regulators can scrutinize any loan they like and attend meetings of bank boards of directors. The cost of complying with Dodd-Frank and its related rules and regulations runs into the billions of dollars annually, and it has cost the banking industry more than $36 billion since 2010, according to American Action Forum, a conservative think tank. Smaller local banks, in particular, have been begging for relief from the costs of compliance. “Dodd-Frank has disproportionately burdened community banks, despite their having no role in the financial crisis,” Schwarzman wrote in the same piece.
NOT EVERYTHING RELATED to Dodd-Frank has been a mistake, however. Big banks are required to have more capital and less leverage. Under pressure from the Fed, for example, banks have boosted their so-called Tier 1, or highest-quality, capital from about 7% pre-crisis to about 12% today. What used to be an assets-to-shareholder-equity ratio of as high as 50 to 1 is now closer to 15 to 1, meaning that a bank’s assets would have to fall in value by about 7% before a bank’s capital would be wiped out, as opposed to falling 2%, as in 2008. This makes them, and the system, safer.
Indeed, Steve Eisman, a portfolio manager at Neuberger Berman, says that for the first time since 1992, when he started his career analyzing the banking industry, he isn’t worried about the “safety and soundness” of the U.S. financial system. He has an eye for spotting banking crises—his prescience about the 2008 collapse earned him millions and a starring role in The Big Short, Michael Lewis’ best seller about the crash.
Still, the pendulum is swinging. On June 8, the House passed the Financial Choice Act, designed to gut much of the post-financial-crisis legislation. Presumably referring to the stagnant economy, Rep. Jeb Hensarling, a Texas Republican and chairman of the House Financial Services Committee, said, “Every promise of Dodd-Frank has been broken.” His bill passed along party lines. Four days later, Mnuchin’s Treasury issued a 149-page report calling for many of the repeals found in the House bill, including a reduction in bank capital requirements and an easing of Volcker rule restrictions.
Such moves have infuriated Trump’s most vocal critics, including Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D., Mass.), who said in a recent interview, “The Goldman appointments are the tangible demonstration of Donald Trump turning his back on virtually every campaign promise he made.…Donald Trump said over and over that he wanted Glass-Steagall, and that he would break up the banks. And now his Treasury secretary says, ‘No, we’re not gonna do that.’ ”
Even if getting the House bill through the Senate won’t be possible without support from Democratic senators, there is much that the Trump administration can do on its own to loosen banking regulations and make it easier for Wall Street to get back to the business of providing capital to people who want it and are willing to pay a fair price for it. For starters, the administration could have the Securities and Exchange Commission roll back certain Dodd-Frank rules and pull regulators out of Wall Street firms.
SOME WALL STREET EXECUTIVES, including Blackstone’s Schwarzman, applaud what Trump is trying to do. “It was natural you were going to see an increase in regulation after the financial crisis,” Schwarzman, chairman of Trump’s Strategic and Policy Forum, which advises the president, wrote Barron’s in an email. “But I’m not sure anyone really took full account of the unintended, negative consequences that these layers and layers of new rules have had. When you look at the totality of the impact—such as a reduction in liquidity and the number of market makers, which could cause the system to freeze up during a crisis—a number of these regulations have actually made things less safe.”
While some on Wall Street would like Trump to take a sledgehammer to Dodd-Frank, others expect the changes to be incremental. Eisman expects Quarles to make changes on the margins. Regulating the banking industry is “an iterative process,” he says. “There are no tablets from Sinai on how to do that. You have to do it by trial and error. The industry probably does have excess capital. You can do with a little bit more leverage and a little bit more bond liquidity. That’s basically what’s going to happen.”
In all of the talk of Wall Street reform, there has been almost no discussion of changing the industry’s compensation structure, which has been good at rewarding bad behavior and swing-for-the-fences bets with other people’s money, but poor at rewarding prudent risk-taking and accountability. There’s no mention of Wall Street’s problematic incentive system in the Hensarling bill, nor in the Mnuchin report. Few regulators have raised it as a concern, let alone a problem desperately in need of a fix. Addressing the compensation system has become something of a third rail on Wall Street: Everyone knows it’s a problem, but no one dares go near it.
Indeed, on Thursday the SEC and several banking regulators backed off from such a push, which had been mandated by Dodd-Frank, in the interest of moving forward with other deregulation priorities.
And yet it is indisputable that Wall Street’s compensation structure is broken, and has been since 1970, when Donaldson, Lufkin & Jenrette raised capital in the public markets. One Wall Street partnership after another tapped the public equity markets, substituting other people’s money for the partners’ money. In turn, what had been a partnership culture that rewarded prudent risk-taking on Wall Street has been replaced with a bonus culture, rewarding big revenue generators with multimillion-dollar bonuses. Lots of things were lost along the road from private partnerships to pubic companies, but foremost among them was any sense of accountability for individual bankers, traders, and executives for the consequences of their inevitable bad behavior.
In the years leading up to the 2008 financial crisis, bankers, traders, and executives were rewarded with big bonuses for manufacturing questionable mortgage-backed securities. By the time they blew up, necessitating a government bailout of the banking system, the bonus checks had been cut, dispensed, and cashed. Not a single bonus was clawed back or repaid.


