TechCrunch : Chinese AI company MiniMax releases new models it claims are compet

Chinese AI company MiniMax releases new models it claims are competitive with the industry’s best

Chinese firms continue to release AI models that rival the capabilities of systems developed by OpenAI and other U.S.-based AI companies.

This week, MiniMax, an Alibaba- and Tencent-backed startup that has raised around $850 million in venture capital and is valued at more than $2.5 billion, debuted three new models: MiniMax-Text-01, MiniMax-VL-01, and T2A-01-HD. MiniMax-Text-01 is a text-only model, while MiniMax-VL-01 can understand both images and text. T2A-01-HD, meanwhile, generates audio — specifically speech.

MiniMax claims that MiniMax-Text-01, which is 456 billion parameters in size, performs better than models such as Google’s recently unveiled Gemini 2.0 Flash on benchmarks like MMLU and SimpleQA, which measure the ability of a model to answer math problems and fact-based questions. Parameters roughly correspond to a model’s problem-solving skills, and models with more parameters generally perform better than those with fewer parameters.

As for MiniMax-VL-01, MiniMax says that it rivals Anthropic’s Claude 3.5 Sonnet on evaluations that require multimodal understanding, like ChartQA, which tasks models with answering graph- and diagram-related queries (e.g., “What is the peak value of the orange line in this graph?”). Granted, MiniMax-VL-01 doesn’t quite best Gemini 2.0 Flash on many of these tests. OpenAI’s GPT-4o and an open model called InternVL2.5 beat it on several as well.

Of note, MiniMax-Text-01 has an extremely large context window. A model’s context, or context window, refers to input (e.g., text) that a model considers before generating output (additional text). With a context window of 4 million tokens, MiniMax-Text-01 can analyze around 3 million words in one go — or just over five copies of “War and Peace.”

For context (no pun intended), MiniMax-Text-01’s context window is roughly 31 times the size of GPT-4o’s and Llama 3.1’s.

The last of MiniMax’s models released this week, T2A-01-HD, is an audio generator optimized for speech. T2A-01-HD can generate a synthetic voice with adjustable cadence, tone, and tenor in around 17 different languages, including English and Chinese, and clone a voice from just 10 seconds of an audio recording.

MiniMax didn’t publish benchmark results comparing T2A-01-HD to other audio-generating models. But to this reporter’s ear, T2A-01-HD’s outputs sound on par with audio models from Meta and startups like PlayAI.

With the exception of T2A-01-HD, which is exclusively available through MiniMax’s API and Hailuo AI platform, MiniMax’s new models can be downloaded from GitHub and the AI dev platform Hugging Face.

Just because the models are “openly” available doesn’t mean they aren’t locked down in certain aspects, however. MiniMax-Text-01 and MiniMax-VL-01 aren’t truly open source in the sense that MiniMax hasn’t released the components (e.g., training data) needed to re-create them from scratch. Moreover, they’re under MiniMax’s restrictive license, which prohibits developers from using the models to improve rival AI models and requires that platforms with more than 100 million monthly active users request a special license from MiniMax.

MiniMax was founded in 2021 by former employees of SenseTime, one of China’s largest AI firms. The company’s projects include apps like Talkie, an AI-powered role-playing platform along the lines of Character AI, and text-to-video models that MiniMax has released in Hailuo.

Some of MiniMax’s products have become the subject of minor controversy.

Talkie, which was pulled from Apple’s App Store in December for unspecified “technical” reasons, features AI avatars of public figures, including Donald Trump, Taylor Swift, Elon Musk, and LeBron James, none of whom appear to have consented to being featured in the app.

In December, Broadcast magazine reported that MiniMax’s video generators can reproduce the logos of British television channels, suggesting that MiniMax’s models were trained on content from those channels. And MiniMax is reportedly being sued by iQiyi, a Chinese video streaming service that alleges MiniMax illicitly trained on iQiyi’s copyrighted recordings.

MiniMax’s new models arrive days after the outgoing Biden administration proposed harsher export rules and restrictions on AI technologies for Chinese ventures. Companies in China were already prevented from buying advanced AI chips, but if the new rules go into effect as written, companies will be faced with stricter caps on both the semiconductor tech and models needed to bootstrap sophisticated AI systems.

On Wednesday, the Biden administration announced additional measures focused on keeping sophisticated chips out of China. Chip foundries and packaging companies that want to export certain chips will be subjected to broader license requirements unless they exercise greater scrutiny and due diligence to prevent their products from reaching Chinese clients.

