FT : Rokos and Goldman Sachs hit in bond market upheaval

Rokos and Goldman Sachs hit in bond market upheaval
Goldman loses around $200mn, while hedge funds Rokos and Leda Braga’s Systematica drop after collapse of Silicon Valley Bank

Billionaire trader Chris Rokos and Goldman Sachs are among big-name investors that have been hit hard in the market upheaval following the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank.

Bond prices rocketed in highly volatile trading at the start of this week, when SVB’s demise sparked a flight to safety and led investors to question how much further the US Federal Reserve can lift interest rates. That caught many traders off guard, and collided directly with hedge fund strategies that had profited handsomely in 2022 from betting on further aggressive monetary tightening.

The pain has affected a clutch of the best-known speculative investors in the market.

London-based Rokos, which manages around $15.5bn, is down around 12.5 per cent this month, said people who had seen the numbers.

At Goldman, a trading desk that handles interest-rate products lost around $200mn, according to people familiar with the matter. Goldman declined to comment.

BlueCrest Capital, bond trader Mike Platt’s investment firm, which made 153 per cent last year thanks in part to bets on rising interest rates, has also lost money, say people familiar with the firm. It is down around 7 per cent this year.

And Andrew Law’s Caxton Macro fund lost around 3 per cent this month.

“What’s hurt a lot of people in macro [bets on global bonds and currency moves] is that everyone was positioned for rates rising,” said one insider in the hedge fund industry. But on Monday, the market moved violently the other way. With prices soaring, the yield on the two-year Treasury note fell at its fastest pace since 1987. Some funds raced to unwind their positions, further fuelling the bond rally.

The “erratic prices action” led to “many investors triggering stop losses on short positions”, said Mark Dowding, chief investment officer at RBC BlueBay.

Macro hedge funds lost 2.15 per cent on average on Monday alone, according to data group HFR, the biggest daily loss since the market turbulence of late 2018. A regular social gathering of hedge fund managers and other investors in London on Thursday night had a “sombre”, wake-like tone, people familiar with the matter said, in contrast to a victorious atmosphere after spectacular returns in 2022.

Rokos hit the headlines in late 2021 when he was wrongfooted by a big sell-off in short-term government debt, as investors panicked that interest rates would have to rise faster than central banks had initially indicated. His fund finished the year down around 26.6 per cent, its worst year since launch in 2015.

He subsequently reduced substantially the market risk he was taking in the fund to try to avoid a repeat of the losses. Last year he made more than 50 per cent, his fund’s best year.

Many computer-driven funds, which latch on to market trends and which had long been betting that the large rally Treasury yields would continue, also lost money.

The Schroder Gaia Bluetrend fund, run by Leda Braga’s Systematica, fell by 10 per cent this month to the end of trading on Monday, according to numbers sent to investors, taking losses this year to about 11.5 per cent.

Among other computer-driven funds losing money, Man Group, one of the world’s biggest hedge fund firms, lost 10.6 per cent in its $5.4bn Evolution fund this month and 7.1 per cent in its $5.9bn Dimension fund.

And Rotterdam-based Transtrend, which manages $5.6bn, lost 9.6 per cent on Monday.

Just over half its losses came from bond bets, although losses were within its risk tolerances, said a spokesman, and the fund has stuck with its short positions in US bonds.

Such quant funds are down on average by around 6 per cent this month, according to a Société Générale index of these portfolios.

However, a few hedge funds have been able to profit during the market turmoil, particularly those betting against bank stocks.

Barry Norris, chief investment officer at Argonaut Capital, profited by shorting SVB and has also been betting against Credit Suisse for several weeks, helping his fund to gain 4.5 per cent this month.

The Swiss bank’s shares, which are now down by more than one-third this year, fell sharply after the chair of Saudi National Bank ruled out further investment. On Friday the shares fell further, despite the pledge of liquidity support from the Swiss National Bank.

Short interest in Credit Suisse was running at just 3.2 per cent of its shares outstanding at the start of the week, according to S&P Global Market Intelligence. But short positions have shot up to 8.2 per cent as of Thursday, as concerns have grown about the lender.

“The problem with Credit Suisse is that it was already suffering from deposit flight,” said Norris. “If you can’t stop the deposit flight then the only way out is to be taken over by a bigger bank.”