In my 2009 book, House of Cards, about the collapse of Bear Stearns, a conversation I had with Jimmy Cayne, the longtime CEO of the firm, proves the point. When I asked him what it was like to lose a billion dollars of his net worth—after Bear’s stock collapsed—he didn’t respond the way I thought he would. “The only people [who] are going to suffer are my heirs, not me,” he said. “Because when you have a billion six and you lose a billion, you’re not exactly like crippled, right?” Maybe he would have thought differently about the risks Bear Stearns was accumulating if his full net worth was on the line, as it was before the firm went public in 1985.
Nearly a decade after the second-worst financial crisis in U.S. history, bankers, traders, and executives are still rewarded for taking big risks with other people’s money. In exchange for the comprehensive changes sought by Wall Street executives, Trump should insist that the top 500 or so executives at every big bank—the ones who decide how to deploy capital, which business lines to be in, and who gets promoted and paid—have a significant portion of their net worth on the line every day, as was de rigueur in the days when Wall Street firms were partnerships and imprudent decisions could put an entire firm at risk almost overnight.
There are many ways that lawyers could construct this obligation—giving creditors and shareholders a “contingent value right” tied to their collective net worth, for instance—but regardless of the particulars, the important thing is for Wall Street’s leaders to have skin in the game, just as they once did, to act as a brake on dangerous practices and ensure accountability when things go wrong.
IT WON’T BE EASY to get Wall Street to go along. Why should the industry voluntarily change an incentive system that pays employees millions of dollars a year to take big risks with other people’s money? But that’s just the point. It’s time for Wall Street to do something that will benefit the whole system, and changing the rewards on Wall Street will do just that.
Trump must make this grand bargain. Not only would it be wildly popular across the political spectrum, but also it would be the right thing to do. “Incentives—compensation and promotion, in particular—are powerful tools for communicating the conduct and culture you desire for your firm,” said the New York Fed’s Dudley in his London speech. “A commitment to the long term must be at the core of banking. Incentives within a firm should support that goal, not undermine it.”