>>> US Early premarket gappers

Early premarket gappers
  • Gapping up:
    • DOYU +22.2%, SEZL +18.3%, BBAI +16.2%, AZUL +10.6%, TALO +9.4%, TSM +4.9%, IBRX +4.6%, CDRE +4.3%, DUOL +4.1%, ORLA +3.8%, DD +2.4%, RKLB +2.4%, PAAS +2.3%, ARMN +2.1%, BKH +1.8%, TTE +1.8%, RIO +1.3%, INCY +1.3%, EVH +1.2%, MTB +1.2%, SQ +1.1%
  • Gapping down:
    • FUL -4.3%, UNH -3.6%, PSO -3.5%, CNXC -3.2%, HOMB -3.1%, PRTH -2.5%, SNAP -2.4%, CLLS -1.8%, NEXA -1.8%, META -1.4%, SLDB -1.3%

>>> Europe : Brokers Upgrades & Downgrades - 16th of January 2025 V2(+)

>>> Up
* Adesso SE Raised to Buy at Hauck & Aufhaeuser; PT 103 euros (+)
* BAE Raised to Neutral at BNPP Exane; PT 1,286 pence
* Balder Raised to Buy at SEB Equities; PT 83 kronor
* Balder Raised to Buy at Nordea; PT 85 kronor
* DNB Bank Raised to Buy at Arctic Securities; PT 260 kroner (+)
* Draegerwerk PT Raised to 86 euros at Hauck & Aufhaeuser (+)
* EasyJet Cut to Neutral at Davy; PT 580 pence (+)
* Ferrovial Raised to Overweight at JPMorgan; PT 49 euros
* First Solar Raised to Buy at Seaport Global Securities; PT $274
* Goldman Sachs PT Raised to $660 from $560 at Argus
* Indutrade Raised to Buy at ABG; PT 325 kronor
* Iren Raised to Buy at Kepler Cheuvreux
* JD Sports Cut to Neutral at UBS (+)
* JPMorgan PT Raised to $275 from $235 at Argus
* Just Eat Takeaway Raised to Buy at Bryan Garnier; PT 17 euros (+)
* Leonardo Raised to Overweight at Morgan Stanley; PT 35 euros
* LVMH Raised to Buy at BofA (+)
* Lindt & Spruengli Raised to Buy at CIC; PT 120,000 Swiss francs (+)
* Orange Polska Raised to Buy at Erste Group; PT 9 zloty
* Orsted Raised to Neutral at Grupo Santander; PT 360 kroner
* Randstad Raised to Buy at BofA
* Rapala VMC Raised to Accumulate at Inderes; PT 2.20 euros
* Rolls-Royce PT Raised to 700 pence at Morgan Stanley
* Sagax Raised to Buy at SEB Equities; PT 270 kronor
* TAG Immobilien Raised to Neutral at BNPP Exane (+)
* Thales Raised to Outperform at BNPP Exane; PT 176 euros
* Witted Megacorp Raised to Buy at Inderes; PT 2 euros
* Zalando Raised to Buy at UBS (+)

>>> Down
* AB Foods Cut to Sell at Citi; PT 1,770 pence
* About You Cut to Neutral at UBS (+)
* Adecco PT Cut to 19.50 Swiss francs at BofA
* BlueNord Cut to Hold at DNB Markets; PT 680 kroner
* European Smaller Companies/The Cut to Hold at Stifel (+)
* First Quantum Minerals Cut to Hold at Canaccord; PT C$20
* ISS Cut to Underperform at BofA
* Klepierre Cut to Neutral at BNPP Exane (+)
* Nokia Cut to Sell at Goldman; PT 3.50 euros
* Nokia ADRs Cut to Sell at Goldman; PT $3.60
* Prosus Cut to Hold at Kepler Cheuvreux
* Safran Cut to Equal-Weight at Morgan Stanley; PT 243 euros
* Saint-Gobain Cut to Neutral at UBS
* Sodexo Cut to Underperform at BNPP Exane (+)
* TFF Group Cut to Reduce at IDMidcaps; PT 25 euros (+)
* Var Energi Cut to Hold at DNB Markets; PT 39 kroner
* Vonovia Cut to Neutral at BNPP Exane (+)