>>> US Close Dow -1.19% S&P -1.10% Nasdaq -0.74% Russell -2.56%

Closing Stock Market Summary

On this quadruple witching options expiration day, investors had a risk-off mentality due to ongoing pressure in the banking sector. Yesterday's pleasing finish was largely a relief rally following news that First Republic Bank (FRC 23.03, -11.24, -32.8%) had received cash infusions from 11 big banks totaling $30 billion. The relief from that news was short lived and investors sold FRC again today after it provided a cash position update and suspended its dividend.

Market participants were also reacting to reports that banks borrowed $11.9 billion from the Bank Term Funding Program and a record $153 billion from the Fed's discount window for the week ending March 15, exceeding anything during the financial crisis.

That understanding renewed investors' worries about the health of the banking industry, leading to fairly indiscriminate selling in bank stocks. The SPDR S&P Bank ETF (KBE) fell 5.6% and the SPDR S&P Regional Bank ETF (KRE) fell 6.0%. Even banks that are viewed as potentially benefiting from the fallout at smaller banks, like JPMorgan (JPM 125.81, -4.94, -3.8%), suffered decent losses today. 

There was some underlying strength today, specifically in the mega cap space, as investors flocked to names that are viewed as being distant from the banking sector fallout, having strong balance sheets and being more resilient in an economic slowdown. Microsoft (MSFT 279.43, +3.23, +1.2%), Alphabet (GOOG 102.46, +1.39, +1.4%), and NVIDIA (NVDA 257.25, +1.84, +0.7%) were notable beneficiaries in that regard. NVDA was upgraded to Overweight from Equal Weight at Morgan Stanley today. 

Selling efforts were otherwise broad in nature. While the Vanguard Mega Cap Growth ETF (MGK) slipped just 0.3%, the Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (RSP) fell 1.7% and the market-cap weighted S&P 500 fell 1.1%. 

The S&P 500 sliced through its 200-day moving average (3,937) in the morning trade, sliding to 3,901 at its worst levels of the session before seeing a small bounce on a day that featured extremely heavy volume at the NYSE and Nasdaq. 

All 11 S&P 500 sectors logged a loss today with information technology (-0.1%) and communication services (-0.5%) sitting atop the leaderboard. Meanwhile, the financial sector (-3.3%) suffered the steepest decline, along with real estate (-2.3%) and industrials (-1.6%). 

  • Nasdaq Composite: +11.1% YTD
  • S&P 500: +2.0% YTD
  • S&P Midcap 400: -2.3% YTD
  • Russell 2000: -2.0% YTD
  • Dow Jones Industrial Average: -3.9% YTD

Reviewing today's economic data:

  • Total industrial production was unchanged month-over-month in February ( consensus +0.5%) following an upwardly revised revised 0.3% increase (from 0.0%) in January. The capacity utilization rate held steady at 78.0% ( consensus 78.5%) following a downward revision to 78.0% (from 78.3%) for January.
    • The key takeaway from the report is that industrial production activity is softening, evidenced both by the year-over-year decline in total production and a capacity utilization rate that is near its lowest level since September 2021.
  • Leading Indicators fell 0.3% in February (consensus -0.4%) following a 0.3% decline in January.
  • The preliminary University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index for March dropped to 63.4 ( consensus 67.2) from 67.0 in February. In the same period a year ago, the index stood at 59.4. Note: Roughly 85% of responses had been recorded prior to the failure of Silicon Valley Bank.
    • The key takeaway from the report is the moderation in inflation expectations, which will please the Fed somewhat, although year-ahead inflation expectations still remain well above the 2.3-3.0% range seen in the two years prior to the pandemic.

Looking ahead to Monday, there is no U.S. economic data of note.

FT : UBS in talks to acquire Credit Suisse

UBS in talks to acquire Credit Suisse
Swiss authorities press for merger to stem crisis of confidence in country’s banking sector

UBS is in discussions to take over all or part of Credit Suisse, with the boards of Switzerland’s two biggest lenders set to meet separately over the weekend to consider Europe’s most consequential banking combination since the financial crisis, according to multiple people briefed on the talks.

The Swiss National Bank and regulator Finma are orchestrating the talks in an attempt to shore up confidence in the country’s banking sector, the people said. Their intervention comes days after the central bank was forced to provide an emergency SFr50bn ($54bn) credit line to Credit Suisse.

