Vix index sends mixed messages to investors
‘Fear gauge’ close to 1993 levels but fund managers fear stocks overvalued
Stock market investors have spent vast amounts of effort this year worrying about why people are not worried enough. With gauges of expected market volatility touching new lows, a parade of bearish commentators has offered up warnings following the same logic: violent corrections occur when investors are complacent about risk; investors have been measurably complacent this year because volatility is low; therefore the likelihood of a violent correction is high.
This week the Vix index, the most popular short-hand measure of expectations for near-term volatility for US stocks, has traded close to the lowest level since Bill Clinton was elected in 1993, prompting a further furrowing of brows from those exasperated at such apparently reckless levels of market relaxation.
Yet is it really the case that investors in aggregate are so dangerously chilled out at a time when the S&P 500 is trading at all-time highs? Real-world evidence of the complacency so many repeatedly reference is not so easy to find. In fact, large institutional investors are by some measures more nervous today than at any time since the dotcom bubble. The most recent BofA Merrill Lynch fund manager survey, which polls investors responsible for almost $600bn of assets, showed that 44 per cent of respondents said equities were today overvalued, which was the highest number since 1999.
These same nervous fund managers had increased the amount of their portfolios sitting in the safety of cash to 5 per cent, above a 10-year average of 4.5 per cent and a reflection of their worry that US equity valuations have become dangerously overheated.
Taken at face value these two indicators are highly contradictory. The entire justification for focusing on every minuscule move in volatility expectations is that the Vix provides a way of assessing market sentiment. Yet if fund managers really are so worried, then the cost of options to protect against a correction, and therefore the Vix, should be higher. Perennial pessimists may soon have to accept something even more worrying than all of this ongoing lack of worry – that their beloved Vix may no longer be a meaningful indicator of anything at all.