>>> Initiation
* Altria Rated New Equal-Weight at Morgan Stanley; PT $54
* Bankinter Rated New Outperform at RBC; PT 9.75 euros
* Beazley Reinstated Outperform at Autonomous; PT 1,000 pence
* Brunello Cucinelli Rated New Buy at Banca Akros (+)
* CaixaBank Rated New Sector Perform at RBC; PT 5.65 euros
* Delivery Hero Cut to Neutral at Bryan Garnier; PT 36 euros (+)
* Eurocommercial Rated New Accumulate at KBC Securities (+)
* Ferragamo Rated New Neutral at Banca Akros (ESN); PT 6.50 euros (+)
* Hannover Re Reinstated Neutral at Autonomous; PT 265 euros
* Hiscox Reinstated Neutral at Autonomous; PT 1,115 pence
* Intercos Rated New Buy at Kepler Cheuvreux; PT 17.50 euros
* Lancashire Reinstated Outperform at Autonomous; PT 840 pence
* Moncler Rated New Accumulate at Banca Akros (ESN); PT 55 euros (+)
* Munich Re Reinstated Neutral at Autonomous; PT 520 euros
* Philip Morris Rated New Overweight at Morgan Stanley; PT $140
* Pluxee Rated New Hold at Stifel; PT 25 euros
* Prisma Properties Rated New Hold at Pareto Securities
* Scor Reinstated Neutral at Autonomous; PT 27.50 euros
* Swiss Re Reinstated Outperform at Autonomous

>>> Call
* European Smaller Companies/The Cut to Hold at Stifel (+)
* Euro to Fall Below Parity in 2025 on Tariffs, ECB, UBS Predicts

>>> Stoxx 600 Pre-Market Indications

  • Zalando (ZAL TH) +9.7%
    • Zalando Says 2024 Profitability Beat Guidance on Customer Growth
  • Kering (PPX TH) +3.9%
    • Watch European Luxury after Richemont’s Unexpected Q3 Sales Beat
  • LVMH (MOH TH) +3.3%
  • ASM Intl (AVS TH) +2.8%
    • Watch European Chip Stocks After TSMC Sales Beat Estimates
  • ASML (ASME TH) +2.5%
  • Barclays (BCY TH) +2%
  • Hermes (HMI TH) +1.9%
  • HSBC (HBC1 TH) +1.9%
  • InPost (669 TH) +1.8%
  • Moncler (MOV TH) +1.6%
  • Saint-Gobain (GOB TH) -2.9%
    • Saint-Gobain Cut to Neutral at UBS
  • Nokia (NOA3 TH) -3.2%
    • Nokia Cut to Sell at Goldman; PT 3.50 euros

>>> TradeGate Pre-Market Indications

DAX:
  • Zalando (ZAL TH) +9.5%
    • Zalando Says 2024 Profitability Beat Guidance on Customer Growth
  • Infineon (IFX TH) +1.4%
    • Singapore Chip-Gear Maker GVT Says AI Boom Far From Over
MDAX:
  • AUTO1 (AG1 TH) +1.3%
  • Hugo Boss (BOSS TH) +1.1%
    • Watch European Luxury after Richemont’s Unexpected Q3 Sales Beat
SDAX:
  • Draegerwerk (DRW3 TH) +4.5%
    • Draegerwerk Prelim FY Net Sales About EU3.37B, Est. EU3.4B
  • Borussia Dortmund (BVB TH) +2.6%
  • SUSS MicroTec (SMHN TH) +2%
  • SAF-Holland SE (SFQ TH) -0.6%
    • SAF-Holland SE Prelim FY Sales About EU1.88B, Est. EU1.94B
  • Verbio SE (VBK TH) -19%
    • *VERBIO SE: VERBIO REDUCES EBITDA FORECAST FOR 2024/25