However, this failed to arrest a slide in its share price, which has fallen to record lows after its largest investor ruled out providing any more capital and its chair admitted that an exodus of wealth management clients had continued.

UBS has a market value of $56.6bn, while shares in Credit Suisse closed on Friday with a value of $8bn.

Swiss regulators told their US and UK counterparts on Friday evening that merging the two banks was their “plan A” to arrest a collapse in confidence in Credit Suisse, a person familiar with those discussions told the FT.

A number of different options are under discussion between the two banks, another person told the FT, who added that both sides are trying to evaluate regulatory constraints in different jurisdictions. This person added that UBS is also analysing the potential risks a deal could have for its own business.

The focus from the central bank is to agree on a simple and straightforward solution before markets open on Monday, one of the people said. There is no guarantee a deal will be reached.

Credit Suisse declined to comment. UBS declined to comment, as did the Bank of England and the Federal Reserve. The Swiss National Bank did not respond to requests for comment.

This is a developing story. More to follow . . . 

>>> Stoxx 600 Pre-Market Indications

  • Nel (D7G TH) +4.6%
    • Nel Raised to Buy at Goldman; PT 20.60 kroner
  • Deutsche Bank (DBK TH) +2.3%
    • Watch European Lenders After Big Banks Support First Republic
  • Rio Tinto (RIO1 TH) +2%
    • Citi Sees Iron Ore Rally as Unsustainable on Demand Doubts
  • Erste (EBO TH) +1.9%
  • Norsk Hydro (NOH1 TH) +1.9%
    • Watch Copper, Aluminum Mining Stocks as Metal Prices Rebound
  • Vonovia (VNA TH) +1.8%
    • Vonovia FY FFO per Share Beats Estimates
  • ING (INN1 TH) +1.7%
  • SocGen (SGE TH) +1.7%
    • SocGen Raised, KBC Cut as HSBC Rejigs Bank Ratings Post-Selloff
  • Aegon (AEND TH) +1.7%
  • Shell (R6C0 TH) +1.7%
  • Orsted (D2G TH) -0.4%
  • Evotec SE (EVT TH) -0.4%
  • Voestalpine (VAS TH) -0.5%

>>> TradeGate Pre-Market Indications

DAX:
  • Deutsche Bank (DBK TH) +2.4%
    • Watch European Lenders After Big Banks Support First Republic
  • Vonovia (VNA TH) +1.7%
    • Vonovia FY FFO per Share Beats Estimates
  • Commerzbank (CBK TH) +1.5%
    • Watch European Lenders After Big Banks Support First Republic
  • Deutsche Post (DPW TH) +1.4%
    • Watch Delivery and Logistics Stocks as FedEx Tops Expectations
  • Symrise (SY1 TH) +1.3%
    • Symrise Raised to Buy at Goldman; PT 117 euros
MDAX:
  • Aroundtown (AT1 TH) +2.3%
  • HelloFresh (HFG TH) +1.5%
  • K+S (SDF TH) +1.5%
  • Kion (KGX TH) +1.2%
  • ProSieben (PSM TH) +1.1%
  • Rheinmetall (RHM TH) +0.8%
  • Lanxess (LXS TH) +0.7%
  • TAG Immobilien (TEG TH) +0.6%
SDAX:
  • Hensoldt (HAG TH) +1.5%
  • Eckert & Ziegler (EUZ TH) +1.3%
  • Deutz (DEZ TH) +1.3%
    • DWS Investment GmbH Cut Deutz Voting Rights to 4.75% on March 13
  • Deutsche PBB (PBB TH) +0.7%
  • Schaeffler (SHA TH) +0.7%
  • flatexDEGIRO (FTK TH) +0.6%
    • flatexDEGIRO Investor Cut Voting Rights to 4.50% on March 10

