Time Is on AT&T’s Side in Wait for Slim’s Assets: Real M&A
2014-12-05 21:44:41.156 GMT
(For a Real M&A column news alert: SALT REALMNA <GO>.)
By Scott Moritz and Patricia Laya
Dec. 5 (Bloomberg) -- AT&T Inc. has no reason to hurry into
any more deals in Mexico. In fact, the more patiently the U.S.
phone company waits, the better.
AT&T has made two acquisitions this year in its expansion
into Mexico -- neither with billionaire Carlos Slim, who
dominates the country’s communications industry. Instead, AT&T
has committed more than $50 billion to buying Mexican wireless
carrier Grupo Iusacell SA and DirecTV, which has a stake in
satellite-TV service Sky Mexico.
That’s left Slim, a former ally of AT&T, in limbo because
he needs to divest a large portion of America Movil SAB’s assets
in Mexico to reduce its market share below 50 percent and avoid
profit-reducing penalties. AT&T may be Slim’s best hope for a
buyer as the Dallas-based company is trying to bundle wireless,
TV and broadband services south of the U.S. border. The catch is
that the Iusacell business AT&T is buying benefits as long as
America Movil faces penalties. Dragging out that punishment also
may make for a tougher -- and maybe cheaper -- sale for Slim.
“AT&T is in no rush to buy America Movil’s assets in the
short term,” Gregorio Tomassi, an analyst at Banco Itau BBA,
said in a phone interview from Mexico City. “America Movil is
seeing the situation is becoming more difficult than they had
initially thought.”
SoftBank Out
America Movil originally contacted potential suitors
including AT&T, SoftBank Corp. and China Mobile Ltd. as it
prepared to sell landline and wireless assets worth about $17.5
billion, people with knowledge of the matter said in September.
Since then, Tokyo-based SoftBank has dropped out of the process,
according to other people familiar with the matter, who asked
not to be named because the decision was private.
Mariko Osada, a spokeswoman for SoftBank, declined to
comment, as did a press official for America Movil, which has a
market value of $77 billion. Fletcher Cook, an AT&T spokesman,
declined to comment on the company’s expansion strategy in
Mexico.
Today, AT&T shares rose less than 1 percent to $33.94.
AT&T’s presence in Mexico since announcing the purchase of
Iusacell on Nov. 7 reduces the appetite of other foreign buyers
to enter the market and improves AT&T’s negotiating power with
America Movil, Tomassi said.
“AT&T has the clearest way to create synergies,” Tomassi
said. “No other operator interested in coming has the level of
synergies, cross-border or inside of Mexico, as AT&T.”
AT&T Expansion
The $176 billion U.S. phone giant had been searching for
new businesses and new regions for expansion amid increased
competition and slowing wireless growth at home. Chief Executive
Officer Randall Stephenson initially set his sights on Europe
but shifted back to the Americas after Comcast Corp. announced
plans to buy Time Warner Cable Inc.
AT&T agreed to pay $48.5 billion for DirecTV, including its
Latin American business, expanding outside the U.S. for the
first time in a decade. It then agreed to buy Iusacell, Mexico’s
third-largest wireless carrier, for an equity value of $1.8
billion.
Mexico helped open the door to competitors earlier this
year when it signed a telecommunications overhaul into law. The
new rules force America Movil, which controls seven out of 10
mobile-phone users in the country, to cut its fees and share
infrastructure with its competitors.
Even without the legislation, Mexico’s proximity, economic
growth potential and increasing population make it a prime
market for AT&T to expand its TV, wireless and Internet service
business.
Balance Sheet
AT&T has the means to buy America Movil’s assets and extend
its reach further in Mexico. Holding off on another deal, for
now at least, might be better for its balance sheet.
Its shopping cart is already filling fast. On top of
DirecTV and Iusacell, AT&T is one of the top bidders in the
Federal Communications Commission’s airwave auction, which has
already surpassed $41 billion. Meantime, its A credit rating has
been in jeopardy since May when Fitch Ratings put it under
review for downgrade after the DirecTV deal was announced.
AT&T had about $2.5 billion in cash and cash equivalents as
of September and has been trimming costs and selling assets this
year. Last month, the phone company said it was cutting its
projected 2015 capital spending budget by 14 percent to $18
billion.
For AT&T to keep up with its network expansion in the U.S.,
continue paying shareholders the 10th highest dividend yield in
the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index and build businesses in growth
markets, it will need more money. While borrowing is an option,
another deal would only exacerbate the situation, putting
further pressure on its credit standing.
