More risks than perceived, downgrade to Sell
More emerging market and US industrial exposure than perceived
We think there are some risks potentially pressuring St Gobain in the coming quarters.
While emerging markets account for only 19% of sales, they represent 30% of
operating profits with the main exposures into Latam (Brazil), Asia (India, China) and
Eastern Europe. Around 20% of operating profit comes from the US, but within that
we estimate c40-50% comes from industrial exposures (mainly in HPM) where recent
data points have indicated a slowdown. France remains the key area of upside in due
course, however recent data points (housing starts, permits, Q3 cement volumes) show
little evidence of end market turn-around for now.
Cutting EPS by -5%, 2016E operating profit >10% below consensus
We cut our 2015E EPS by -2% and thereafter by c-5% p.a. 2016E consensus of
c€3.1bn operating profit is too optimistic in our view, and implies c+16% organic
operating profit growth, incorporating a c-2% headwind from FX next year (based on
current spot rates). Considering global growth dynamics we think c+5% organic
operating profit growth is more appropriate, which puts our 2016E operating profit at
slightly below €2.8bn, >10% below consensus and EPS c-20% below consensus.
Consensus estimates imply >15% LFL operating profit growth in 2016E, which we
believe is highly unrealistic.
Q3 sales due 28th October
St Gobain will release Q315 sales aftermarket on 28th October. We expect LFL sales
growth of +1.4% (after Q2 +2.1%) and total sales growth of +3.4% y/y. We see FX
still delivering a tailwind of +2.2%, but lower than H1 (+4.6%). We expect France to
continue to decline albeit at a lower pace than H1, emerging markets to slow after a
robust showing in H1 (+4.8% y/y LFL), North America to grow but held back by the
industrial exposure and the rest of Europe to continue to grow around 2%.
Valuation: Sell, €36 PT (from €41)
Our PT is based on DCF, utilising LT normalised EBIT margins of 8.7%. At our PT the
shares would trade on 15x 2016E P/E including the expected accretion from Sika which
we include from 2017E.