>>> What to look at today - 17th of March 2023

Asian equities advanced Friday after a rescue package for First Republic Bank fueled a rebound in US shares. Bond yields in the region moved higher as investors continue to weigh chances of further interest rate hikes. Indexes rose in Hong Kong, Japan and South Korea amid a rebound in banking shares. Baidu Inc. added to the positive sentiment after brokerages tested its just-unveiled ChatGPT-like service and granted it their preliminary approval. Technology stocks surged and were among the best performers on Friday. Even so, an Asia equity gauge was set for a second weekly loss after the recent turbulence in the banking sector. Contracts for the Euro Stoxx 50 index gained while S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100 futures were little changed. The S&P 500 notched its largest one-day advance since January on Thursday after the biggest US lenders agreed to contribute $30 billion in deposits to First Republic, easing speculation that the bank could be the next to fail after two high-profile demises touched off the crisis last week.  Bond yields climbed about 19 basis points for Australia’s policy-sensitive three-year maturity and were also higher in New Zealand on Friday. The two-year Treasury yield rose about four basis points Friday following a 27 basis point jump to above 4% in the previous session. Traders who on Wednesday had largely abandoned bets for a ninth Fed rate hike next week upgraded the odds of a quarter-point move back to around 80%.  The dollar weakened against all of its Group-of-10 counterparts, with the Australian and New Zealand currencies leading gains. Markets were also digesting a 50 basis points rate hike by the European Central Bank and comments from the ECB president that inflation is projected to remain too high for too long. The ECB rate hike added to bets the US central bank will also raise next week. Friday’s quarterly triple witching, where contracts for index futures, equity index options and stock options all expire, could amp up swings in trading. The First Republic news came after a lifeline from Swiss regulators earlier this week stabilized Credit Suisse Group AG, easing worries that troubles at the European lender would lead to a cascading crisis in that region. The idea of a forced combination with a larger rival, UBS Group AG, was shot down on Thursday and receipts in Credit Suisse ended the session unchanged. The cost to insure the Swiss bank’s debt has been rising. In China, some brokers resumed bond-pricing feeds on certain bond information platforms Friday morning, after an abrupt suspension earlier this week disrupted trading in the $21 trillion market. Bitcoin rose to near the highest level since June amid a broad rally in cryptocurrencies. Other tokens such as Ether, Solana and Polkadot surged as well. oil advanced but was still headed for the worst week so far this year after the recent turmoil in the financial sector. Gold rose. US After Hours FDX +11.8% jumps following earnings; SRPT -19.8% falls as FDA requires meeting; FRC -16.5% lower after cash update and dividend suspension; WAL -6.7% and PACW -5.9% lower in sympathy.

Nikkei +0,77% Hang Seng +1,79% CSI +1,57% Shanghai +1,58% Shenzen +1,22%

Eur$ 1,0645 CNH 6,8648 CNY 6,8665 JPY 133,19 GBP 1,2146 CHF 0,9270 RUB 76,4614 TRY 19,0079 WTI$ 69,11 Gold 1,928 BTC 25,800 +4% ETH 1,708

S&P +0,07% Nasdaq +0,24% EuroStoxx +0,73% FTSE +0,60% Dax +0,39% SMI +0,58%

Macro :
- *US 'AA+' RATING AFFIRMED BY S&P GLOBAL RATINGS, OUTLOOK STABLE
- Brevan Howard Grounds a Few Traders After Losses in Bond Rout
- University of California to Dump Hedge Funds for Private Credit
- Tiger Global venture capital funds said to lose 33% of value in 2022
- Ackman Concerned About ‘Contagion Risk’ Spiraling Out of Control

