WSJ : Amazon CEO’s Talks With U.S. Officials Triggered Crackdown on Anthropic Mo

Amazon CEO’s Talks With U.S. Officials Triggered Crackdown on Anthropic Models
Information shared with Trump administration sparked move to halt foreign access to company’s powerful AI tools

  • The Trump administration halted foreign use of Anthropic’s most-capable AI models after Amazon.com Chief Executive Andy Jassy raised security concerns.
  • Anthropic shut off access to its Mythos and Fable models to comply, stating the rule effectively prevented its foreign-born researchers from working.
  • The action reignited a long battle between Anthropic and the Trump administration, which distrusts the startup’s ties to liberal causes.

The Trump administration’s decision to halt all foreign use of Anthropic’s most-capable AI models was prompted by conversations between Amazon.com AMZN -1.23%decrease; down pointing triangle Chief Executive Andy Jassy and U.S. officials including Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, people familiar with the matter said.

Researchers at Amazon had used a series of prompts to get Anthropic’s Fable 5 model to provide them with information that could be used to aid cyberattacks and was supposed to be off-limits, Jassy told the officials, according to people familiar with the matter. Tech industry executives have been in regular touch with the administration about the power of cutting-edge AI tools.

Shortly afterward, White House officials held a meeting to discuss how to respond, and security researchers began testing Amazon’s claims. The officials asked Anthropic to fix the vulnerabilities or take down the model, according to administration officials.

The officials decided that the most direct way to address that risk was by preventing foreign governments, companies and individuals from accessing the tool, the people said. President Trump later signed off on the action despite reservations about its hindering innovation, a senior White House official said.

The administration had long felt that Anthropic, one of the leaders in America’s artificial-intelligence race, couldn’t be trusted to manage the security risks its new model presented. Friday’s call between some administration officials and Anthropic Chief Executive Dario Amodei reinforced that idea, the people said. Some of the officials said the company indicated that it was unwilling to work with security experts in the government to address the issue.

In response to the government’s move Friday, Anthropic said it was shutting off access to Mythos and Fable to all users to make sure it complied, potentially hampering efforts by companies around the world to use the tools to identify software vulnerabilities. Many of the researchers at Anthropic are foreign-born, meaning the government’s rule effectively prevented them from working on the latest models, the company said.

The government’s talks with Amazon—a big investor in Anthropic that supplies the AI company with chips for data centers, while deploying its best models to identify software vulnerabilities—are a sign of how America’s largest companies and governments are navigating the emerging technology’s novel capabilities. Friday’s rapid events show how quickly new discoveries and experimentation can affect government restrictions and, potentially, company fortunes.

“As a leading cloud provider that serves a large number of private and public sector customers, it’s not uncommon for governments to seek our counsel on potential security risks,” an Amazon spokesman said. “When they occur, we don’t share the details of these discussions.”

Anthropic has said that the vulnerabilities like those flagged by Amazon are relatively basic. The company has said that other publicly available models are capable of discovering them and that they don’t represent a full so-called jailbreak, a point of view shared by some security researchers familiar with Amazon’s research.

The startup has said it has adequate safeguards in place and is known for giving priority to safety. It previously held off expanding access to Mythos at the direction of the White House and works with a key government AI testing unit before releasing models.

The Information earlier reported that Jassy raised concerns with senior administration officials.

Increased controls
Combined with a recent executive order giving security officials more oversight of models, and discussions about the government’s potentially taking equity stakes in AI companies, the moves show a dramatic increase in the control the administration is willing to exert over the industry, some analysts said.

The senior White House official said the new intervention was about model safety and doesn’t detract from the administration’s innovation focus. White House AI adviser and venture capitalist David Sacks, an Anthropic critic, said on social media that the administration had issued the restriction “reluctantly.”

The administration’s “hope now is that Anthropic remediates the safety issue, the export control is lifted, and Fable goes back into general release,” he wrote.

Shutting down the top models could hold back Anthropic as it prepares for an initial public offering as soon as this fall if users turn to other models. It could also benefit competitors such as OpenAI, which has a powerful cyber model of its own that it is gradually offering to customers and discussing with the Trump administration.

Founded in 2021 by Amodei and other OpenAI alumni who felt the ChatGPT maker wasn’t emphasizing AI safety, Anthropic has become a top model provider to businesses for the strength of its Claude Code tool.

The moves Friday reignited a long battle between Anthropic and the Trump administration, which remains distrustful of the startup’s ties to donors to liberal causes and its warnings about the dangers of AI. Anthropic previously hired several former Biden administration officials, and Amodei has criticized Trump and his administration.

Anthropic and the Trump administration have been sparring over the use of the startup’s AI tools by the military, resulting in an unprecedented designation by the Pentagon that the company is a security risk. Anthropic is fighting the move in two separate lawsuits.

Some analysts have said the White House’s dislike of Anthropic may have influenced the latest model move. The senior White House official said the move was about model safety and the Defense Department wasn’t heavily involved.

Amazon’s report
Friday’s action comes after reports that a user had bypassed the safety guardrails of Anthropic’s Fable 5, adding to worries about its ability to facilitate cyberattacks.

An Amazon report on Fable shared with cyber experts showed that it was able to dig up security bugs in at least four software programs when the tool was prompted with a specific set of queries, according to people who viewed the paper. That is information that Fable would typically not provide, but it is still a long way from dangerous cybersecurity information, according to Andrew Morris, founder of the cybersecurity firm GreyNoise Intelligence.

Many other tools can already reveal this information, but Anthropic’s software is known for being able to convert that bug information into working “exploit” code. Such code could be used to break into networks, but there is no evidence that Amazon’s researchers were able to access that capability, which is protected by Fable’s security guardrails, Morris said.

Jassy’s calls to administration officials were viewed by some as a general warning that quickly escalated into a wide Commerce Department ban on foreign users’ accessing Mythos and Fable, the people said. National Cyber Director Sean Cairncross and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick were involved in the conversations. The Commerce Department is in charge of export controls on critical technology.

Anthropic began previewing Mythos to Amazon and other tech companies earlier this year, working with the Trump administration on a phased approach. The goal was to let critical users apply the model to find software vulnerabilities and address them before more of the public had access.

An April meeting that included Amodei, Bessent and White House chief of staff Susie Wiles was seen as an olive branch and peacemaking opportunity, but it also included a discussion about security.

Adam Thierer, a senior fellow at the R Street Institute think tank focused on technology and innovation, said this past week’s events are “a significant escalation in the politicization of AI and centralization of control over advanced computation in this country.”