>>> Belstaff receives offer from Diesel owner OTB

Belstaff receives offer from Diesel owner OTB - report
23 JUL 2017
OTB Group, the luxury retail company which owns the Diesel, Viktor & Rolf and Marni brands, has bid for the UK-based fashion retailer Belstaff, The Sunday Times reported. City sources cited in the report said the offer from Italy-based OTB was made during the past few weeks.
The Reimann family of Germany put Belstaff on the market in April, the report said. The family paid almost GBP 100m (USD 130m) to acquire the business six years ago but one analyst suggested a sale now could be worth just GBP 3m (USD 3.9m), the item reported.
Belstaff made a GBP 4.8m loss on GBP 7.8m sales in the 12 months to the end of 2015, the report noted.
The original item appeared in The Sunday Times, Business & Money section

>>> Jimmy Choo receives bids from Inter Parfums, Hony Capital and CVC

Jimmy Choo receives bids from Inter Parfums, Hony Capital and CVC - report
23 JUL 2017
Jimmy Choo [LON:CHOO], the UK-based luxury shoe brand, has received takeover bids from the French cosmetics groupInter Parfums [EPA:ITP] and the private equity firms Hony Capital and CVC Capital Partners, The Sunday Times reported.
The unsourced information was briefly mentioned at the end of an unrelated report.
The original item appeared in The Sunday Times, Business & Money section, page 1

>>> Telecom Italia eyed by couple of private equity firms

Telecom Italia eyed by couple of private equity firms – reported rumour
23 JUL 2017
Telecom Italia [TLIT:MI], the listed Italian telecommunication company, is rumoured to have been eyed by a couple of private equity firms, reported Il Sole 24 Ore quoting sources. Those funds are considering Telecom Italia, which is trading at 0.8 EUR per share, a good deal.
The report also said that these funds might team up with a strategic player. This weekend, the Italian press focused its attention on the departure of Flavio Cattaneo, the chief executive, who will leave his post on Friday 28 July.
The report also said that alongside the private equity firm there might be a strategic buyer. The report quoted rumours according to which Vincent Bollore, head of Vivendi [VIV:PA], and main shareholder in TI, met with Cesar Alierta, chairman of Spanish telecommunication company Telefonica.
The report said that Bollore has offered its stake in Telecom Italia at a price of EUR 1.5 per share. Vivendi has its share on a book value of EUR 1.1 per share, the report said. Deutsche Telekom and Orange have also been mentioned as potential interested parties for TI, the report said.

>>> ACS looking for partners to contribute EUR 6bn to counter offer for Abertis

ACS looking for partners to contribute EUR 6bn to counter offer for Abertis - report (translated)
23 JUL 2017
Actividades de Construccion y Servicios [BME:ACS] (ACS) will only present a counter offer for Abertis [BME:ABE] if it finds partners that can contribute at least EUR 6bn to the total EUR 17bn the company would need for the transaction, El Mundoreported, citing sources from the construction company.
Even though the company confirmed on 21 July that it is studying the possibility to bid for Abertis, ACS is still far from presenting a specific proposal, according to the sources consulted by the Spanish-language paper.
ACS Corporate Director General Angel Garcia Lozano, who is leading the transaction, considers the company should not contribute with more than EUR 11bn, a figure that would ensure the company being Abertis main stakeholder. His intention is to find investment funds which could contribute with the remaining EUR 6bn to carry out the transaction, El Mundoexplained.
In fact, it could finally not be necessary to reimburse the complete amount, since the company led by Florentino Perez expects La Caixa to keep being Abertis shareholder (it currently holds a 22% stake), the item pointed.
ACS has paid off a great part of its debt in the last years and wants to study this transaction thoroughly. Therefore the company will probably postpone a final decision to the end of the summer, according to the paper.
Markets already expressed concerns about the effects the transaction could have on ACS and the price of its shares dropped over a 6% after the stock market regulator CNMV requested the company to confirm it was considering to counter offer for Abertis, El Mundo added.
As to other possible bidders, last week airports operator Aena [BME:AENA] made public it had been studying the possibility to present a counter-offer for Abertis, but its main shareholder Enaire finally ruled out this possibility.
In relation to Atlantia's intention to present an offer for Abertis, Spain's Minister of Economy Luis de Guindos declared on 21 July that the government's strategic interest in Abertis does not necessarily mean that the buyer must be a Spanish company.
Link to original source.