Keep an eye on :
- A2A IM : Italy’s A2A Makes Non-Binding Bid for Majority of Utility Egea
- MT NA : US Steel Jumps After 1Q EPS Forecast Beats Estimate
- AF FP : Air France to Boost Services to Pre-Pandemic Levels This Summer
- ALO FP : Alstom in ~€250M Seven-Year Contract With Newark Airport
- BOY LN : Bodycote FY Headline Profit Pretax Beats Estimates
- BRSAN TI : Borusan Mannesmann in Talks to Buy Europipe US Unit
- CO FP : Casino Raises R$4.1B With Assai Share Sale at R$16 Apiece
- CSGN SW : Swiss Government Was Informed by Finma, SNB on Credit Suisse
- CTT PL : CTT FY Net Income EU36.4M Vs. EU38.4M Y/y
- DPLM LN : Diploma Buys Tennessee Industrial Electronics; Launches Placing
- EDF FP : EDF Maintains Nuclear Output Target Amid Expanded Reactor Checks
- ENI IM : Eni Says Share Buyback May Be Increased Up To Maximum of EU3.5b
- ENEL IM : Enel FY Adjusted Net Beats Estimates
- ENEL IM : Enel CEO Confirms Dividend, Says May Improve if Conditions Allow
- RACE IM : Ferrari Debuts New Spider Model of Its Iconic Roma Supercar
- FDX US : FedEx Jumps After Boosting Forecast as Cost Cuts Take Hold
- INRN SW : Interroll FY Ebitda Beats Estimates
- INTRUM SS : Intrum Reported to Police by Danish Agency for 2016 Activity: JP
- IPN FP : Ipsen Gets New FDA PDUFA Date for Investigational Palovarotene
- LIAB SS : Lindab Appoints Lars Ynner as Chief Financial Officer
- MANU US : Qatari Royal to Make Second Man United Bid Within 10 Days: Sky
- MOVE SW : Medacta Sees 2023 Revenue EU480M to EU495M, Est. EU484.8M
- MED SW : Medartis Offering of 476,190 Shares Prices at CHF63/Share
- MBG GY : Mercedes Overtakes Tesla on Self-Driving, Catches Up on Software
- TYRES FH : Nokian Tyres Has Received Payment for Sale of Russian Operations
- NOVN SW : Novartis Gets FDA Nod for Tafinlar With Mekinist for Children
- RNO FP : Nissan Technicians Reject Union in Setback for Auto Organizing
- REP SM : Repsol Ditches Canadian LNG Export Terminal Expansion Plan Due
- CFR SW : Richemont to List A Shares, Terminate Depository Receipt Program
- RUI FP : Rubis FY Ebitda Beats Estimates
- SAN FP : Sanofi Follows Lilly, Novo in Cutting Insulin Prices
- SZG GY : Borusan Mannesmann in Talks to Buy Europipe US Unit
- SIFG NA : SIF FY Revenue Misses Estimates
- SKAB SS : Skanska Signs NOK410m Contract for Building in Norway
- STLA IM : Stellantis Announces Launch Of First Tranche Of €1.5B Share Buyback Program
- TEL NO : CK Hutchison in Deal Talks With Telenor in Denmark, Sweden: FT
- UBSG SW : UBS, Credit Suisse Are Said to Oppose Idea of Forced Combination
- UCG IM : UniCredit Urges Holders to Back CEO Pay Plan After Proxy Dissent
- VNA GY : Vonovia FY FFO per Share Beats Estimates
- WBD IM : Webuild Accelerates on Asset Reorganization, Ferrari Says
- MF FP : Wendel FY Net Income Misses Estimates,
- MF FP : *WENDEL TO CREATE THIRD-PARTY ASSET MANAGEMENT BUSINESS

>>> Europe : Brokers Upgrades & Downgrades - 17th of March 2023

>>> Up
* Chubb Raised to Overweight at JPMorgan; PT $239
* Genuit Group Raised to Buy at Peel Hunt; PT 320 pence
* GSK Raised to Buy at Deutsche Bank; PT 1,700 pence
* Nel Raised to Buy at Goldman; PT 20.60 kroner
* Nexus Raised to Buy at Pareto Securities; PT 61 euros
* Nobia Raised to Buy at DNB Markets; PT 27 kronor
* Nvidia Raised to Overweight at Morgan Stanley
* SocGen Raised to Buy at HSBC; PT 33 euros
* Symrise Raised to Buy at Goldman; PT 117 euros
* Vale ADRs Raised to Outperform at Itau BBA; PT $18

>>> Down
* iomart Cut to Add at Peel Hunt; PT 145 pence
* KBC Cut to Hold at HSBC; PT 68 euros

>>> Initiation
* Alliance Pharma Rated New Hold at Peel Hunt; PT 65 pence
* Inventiva SACA ADRs Rated New Buy at Stifel; PT $27
* Oxford Nanopore Rated New Reduce at Peel Hunt; PT 170 pence
* Wartsila Resumed Buy at Nordea; PT 10.60 euros

>>> Call
* SocGen Raised, KBC Cut as HSBC Rejigs Bank Ratings Post-Selloff

FT : Exiled son of Iran’s last shah steps up to lead galvanised diaspora

Exiled son of Iran’s last shah steps up to lead galvanised diaspora
Former crown prince Reza Pahlavi emerges as a figurehead for those who believe regime change is within sight

Reza Pahlavi was for decades on the distant margins of Iranian politics, an exiled crown prince with a spattering of monarchist supporters inside and outside the country.