>>> What to look at today - 16th of December 2024

Asian equities tracked Wall Street’s gains as cooling US core inflation kept alive the prospect of Federal Reserve easing this year. The yen climbed on Bank of Japan rate-hike expectations. Gauges in Australia, Hong Kong and South Korea all advanced, sending an index of Asian equities higher for a third day. The S&P 500 rose 1.8% Wednesday, the benchmark’s best day since the November election, which erased its 2025 decline. US stock futures declined. The yen rose on a report that BOJ officials see a good chance of a rate increase next week as long as Donald Trump’s arrival at the White House doesn’t trigger too many negative surprises. Treasuries were little changed while an index of the dollar halted a two-day losing streak. Swap traders are back to fully pricing in a Fed rate reduction by July following the US inflation report, reinstating bets that were dashed when December jobs data came in stronger than expected. But the renewed appetite for risk will be tested in the coming days as the Fed and the Bank of Japan hand down policy decisions and Trump takes office. Japan’s currency rallied as much as 0.8%, before paring gains, as BOJ officials were said to acknowledge there’s a likelihood the rate will be raised from 0.25% at the end of its two-day meeting on Jan. 24. That’s so unless Trump ruffles markets or changes expectations about the global economy at the start of his presidency. The cooling in the dollar’s rally helped put emerging-market currencies on course for a third day of gains, their longest run of increases in over a month. The Thai baht, Taiwanese dollar and the Russian ruble all strengthened. The South Korean won swung to a loss after central bank Governor Rhee Chang-yong said all six members of the board were open to a rate cut in the next three months.  Elsewhere in Asia, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co.’s profit in the December quarter topped estimates with a 57% rise, giving a boost to investors hoping to see the AI hardware spending spree extend into 2025. The company’s shares in Taipei jumped by the most since October. 
In commodities, oil held a powerful, early-year advance on mounting concerns about risks to global supplies, and as commercial crude inventories in the US posted their longest run of declines since 2021. Gold slipped. Later Thursday, the European Central Bank will release its meeting minutes while US data to be released includes initial jobless claims and retail sales, providing investors with a broader picture of the health of the world’s largest economy. The so-called US core consumer price index — which excludes food and energy costs — increased 0.2% in December. That marked the first stepdown in the rate in six months. From a year ago, it rose 3.2%. That’s still above the Fed’s 2% target. A handful of Federal Reserve officials said the data offered confidence that inflation would continue to ebb. “The process of disinflation remains in train. But we are still not at our 2% goal, and it will take more time until we can achieve that on a sustained basis,” New York Fed President John Williams said Wednesday. Maintaining the dollar as the world’s reserve asset is critical to US economic health and the nation’s future, Scott Bessent, Donald Trump’s nominee for Treasury secretary, will tell a Senate committee, according to prepared remarks. US After Hours SEZL +11.7% soars on uplifting guidance; SNAP -2.4% and META -1.3% slipping on reports Trump may suspend enforcement of TikTok ban.

Nikkei +0.33% Hang Seng +1.17% CSI +0.10% Shanghai +0.24% Shenzen +0.38%

Eur$ 1.0286 CNH 7.3494 CNY 7.3316 JPY 156.22 GBP 1.2216 CHF 0.9126 RUB 102.5106 TRY 35.4658 WTI$ 80.23 +0.24% Gold 2,693 -0.12% BTC 99,700 +0.02% ETH 3,374 -1.72%

S&P +0.11% Nasdaq +0.13% EuroStoxx +0.21% FTSE +0.22% Dax -0.01% SMI +0.50%

Macro :
- Dealmakers fear cross-border M&A will be hostage to Trump diplomacy
- Israel and Hamas Reach a Deal to Pause 15-Month-Long War in Gaza
- India achieves 'historic' space docking mission
- Dollar Bulls Overstretched Enough to Signal Peak May Be In
- Advent Said to Name D’Angelo to Lead Health Care Deals in Europe
- Euro to Fall Below Parity in 2025 on Tariffs, ECB, UBS Predicts
- Crypto Exchange Kraken Says Chief Legal Officer Santori Leaves
- EM Assets Inch Higher Ahead of Trump’s White House Return
- Geller’s $10.4 Billion Multifamily Office Is Acquired by Corient
- Short Seller Hindenburg Research to Be Disbanded, Founder Says
- FTC Chair Khan on Deere Suit, Big Tech and M&A (Video)
- Waltz: Trump Will Find a Way to Preserve TikTok, User Data
- Investors Seek $5 Billion for Basketball League to Rival NBA