(BFW) Asda Is Said to Look at GBP4.4b Takeover of B&M: Sunday Times

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/business/asda-eyes-4-4bn-bid-for-b-m-qqp7f0lpf (subscription required) Asda is exploring a £4.4bn takeover of B&M, the fast-growing discount retailer run by billionaire brothers Simon and Bobby Arora.
Britain’s third-biggest supermarket chain is understood to be in the early stages of assessing a bid for B&M, which is chaired by the former Tesco boss Sir Terry Leahy. It would be the latest in a series of surprising swoops by the leading grocers, which are trying to diversify away from food and fill space in their out-of-town stores as the German discounters Aldi and Lidl eat into their market share.

Sainsbury’s bought the catalogue retailer Argos for £1.4bn last year and is in talks to acquire the convenience store chain Nisa for £130m. Tesco faces a lengthy competition inquiry to complete its £3.7bn acquisition…
Want to read more

FT : Orange no longer banking on telecoms for growth

Orange no longer banking on telecoms for growth
Chief executive plans online bank this year as French telco revenues are stunted

In a sign that the French telecoms scene is stagnating in terms of growth and consolidation opportunities, Stéphane Richard, chief executive of its biggest operator, is banking on another industry to boost earnings: financial services.

Later this year, Orange will roll out an online bank that seeks to take advantage of new legislation making it easier for consumers to change their provider. Mr Richard says the new venture “is based on a belief that in our core business — which is providing connectivity services both in fixed and mobile — it would be very difficult in coming years to find growth, because we are in a business which is highly regulated and highly competitive.”

Orange increased revenues by just 0.6 per cent last year, after they fell 0.1 per cent in 2015 and dropped 2.5 per cent in 2014. 

The financial services launch has been postponed from July in order to prolong the testing phase. The idea is that it will be a full-service bank, offering consumers everything from payment services to insurance and savings. But analysts are sceptical that it can have much of an influence on the bottom line.

”I think it’s quite a good sideline, but I don’t think it will ever be that big for them,” says Simon Weedon, an analyst at Citigroup. “Banking probably doesn’t have the inherent stickiness for the core product that cross-product sales within telecoms do.”

The move into banking comes as Orange continues to face fierce competition from telecoms rivals in its domestic market, where repeated attempts at pushing through consolidation have failed. Mr Richard, a long-time advocate of fewer players in the French telecoms sector, now believes that any deals are off the table in the short term. 

He says: “The authorities are against it, President Macron is not a big fan of consolidation,” and, predominantly, “each of the players that could enter into a consolidation game today have a different agenda.”


Performance at Bouygues, which Orange was going to buy for €10bn in cash and shares in April last year, has picked up — taking pressure off it to sell. Mr Richard says: “The only deal that might be imagined in France . . . will be between Bouygues and Altice, and this seems to be very unlikely to happen.”

As consolidation has floundered, competition among telecoms providers has turned to a new battleground: content. They are investing in it as a way of differentiating themselves in their push to add and retain clients, and increase average revenue per user.

Altice, the second largest operator, has been spending a fortune, including snapping up rights for the Uefa Champions League and Europa League for the 2018 to 2021 seasons. For its part, Orange has been more cautious. It announced this month it had strengthened its commercial ties with Vivendi’s pay-TV unit CanalPlus — stopping short of buying the stake in CanalPlus that had been previously mooted.

Mr Richard says: “I am still sceptical about the value that a telco can really create from massive investments in content, especially when it is about buying sports rights at extravagant prices. Because what we see today is a bubble and is an incredible inflation of prices in sports rights.”

He adds: “The money that you put on content, you cannot put it on networks. Either you invest massively in fibre to the home, or you invest massively in the content. We have made a clear choice to focus our investments into the networks.”