No Need
AT&T’s Stephenson has said that the timing and structure of
America Movil’s breakup isn’t clear yet and that his phone
company would be just fine without Slim’s assets.
“We believe we have found a path here that gets us a very
nice, scalable growth platform without the America Movil
assets,” Stephenson said at an investor conference last month.
“If things materialize over time and those look attractive,
you’d obviously have to look at them. But we really don’t need
the America Movil assets to be successful.”
A deal to hive off some of America Movil’s assets was
always going to be a long, complicated process, according to Jim
Kahan, a former AT&T strategy chief.
“Divestitures like this aren’t a simple thing to do,”
said Kahan, a senior adviser with TAP Advisors LLC, a boutique
investment-banking firm. “My guess is once the Iusacell deal
closes, AT&T is going to to want to start building that
business. My gut reaction is that they can start even without
America Movil.”
Breathing Room
AT&T has some breathing room. It’s under no great pressure
to purchase America Movil’s assets, said Dave Novosel, an
analyst at Gimme Credit LLC.
“I don’t think there are a lot of players that are in a
position to buy the America Movil assets, so I don’t think AT&T
has much competition,” Novosel said in a phone interview.
“Meanwhile, AT&T already has two acquisitions going at the same
time, so there’s reason to think they have the flexibility to
wait.”
For Related News and Information:
AT&T CEO Says Doesn’t Need America Movil’s Assets in Mexico
America Movil Falls as AT&T’s Mexican Deal Spurs Competition
AT&T Faces Off Against Former Ally Slim With Second Mexico Deal
Bloomberg Intelligence, North American telecom: BI TELCN <GO>
Real M&A stories: NI REALMNA <GO>
Top deal stories: DTOP <GO>
America Movil is up 4.9 percent this year as of yesterday.
--With assistance from Carlos Manuel Rodriguez in Mexico City,
Jeffrey McCracken in New York and Grace Huang in Tokyo.
To contact the reporters on this story:
Scott Moritz in New York at +1-212-617-5460 or
smoritz6@bloomberg.net;
Patricia Laya in Mexico City at +52-55-5242-9262 or
playa2@bloomberg.net
To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Sarah Rabil at +1-212-617-5992 or
srabil@bloomberg.net;
Beth Williams at +1-212-617-2307 or
bewilliams@bloomberg.net
Beth Williams
2014-12-05 21:44:41.156 GMT
(For a Real M&A column news alert: SALT REALMNA <GO>.)
By Scott Moritz and Patricia Laya
Dec. 5 (Bloomberg) -- AT&T Inc. has no reason to hurry into
any more deals in Mexico. In fact, the more patiently the U.S.
phone company waits, the better.
AT&T has made two acquisitions this year in its expansion
into Mexico -- neither with billionaire Carlos Slim, who
dominates the country’s communications industry. Instead, AT&T
has committed more than $50 billion to buying Mexican wireless
carrier Grupo Iusacell SA and DirecTV, which has a stake in
satellite-TV service Sky Mexico.
That’s left Slim, a former ally of AT&T, in limbo because
he needs to divest a large portion of America Movil SAB’s assets
in Mexico to reduce its market share below 50 percent and avoid
profit-reducing penalties. AT&T may be Slim’s best hope for a
buyer as the Dallas-based company is trying to bundle wireless,
TV and broadband services south of the U.S. border. The catch is
that the Iusacell business AT&T is buying benefits as long as
America Movil faces penalties. Dragging out that punishment also
may make for a tougher -- and maybe cheaper -- sale for Slim.
“AT&T is in no rush to buy America Movil’s assets in the
short term,” Gregorio Tomassi, an analyst at Banco Itau BBA,
said in a phone interview from Mexico City. “America Movil is
seeing the situation is becoming more difficult than they had
initially thought.”
SoftBank Out
America Movil originally contacted potential suitors
including AT&T, SoftBank Corp. and China Mobile Ltd. as it
prepared to sell landline and wireless assets worth about $17.5
billion, people with knowledge of the matter said in September.
Since then, Tokyo-based SoftBank has dropped out of the process,
according to other people familiar with the matter, who asked
not to be named because the decision was private.
Mariko Osada, a spokeswoman for SoftBank, declined to
comment, as did a press official for America Movil, which has a
market value of $77 billion. Fletcher Cook, an AT&T spokesman,
declined to comment on the company’s expansion strategy in
Mexico.
Today, AT&T shares rose less than 1 percent to $33.94.