Keep an eye on :
- AKRBP NO : Aker BP Prelim 4Q Avg Production Beats Estimates
- ALO FP : Alstom in Pact With Metrolinx for GO Transit Cars Overhaul
- APAM NA : Universal Stainless Stockholders Approve Acquisition by Aperam
- ARYN SW : Aryzta Says it Expects to Achieve 2025 Targets One Year Early
- ASML NA : *TSMC SEES 2025 CAPEX $38B TO $42B, EST. $35.15B
- BX US : Blackstone Said to Seek $3 Billion in Dylan, Adele Rights Sale
- ROO LN : Deliveroo 4Q Gross Transaction Value Matches Estimates
- DNO NO : DNO 4Q North Sea Net Output 19,031 Boepd, Kurdistan 17,424 Boepd
- DKNG US : DraftKings, Flutter Slide as Maryland Proposes Tax Hike
- DD US : DuPont to Speed Up Sale of Electronics Unit, Retain Water Unit
- EIX US : Edison International Bonds, Shares Rally After Analyst Upgrade
- LLY US : Eli Lilly Wins US FDA Approval for Omvoh in Crohn’s Disease
- FAST NA : Fastned 4Q Revenue Related to Charging EU26.6M
- FM CN : First Quantum Minerals 2025 Copper Prod Forecast Misses Est.
- FRA GY : Fraport 2024 Frankfurt Airport Passenger Traffic rose 3.7% to 61.6M
- GEBN SW : Geberit FY Sales Matches Estimates
- IDIA SW : Idorsia Sees 2025 Net Revenue About CHF110M, Est. CHF122.3M
- INCY US : Incyte, Syndax’s Niktimvo Gets FDA OK in 9mg, 22mg Vial Sizes
- KER FP : Kering and Ardian in Investment Pact on Paris Real Estate
- KESKOB FH : Kesko Dec. Comparable Sales +3.9%
- LHA GY : Italy’s ITA Airways Names Joerg Eberhart CEO, New Board Slate
- META US : Meta Falls on Report Trump Considering Action to Stop TikTok Ban
- MOWI NO : Mowi Prelim 4Q Ebit About EU226M, Est. EU205.3M
- ORNBV FH : Orion Upgrades FY Outlook for 2024 on Better Than Expected Sales
- PARA US : Paramount Global falls as lawmaker says Skydance deal should get CFIUS scrutiny
- PLUG US : US to Finalize Billions in Funding for Rivian, Plug Before Trump
- RNO FP : Renault Group 2024 Global Vehicle Sales Up 1.3% vs. 2023, Renault Says New Model Launches Helped Bolster 2024 Deliveries, Renault Confident on Outlook for EV, Hybrid Sales This Year
- REP SM : Repsol 4Q Downstream Refining Margin/BBL Beats Estimates
- CFR SW : Richemont 3Q Sales at Constant Exchange Rates Beats Estimates
- RIO LN : Rio Tinto 4Q Pilbara Ore Shipments Misses Estimates
- RIO LN : GOP Eyes Fast-Track Budget Bill for Rio Tinto Mine Approval
- SFQ GY : SAF-Holland SE Prelim FY Sales About EU1.88B, Est. EU1.94B
- 3382 JP : KKR Considers Joining Seven & i Management Buyout After Apollo
- SLXN US : Silexion Therapeutics Shares Jump After Pancreatic-Cancer Treatment Data
- SIVE SS : Sivers Semiconductors Sets SEK105 million Shares ATM Offering
- STLA US : Stellantis 4Q Consolidated Shipments Decline 9% Y/y
- TSLA US : Tesla is offering Cybertruck discounts as EV market gets crowded
- 2330 TT : TSMC Profit Beats Estimates After Year of Rapid AI-Driven Growth
- UMG NA : Universal Music Plans US Share Sale for Pershing Square Stake
- VAIAS FH : great
- VOW GY : Exclusive-Chinese buyers interested in unwanted German Volkswagen factories, source says
- ZAL GY : Zalando Says 2024 Profitability Beat Guidance on Customer Growth

>>> Europe : Brokers Upgrades & Downgrades - 16th of January 2025

>>> Up
* BAE Raised to Neutral at BNPP Exane; PT 1,286 pence
* Balder Raised to Buy at SEB Equities; PT 83 kronor
* Balder Raised to Buy at Nordea; PT 85 kronor
* Ferrovial Raised to Overweight at JPMorgan; PT 49 euros
* First Solar Raised to Buy at Seaport Global Securities; PT $274
* Goldman Sachs PT Raised to $660 from $560 at Argus
* Indutrade Raised to Buy at ABG; PT 325 kronor
* Iren Raised to Buy at Kepler Cheuvreux
* JPMorgan PT Raised to $275 from $235 at Argus
* Leonardo Raised to Overweight at Morgan Stanley; PT 35 euros
* Orange Polska Raised to Buy at Erste Group; PT 9 zloty
* Orsted Raised to Neutral at Grupo Santander; PT 360 kroner
* Randstad Raised to Buy at BofA
* Rapala VMC Raised to Accumulate at Inderes; PT 2.20 euros
* Rolls-Royce PT Raised to 700 pence at Morgan Stanley
* Sagax Raised to Buy at SEB Equities; PT 270 kronor
* Thales Raised to Outperform at BNPP Exane; PT 176 euros
* Witted Megacorp Raised to Buy at Inderes; PT 2 euros