Last month, analysts at Berenberg downgraded Orange to sell from hold, noting that “competition on the French telecoms market is fierce and consolidation hopes have faded”. The note said that rivals Bouygues and Iliad have “higher growth prospects” while “Orange faces structural issues in its B2C, B2B and wholesale businesses in France that only consolidation and a complete reconfiguration of the cost base could ultimately address.”

Another challenge has been Orange’s stake in BT, whose share price is at its lowest level since 2013, following an accounting scandal in Italy and a subsequent profit warning in January, combined with falling demand in the public sector.

Orange announced last month it would be cutting its exposure to BT, where it owns a stake following the sale in 2014 of EE, the mobile operator that was co-owned by the French group. 

“We are disappointed about the share price and upset about the troubles and the operational troubles at BT, especially in Italy, but also in the B2B business globally,” says Mr Richard. 

“But at the same time, I think BT is a solid company, has great assets and should recover.”

Orange and Mr Richard face uncertainty regarding the role of the French state in the company. President Macron indicated during his election campaign he may look to sell down government stakes in companies, while Mr Richard’s position as effectively one of France’s most senior public servants comes up for potential renewal next year.

He has had seven years as CEO, but says around 10 are needed to “implement real change and transformation”. And he views any state divestment as more likely in the medium rather than short term.

“For a state to be, at the same time, the regulator, the industrial organiser and a shareholder of one of the players, it’s always difficult,” he says.

FT : Investors look to European earnings to reignite equities rally

Investors look to European earnings to reignite equities rally
Analysts predict first full year of earnings expansion for 6 years

Investors are looking to a slew of quarterly earnings from more than 100 European companies this week to help reignite a rally in the region’s equity markets that has stalled over the past couple of months.

Total, Peugeot and Airbus are among the leading companies that will report over the next five days, as a quarterly earnings season that analysts predict will be the best second quarter of the past six years gets into gear.

Confidence in the trajectory for European equities was bolstered after the region’s companies delivered 25 per cent profit growth in the first quarter. Money managers’ appetite for the region’s equities was further amplified after Emmanuel Macron’s French presidential victory eased fears about the spread of populism across the continent.

However, while the Stoxx Europe 600 is up almost a quarter since its low in the aftermath of Brexit, the rally has flagged since early May as renewed strength in the euro has sapped momentum.

The benchmark for European equities has fallen 4 per cent since touching its high for the year on May 10, while the S&P 500 has advanced almost 3 per cent over the same period.


If second-quarter European earnings do deliver the double-digit profit growth that analysts forecast, it will keep the region’s companies on course for the first full year of earnings expansion for six years, according to Jonathan Stubbs, a strategist at Citigroup. The consensus among analysts is for an 11 per cent year-on-year increase in earnings for Stoxx 600 companies, according to JPMorgan.

“Europe has been the relative laggard in equity terms but it is very much in catch-up mode, with positive earnings growth and earnings estimate upgrades,” Mr Stubbs said.


With US stocks setting new records last week, there are already some signs of a rotation into European equities in the hope the market finds fresh impetus. Flows into European stocks last week reached more than $3bn, their highest level since Mr Macron’s presidential victory, according to data provider EPFR.

Mislav Matejka, a strategist at JPMorgan Chase, said earnings growth in the eurozone was set to surpass that of the US both this year and next, while the region’s price/earnings ratio was “fair value” relative to other world regions.

FT : Franco-German fighter jet plans threaten to leave UK grounded

Franco-German fighter jet plans threaten to leave UK grounded
Brexit raises questions over Britain’s role in European defence projects

When German chancellor Angela Merkel and French president Emmanuel Macron unveiled plans for closer defence co-operation between their two countries this month, including the development of Europe’s next generation fighter jet, there was a stark omission: the UK. 

Even though Britain is co-operating with France on a €2bn demonstrator for a future generation combat drone, it will not — for now, at least — have any say in early plans for Europe’s newest fighter project. The programme will be “under the direction” of France and Germany. 

