Bitcoin Isn’t a Currency, It’s a Commodity—Price It That Way - Link : http://on.wsj.com/2lSojSfIf bitcoin has more in common with gold than dollars, it could have a long way to fallIs a bitcoin worth the $15,000 it commands today, or is it really worth about $3,000? The huge runup in value since September suggests the lower figure.Cryptocurrency fans typically fall into two groups. One sees the currencies as ways to buy and sell things; the other views them as investments. For now, the investment crowd is winning out: Bitcoin remains a cumbersome way to purchase most goods, but its value has skyrocketed, nearly quadrupling since mid-September.If bitcoin is an investment, it most closely resembles gold. Both are stores of value that provide some built-in protection against inflation because there is a finite supply and because extracting new deposits gets more expensive over time, barring big technology changes.If bitcoin really is digital gold, however, investors should analyze it like a commodity—looking at supply constraints and the factors driving demand. That exercise produces worrying results.The most important factor in gold prices over the long run is production costs, which act something like a natural price floor when demand dips. Of course, gold prices can also temporarily move much higher when demand is strong but tend to fall back toward the marginal cost of production once worries about inflation or the dollar subside and gold begins to lose its appeal as a hedge.The last great bull market in gold is a classic example: Prices peaked around $1,900 a troy ounce in 2011— more than three times the production cost, at the time for Barrick Gold Corp., the largest listed gold producer. By the end of 2016, gold prices had plummeted to $1,151 a troy ounce, above Barrick’s production cost of $844, according to FactSet.Applying the same analysis to bitcoin suggests its price could face a steep fall if demand dries up. The cost of minting a bitcoin is as low as $3,224 in Louisiana, according to an analysis by the Crescent Electric Supply Co., one of the largest electrical suppliers in the U.S. The Pelican State had the lowest average residential power costs in the U.S. as of October, according to the Energy Information Administration. Electricity is the biggest cost for bitcoin miners once they fork out for their equipment.On the demand side, some investors appear to be using bitcoin as a hedge against currency weakness in a manner similar to gold. Deutsche Bank reckons that Japanese retail investors were the main force behind the monstrous bitcoin rally last fall—also a period of weakness for the yen, which shed about 6% of its value between early September and mid-November. Around 40% of bitcoin trading is yen-denominated according to Japanese bank Nomura.If the yen were to rise sharply next year, or even if investors began concluding bitcoin was overpriced as a hedge relative to gold, bitcoin might have a long way to fall.Write to Nathaniel Taplin at nathaniel.taplin@wsj.comCorrections & AmplificationsBarrick Gold’s production cost was $844 a troy ounce in 2016, according to FactSet. An earlier version of this article incorrectly stated that amount was the production cost in 2011 and incorrectly stated that the cost in 2016 was $1,118 a troy ounce. (Jan. 4)
After Hours Summary: ZUMZ +15.4%, RAD -6.6%, TSLA -2% following earnings/guidance/sales updates... INTC -1.1% continued weakness despite hosting call to discuss reports of new security research findingsAfter Hours Gainers:
Companies trading higher in after hours in reaction to earnings/guidance/SSS: ZUMZ +15.4% (reports December comps of +7.9 vs -3.4% year ago and +7.8% last month and increases guidance), RECN +3.6%
Companies trading higher in after hours in reaction to news: SKLN +25.1% (Skyline Medical reports sale of 5 STREAMWAY Systems in Q4; 6 units have been booked for sale in January 2018), TOPS +18.4% (extended the time charter agreements with Stena Bulk AB; total gross revenue backlog for the fixed charter period of all operating fleet stands at about $131 million), APHB +17.9% (Ampliphi Biosciences announces topline results for the first seven patients treated under its ongoing single-patient expanded access program; 'six patients, 86%, achieving treatment success' ), AMPE +6.7% (still checking), MNTA +6% (Momenta Pharma and Mylan announced the development strategy for M710, a proposed biosimilar to EYLEA injection; cos plan to initiate a pivotal clinical trial in patients in 1H18), DCIX +5% (Trend Discovery discloses increased passive stake), SAND +4.2% (reported record gold equivalent production in 2017 and the sale of US$18 million of securities of Equinox Gold ), AMD +2.4% (seeing modest bounce in after hours trade after company claims 'near-zero risk' to its chips), OSTK +2% (CEO Byrne and Hernando de Soto enter MOU to form blockchain company focused on property rights), MNK +1.4% (added to Select List at Stifel), SSW +1.3% (announces letter of intent for potential $250 mln Unsecured 5.50% Debenture and Warrant Investment from Fairfax Financial Holdings Limited), BB +1.2% (continued strength following exec commentary in Bloomberg interview), SRPT +1% (initiated with Buy/$75 tgt at Janney ), QURE +0.7% (initiated with Buy/$25 tgt at Janney)
After Hours Losers:
Companies trading lower in after hours in reaction to earnings/guidance/SSS: RAD -6.6%, TSLA -2% (reports Q4 deliveries), LNDC -1.6% (light volume)
Companies trading lower in after hours in reaction to news: OVAS -4.8% (reports initial safety data from Phase 1 Study of OvaPrime, is reducing headcount by ~50% and appoints James Lillie as Chief Scientific Officer), REXX -3.5% / RENN -1.4% (modestly pulling back), ARE -3.2% (is commencing public offering of 6,000,000 shares of common stock in connection with the forward sale agreements), INSM -3% (announces additional data from ALIS), ZYNE -1.2% (light volume; provides 2018 clinical/corporate update focusing strategy on rare and near-rare neurological and psychiatric disorders; Liza Squires, M.D. joins as Chief Medical Officer), INTC -1.1% (following call to discuss reports of new security research findings)
![]()