>>> Down
* AB Foods Cut to Sell at Citi; PT 1,770 pence
* Adecco PT Cut to 19.50 Swiss francs at BofA
* BlueNord Cut to Hold at DNB Markets; PT 680 kroner
* First Quantum Minerals Cut to Hold at Canaccord; PT C$20
* ISS Cut to Underperform at BofA
* Nokia Cut to Sell at Goldman; PT 3.50 euros
* Nokia ADRs Cut to Sell at Goldman; PT $3.60
* Prosus Cut to Hold at Kepler Cheuvreux
* Safran Cut to Equal-Weight at Morgan Stanley; PT 243 euros
* Saint-Gobain Cut to Neutral at UBS
* Var Energi Cut to Hold at DNB Markets; PT 39 kroner

>>> Initiation
* Altria Rated New Equal-Weight at Morgan Stanley; PT $54
* Bankinter Rated New Outperform at RBC; PT 9.75 euros
* Beazley Reinstated Outperform at Autonomous; PT 1,000 pence
* CaixaBank Rated New Sector Perform at RBC; PT 5.65 euros
* Hannover Re Reinstated Neutral at Autonomous; PT 265 euros
* Hiscox Reinstated Neutral at Autonomous; PT 1,115 pence
* Intercos Rated New Buy at Kepler Cheuvreux; PT 17.50 euros
* Lancashire Reinstated Outperform at Autonomous; PT 840 pence
* Munich Re Reinstated Neutral at Autonomous; PT 520 euros
* Philip Morris Rated New Overweight at Morgan Stanley; PT $140
* Pluxee Rated New Hold at Stifel; PT 25 euros
* Prisma Properties Rated New Hold at Pareto Securities
* Scor Reinstated Neutral at Autonomous; PT 27.50 euros
* Swiss Re Reinstated Outperform at Autonomous

>>> Call
* Euro to Fall Below Parity in 2025 on Tariffs, ECB, UBS Predicts

FT : Quality control merger fails the investor smell test

Quality control merger fails the investor smell test
A putative tie-up between Switzerland’s SGS and France’s Bureau Veritas sent the combined market capitalisation dipping

In most sectors, big is most definitely better. Corporate behemoths are more profitable, have stronger brands, can more easily attract talent and build capabilities, and tend to take share from minnows. The business of auditing financial accounts, by way of example, is largely concentrated among the Big Four. 

Not so the business of auditing real-world stuff — a roughly €150bn market that involves inspecting beaches for cleanliness, testing products for quality, and certifying processes for compliance. The top 10 companies only hold about a quarter of the market according to Karl Green at RBC Capital. A potential €32bn tie-up between two of its leading players — Switzerland’s SGS and France’s Bureau Veritas — has gone down like an adulterated yoghurt, with the combined market capitalisation dipping on Wednesday. 

That reflects the specifics of this sector, which deals in the rich tapestry of the physical world. Sums, spreadsheets and — to a large extent — accounting standards are universal. Work can be optimised to increase efficiency. But a unit that sends out marine experts with clipboards to inspect ships, for instance, cannot easily take on a job inspecting clothing for residue chemicals.

While there would be room to slim down corporate overheads, that’s unlikely to be transformative. This limits the possibility of SGS — the larger business with a SFr16.4bn (€17.5bn) market capitalisation — paying much of a premium for Bureau Veritas without destroying value. 

Market share gains, too, may prove elusive. The cost of testing, inspection and certification (TIC) is relatively small. That does not give clients much of an incentive to shop around, which makes for sticky relationships with existing suppliers. 


For the inspectors, a merger makes most sense as a defensive move. The TIC market will at some point need to transform to keep up with the world around it. Human testers will, over time, be replaced by sensors and drones. Artificial intelligence can help create product prototypes, which can then be put through their paces on laptops rather than in labs. That will require a cycle of capital investment better shared than borne alone. 

On top of that, the market for TIC services isn’t looking quite as hot as it was. Secular drivers of demand include economic growth, increasing regulation and international trade. That squares poorly with President-elect Donald Trump’s desire to impose tariffs and his dislike of clean energy pledges and red tape.

That a bigger entity could better withstand heavy investments and lumpier demand makes intuitive sense. But if the test is one of appealing to investors, this putative union could struggle to scrape through.