Britain has long been a key partner on European defence projects, from the Panavia Tornado in the 1970s to the more recent Eurofighter Typhoon fast jet and the A400M military transport aircraft. The need to collaborate and share the costs of big procurement projects has intensified as modern equipment becomes more complex and expensive.

Now, however, its decision to quit the EU — as well as the UK’s increasing propensity to buy kit from the US — has raised questions over its role in future European defence projects.

“The UK is sending massively mixed messages about the importance that it puts on Europe as a whole, but especially in defence,” says Francis Tusa, editor of Defence Analysis, citing the UK’s absence from some recent joint exercises in Europe. “This is leading to more and more countries in Europe saying, ‘well, if you’re not interested, we’ll look to work with those that are’.”

Executives from BAE Systems, which with France’s Dassault Aviation is the lead industrial partner on the drone technology demonstrator — referred to in defence circles as an “FCAS” — are nonchalant about the development. 

“We don’t feel threatened by it,” Chris Boardman, BAE’s head of military air, told reporters gathered the following day at the Royal International Air Tatoo at RAF Fairford, the industry’s summer festival of warplane aerobatics. “I would like to see how . . . the concept that France and Germany are talking about matures. One way or other the UK will have an involvement.” 

But the question is to what degree, say observers. Will the UK be involved at the all-important planning stages of the project, which shape capabilities, and dictate, in turn, where the expertise and work will be located? 

There are also concerns over whether any duplication between the two projects could put the Franco-British collaboration at risk, in particular as both are likely to involve Dassault, which refused to comment. 

The FCAS project, combining capabilities on Britain’s Taranis demonstrator and France’s Neuron, is seen by many in the defence sector as critical to sustaining the UK’s competence in high-end aerospace skills and technology. Production of the Eurofighter Typhoon could end unless it wins big orders, while all but one of the air platforms highlighted in the UK’s 2015 defence review are designed and built abroad.

BAE has 15 per cent by value of the UK’s newest fighter — the F-35 — but that is a Lockheed Martin-led programme where the most sophisticated technology has been developed in the US. Without a new indigenous air combat programme, key UK expertise could evaporate, some industry executives warn. 

Drawing firm conclusions from the vague declaration last week is difficult. There was no detail on whether the plan was for manned or unmanned aircraft, and no funding was committed. 

The British government is sceptical that the Franco-German declaration will amount to much in practice. It views the proposals as expensive, with officials noting that the only commitment is to develop “provisional road maps”.

European defence industry executives and military officials describe it as a “political statement of ambition” rather than a concrete decision to press ahead on a joint programme. 

It was motivated as much by a desire to see Franco-German defence collaboration move forward in the wake of Brexit, as by the respective needs of Germany to start thinking about a replacement for its ageing fleet of Tornados and of France, in the longer term, for its Rafale fighters. 

“We were asked to input but we didn’t know what was going to happen,” one European executive said of the announcement. It was a surprise even to Airbus, which has been studying next generation aerial combat systems for the German military, when “this actually popped up”, he added. 

This has lent weight to those who argue the declaration was an opportunistic attempt to press the UK to commit itself more fully to European defence collaboration post-Brexit. 

French officials argue there is no reason for the UK to feel excluded. The FCAS programme was the result of a bilateral treaty signed in 2010, covering a very specific unmanned capability while the German project is about European collaboration, said one. Non-EU members have often participated in European defence procurement programmes, the official said, and France’s desire to continue collaborating with Britain remained strong. 

Yet, at a time when almost every western nation is struggling to fund the multibillion-dollar investment required for the most advanced military procurement programmes, the signals being sent by Paris and Berlin were clear, say industry sources. 

One continental European industry executive said: “It is about Europe saying, ‘all these follow on programmes, we will do them ourselves.’ No one will say no to the UK [if it wants to join in], but this is clearly going to be Franco-German led.”