But Pahlavi, the US-based son of Iran’s last shah who was toppled in the 1979 revolution, has in recent months become a figurehead for an increasingly ambitious opposition in the diaspora that believes the time is ripe to foment regime change in the Islamic republic.

The result is that, 44 years after his father was unseated, Pahlavi has been touring European capitals as part of a campaign to convince the west to ramp up support for Iranian protesters who want the theocracy replaced by a secular democracy.

Supplementing the sanctions already imposed on the republic with actions to “empower” Iranians who oppose the regime would go a long way to “making them more capable of bringing pressure from within”, Pahlavi said in an interview with the Financial Times.

Such comments reflect confidence among the regime’s opponents abroad that the mass protests last year that followed the death of 22-year-old Mahsa Amini have altered the dynamics in Iran. It also underlined how they hoped to shape western policy.


Pahlavi, 62, attended last month’s Munich Security Conference, while Iranian officials were not invited. He followed up by meeting lawmakers in London, Paris and Brussels.

Pahlavi, who has not returned to Iran since 1978 when he left, aged 17, to study in the US, said that chances for “high-level” meetings existed before, but the difference now was that people were engaging. “After 43 years the world is beginning to say we’d better start talking to people who are part of the solution and the alternative.”

The protests have diminished, but with Iran under mounting social and economic pressures, the republic’s opponents predict further cycles of unrest. Buoyed by internal calls for regime change, Pahlavi and others in the diaspora are drawing up a charter to prepare for a “transition” should the theocracy collapse.

After decades of deep divisions within a diaspora that mostly displayed little appetite for political activity, Pahlavi and other opposition figures abroad have found their voices amplified to unprecedented levels on the international stage.

It is in part due to the nature and scope of the protests, which presented the regime with its severest threat in years. This coincided with escalating tensions between Iran and the west that were partly due to Tehran’s crackdown against the demonstrators, as well as its decision to sell drones to Russia used in its war against Ukraine.

Pahlavi is the eldest son of the late Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, who sought to modernise Iran over four decades as shah with the backing of the US. But many Iranians felt alienated by his western-style development, corruption and autocratic rule, culminating in the tumultuous events that overthrew his dynasty.

Today, many Iranians remain sceptical about the overseas opposition and Pahlavi, arguing they lack credible leaders and are removed from ordinary people and the republic’s pro-democracy activists. There are questions about their level of support inside the country. Some say the diaspora’s activities play into the hands of a regime keen to blame the unrest on its foreign enemies.

“The [overseas] opposition is more relevant than before because of the impact they’re having on domestic politics in the countries they reside, but their agenda is not always the same as internal activists,” said Ali Vaez, analyst at Crisis Group, a think-tank. “Their own intolerance and infighting has contributed to concerns.”

Analysts say the new elevated role of Pahlavi and others in the diaspora also exposed a weakness in the opposition — the lack of clear leadership inside or outside Iran. “There are so many people with capacity and potential, but it’s hard to identify one single person that will galvanise and rally support, particularly inside Iran,” said Sanam Vakil, an Iran expert at Chatham House.

Pahlavi insisted he was in contact with activists inside Iran and was reflecting their views. His aim was to convince the west to do more to help Iranians circumvent internet restrictions and to raise funds to support striking workers, believing labour unrest would “paralyse the system”.

“We’re trying to do all of this in the context of non-violent and civil disobedience change without having to resort to violence or foreign intervention,” he said. Opposition figures called for general strikes during the protests, a tactic that helped loosen the shah’s grip on power in 1979, but they went largely unheeded.

In Iran, analysts and diplomats say that among the activist diaspora, which includes actors, journalists and footballers, Pahlavi has a degree of stature as the last shah’s son. Yet his heritage is also seen as a weakness, as many remember the autocratic nature of his father’s regime.

“Nobody is contesting what happened in history,” Pahlavi said. “I had no responsibility in the previous regime, I had the title of crown prince but nobody holds me accountable for that.”
Pahlavi, whose supporters still refer to him as “his majesty”, is ambiguous on whether he wants to see a return to monarchy. He said he would recuse “myself from this debate so I don’t favour one or the other”.

His task was to build a “coalition of political organisations [and] groups” and prepare for what happens should the regime fall. Asked if he viewed himself as a transitional leader, he replied: “That’s what people want me to play as a role; monarchists or republicans.”

He added: “My mission in life will end the day people go to the polls and elect their future system.”