Budget uncertainty keeps Italy out of European rally
Bond yields rise and stocks fall as investors measure political uncertainty
Uncertainty in the run-up to Italy’s budget in October is leaving the country’s assets looking exposed.
As the populist coalition government prepares its first finance bill, there is once again an uneasy tone to trade, keeping the FTSE MIB out of a broader rally on global markets, while its sovereign debt is also being sold off, sending yields higher.
The pattern comes as the ruling parties continue their budget negotiations. The League and Five Star parties are united in power but have opposing policy aims, adding to the uncertainty.
The yield on the country’s benchmark 10-year sovereign debt is at its highest level since May up 3.6 basis points at 3.202 per cent. Apart from one session on May 29, it last regularly traded above 3.2 per cent in late 2014.
There is also a debt auction scheduled for Thursday, with €7.5bn in bonds expected to be sold.
“There continues to be high uncertainty about the size and composition of Italy’s draft budget for 2019. The promises made in the coalition agreement of the new government are estimated to add up to between 4½% and 7% of GDP (including a flat tax, citizenship income and pension reform). If implemented, this would most likely derail Italy’s debt dynamics.
“Based on the October draft budget, the EC will prepare an opinion by 30 November, scrutinising the assumptions and evaluating the budget proposal against EU fiscal rules.”
FELIX HUEFNER, SENIOR EUROPEAN ECONOMIST, UBS
On Tuesday Reuters carried reports that the deputy prime minister, Luigi Di Maio, told an Italian newspaper that he did not rule out breaching the European Union’s rules limiting public deficits to 3 per cent of gross domestic product.
Milan’s FTSE MIB is down 0.8 per cent and is being led lower by banks, underperforming a rise of 0.3 per cent for the Europe-wide Stoxx 600.
The country’s banks are major holders of Italian government debt, which also faces losing a major buyer when the European Central Bank reduces its bond-buying stimulus spending on schedule in September.
UBI Banca is down 2.1 per cent and UniCredit is down 2.5 per cent.
The euro remained aloof from Italy’s politics — up 0.1 per cent at $1.1692 — but analysts remained concerned that any turbulence with the bloc’s third-biggest economy could yet become an important driver for the shared currency:
“The main downside risk to the outlook for the euro against the dollar in the near-term continues to be posed by Italian political developments.
“There is clearly the potential for conflict with the EU and an unfavourable Italian debt market reaction. So far, the euro has proven relatively resilient to the pricing in of a higher Italian political risk premium, but that may not last.”
LEE HARDMAN, CURRENCY ANALYST, MUFG