FT : Carillion and NCC have fallen into textbook traps of expansion

Carillion and NCC have fallen into textbook traps of expansion
Both will be case studies of how missteps can turn big companies into small ones

Companies such as Carillion and NCC should abandon their high-flown references to tomorrow in their mission statements. 

Carillion promises to “make tomorrow a better place” but the Wolverhampton-based construction group is struggling to make it through today. Cyber security specialist NCC talks of “securing tomorrow, today” but last week laid bare the chasm at its foundations. 

The two businesses are in very different markets. Carillion manages hospitals and ministry of defence military bases, and has just won a contract to help build the High Speed 2 rail link to Birmingham. NCC advises companies, many of them FTSE 100 and Fortune 500 groups, on defence against the dark arts of malware and ransomware.

The group, formerly known as the government’s National Computer Centre, calculates that 90 per cent of businesses will experience cyber security threats. It is big in a market that couldn’t be more cutting edge. The construction industry is just cut-throat.

But both NCC and Carillion have fallen into textbook traps of expansion by acquisition, over-optimism at the top and accounting practices that have allowed them to borrow from tomorrow by booking revenues early. Both will end up as case studies of how management missteps can turn big companies into small ones. 

This month Carillion, which uses thousands of sub-contractors, has written off nearly £850m in assets, scrapped its dividend, and waved goodbye to its chief executive. Its shares have fallen two-thirds, valuing the group at about £300m, or approximately half its net debt. A year or so ago, the group was worth more than £1.2bn.

Carillion, the builder of Tate Modern gallery, has been caught in a vice of mis-priced contracts, late payments and rising costs compounded by heavy borrowings against an asset-light balance sheet. Onlookers now fret that debt could rise to £900m in a year and wonder how they missed the signs. There are questions whether Carillion booked revenues on long-term contracts too soon and over its use of supply-chain finance to put off paying creditors. The group has called in bankers and accountants to review options. The market is braced for fire sales, rights issues and possibly a debt-for-equity swap.

Meanwhile, NCC’s new chairman Chris Stone, whisked in this spring to sort out the Manchester group after profit warnings and the abrupt departure of the previous top brass, last week announced nearly £70m in exceptionals and writedowns, and £55m in pre-tax losses in the year to May.

Shares in NCC have nearly halved in a year valuing it at £500m. In early 2016, it was a FTSE 250 company worth more than £1bn. 

Mr Stone also listed a litany of accounting goofs that would make a trainee bean counter blush.

In their rush to turn the small Manchester company into a big one, NCC’s former bosses paid too much for acquisitions that they failed to integrate. They took on too many new staff before knowing there was enough work to keep them busy, and moved into swanky offices. They alienated key customers, including the Dutch government, and lost contracts they assumed were in the bag. The company also booked revenues early, didn’t account for holiday pay properly and bungled the paper work so that dividends were paid unnecessarily out of non-distributable reserves.

Mr Stone and Brian Tenner, interim chief executive, have now corrected the “schoolboy errors” and plan to straighten out NCC’s “spaghetti-like” organisation. They talk of imposing new disciplines on employees, encouraging them to bill their hours properly and cross-sell services more efficiently.

NCC’s biggest fault, Mr Stone concludes, was in failing to put structures in place that could cope with the group’s expansion. “The exciting stuff is winning new clients and making acquisitions,” he says. “But you have to invest in all the dull stuff that makes everything work.

“Where we are different is that change has not been forced upon us by mounting losses, a stretched balance sheet, technological obsolescence or a sudden shrinking in our markets.”

NCC is generating cash and its net debt at £44m — slightly more than 1.5 times earnings before exceptionals and other nasties — is manageable. It needs to double profit margins to justify shares trading at a whopping 25 times forecast earnings. But the dividend should be safe. 

That is not true of Carillion whose pension deficit and net debt are together about four times the group’s equity. Carillion’s tomorrow looks altogether less assured.