AT&T’s presence in Mexico since announcing the purchase of
Iusacell on Nov. 7 reduces the appetite of other foreign buyers
to enter the market and improves AT&T’s negotiating power with
America Movil, Tomassi said.
“AT&T has the clearest way to create synergies,” Tomassi
said. “No other operator interested in coming has the level of
synergies, cross-border or inside of Mexico, as AT&T.”
AT&T Expansion
The $176 billion U.S. phone giant had been searching for
new businesses and new regions for expansion amid increased
competition and slowing wireless growth at home. Chief Executive
Officer Randall Stephenson initially set his sights on Europe
but shifted back to the Americas after Comcast Corp. announced
plans to buy Time Warner Cable Inc.
AT&T agreed to pay $48.5 billion for DirecTV, including its
Latin American business, expanding outside the U.S. for the
first time in a decade. It then agreed to buy Iusacell, Mexico’s
third-largest wireless carrier, for an equity value of $1.8
billion.
Mexico helped open the door to competitors earlier this
year when it signed a telecommunications overhaul into law. The
new rules force America Movil, which controls seven out of 10
mobile-phone users in the country, to cut its fees and share
infrastructure with its competitors.
Even without the legislation, Mexico’s proximity, economic
growth potential and increasing population make it a prime
market for AT&T to expand its TV, wireless and Internet service
business.
Balance Sheet
AT&T has the means to buy America Movil’s assets and extend
its reach further in Mexico. Holding off on another deal, for
now at least, might be better for its balance sheet.
Its shopping cart is already filling fast. On top of
DirecTV and Iusacell, AT&T is one of the top bidders in the
Federal Communications Commission’s airwave auction, which has
already surpassed $41 billion. Meantime, its A credit rating has
been in jeopardy since May when Fitch Ratings put it under
review for downgrade after the DirecTV deal was announced.
AT&T had about $2.5 billion in cash and cash equivalents as
of September and has been trimming costs and selling assets this
year. Last month, the phone company said it was cutting its
projected 2015 capital spending budget by 14 percent to $18
billion.
For AT&T to keep up with its network expansion in the U.S.,
continue paying shareholders the 10th highest dividend yield in
the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index and build businesses in growth
markets, it will need more money. While borrowing is an option,
another deal would only exacerbate the situation, putting
further pressure on its credit standing.
No Need
AT&T’s Stephenson has said that the timing and structure of
America Movil’s breakup isn’t clear yet and that his phone
company would be just fine without Slim’s assets.
“We believe we have found a path here that gets us a very
nice, scalable growth platform without the America Movil
assets,” Stephenson said at an investor conference last month.
“If things materialize over time and those look attractive,
you’d obviously have to look at them. But we really don’t need
the America Movil assets to be successful.”
A deal to hive off some of America Movil’s assets was
always going to be a long, complicated process, according to Jim
Kahan, a former AT&T strategy chief.
“Divestitures like this aren’t a simple thing to do,”
said Kahan, a senior adviser with TAP Advisors LLC, a boutique
investment-banking firm. “My guess is once the Iusacell deal
closes, AT&T is going to to want to start building that
business. My gut reaction is that they can start even without
America Movil.”
Breathing Room
AT&T has some breathing room. It’s under no great pressure
to purchase America Movil’s assets, said Dave Novosel, an
analyst at Gimme Credit LLC.
“I don’t think there are a lot of players that are in a
position to buy the America Movil assets, so I don’t think AT&T
has much competition,” Novosel said in a phone interview.
“Meanwhile, AT&T already has two acquisitions going at the same
time, so there’s reason to think they have the flexibility to
wait.”
For Related News and Information:
AT&T CEO Says Doesn’t Need America Movil’s Assets in Mexico
America Movil Falls as AT&T’s Mexican Deal Spurs Competition
AT&T Faces Off Against Former Ally Slim With Second Mexico Deal
Bloomberg Intelligence, North American telecom: BI TELCN <GO>
Real M&A stories: NI REALMNA <GO>
Top deal stories: DTOP <GO>
America Movil is up 4.9 percent this year as of yesterday.
--With assistance from Carlos Manuel Rodriguez in Mexico City,
Jeffrey McCracken in New York and Grace Huang in Tokyo.
To contact the reporters on this story:
Scott Moritz in New York at +1-212-617-5460 or
smoritz6@bloomberg.net;
Patricia Laya in Mexico City at +52-55-5242-9262 or
playa2@bloomberg.net
To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Sarah Rabil at +1-212-617-5992 or
srabil@bloomberg.net;
Beth Williams at +1-212-617-2307 or
bewilliams@bloomberg.net
Beth Williams